6 ms·
I think we tend to underestimate what ancient technology could produce because we forget that in ancient times they often operated on longer timescales than we
by tzs 5y ago
I think we tend to underestimate what ancient technology could produce because we forget that in ancient times they often operated on longer timescales than we do.
With our technology for example we could make all the parts for the Antikythera mechanism in a short time. The ancient Greeks definitely had no technology that would have allowed them to do that, so we see the existence of the Antikythera mechanism as a great mystery.
But I don't see any reason to believe that the Greeks built it in a short time. It could easily be the lifework of the builder, or even the lifework of successive generations of a family of builders.
If you need to make a very precise gear in a day you need our technology. If you need to make a very precise gear in 50 years you just need someone with an abrasive that is harder than the material you are making the gear from.
- colordrops 5y agoSame goes for the perfectly fitted stones in Inkan walls in Peru. They weren't built by aliens or telekinesis, but rather unoccupied workers that rubbed on the stones all day for decades. There is plenty of evidence that these walls and cities were never in a "finished" state, but always in progress, with partially complete stones and scattered pieces not yet near the wall in many sites.
- beamatronic 5y agoWhat's remarkable to me is to think about the infrastructure that must have existed, even to support this basic labor. All these stones had to get quarried and moved around. All these workers had to be fed, housed, and clothed. Whatever tools and simple machines they used, would have required constant maintenance.
- Gravityloss 5y agoThen there are projects like Colosseum which took only 7-8 years to build. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colosseum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colosseum or Parthenon that took 9 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parthenon
- JJMcJ 5y agoRecently a group finished a stone block of the size in the Egyptian pyramids in just a few days. Another group hauled a Stonehenge sized block of stone from area the stones came from to the site of Stonehenge in about two weeks. Estimate is that, using existing tools of the time, 100 stonemasons could have done the Sphinx in about five years. And we have medieval and classical buildings in Europe where the building methods are fully known and there were no flying saucers or other magical methods.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoThere is also this implicit form of -ism built into it, in that certain groups of people were "obviously" less intelligent so it is unlikely they could ever build something magnificent or intellectually obscure. Whether it is a belief that aliens must have built Mayan or Egyptian Pyramids because of a bias that they were dumb savages, or whether it is dismissal of alternate forms of successful government and social organization in "uncultured" parts of the world. It is easier to assume something like "this mechanism shouldn't exist" if you (general "you") think a group of people are already beneath you due to your implicit biases.
- PostOnce 5y agonobody thinks Einstein was beneath us because he didn't have an iPhone if something "shouldn't exist" in a time period it has nothing to do with judging those people as inferiors, its simply the timeline of the development of technology (or our misconception thereof)
- darcys22 5y agoEinstein is a bad example cause he was very recent also.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoFor those of us who study culture, this is absolutely a thing. Its called pseudoarchaeology and it has always been very popular with White Supremacists. https://entangledstates.org/2021/10/05/the-connection-between-ancient-aliens-and-white-supremacy/ https://entangledstates.org/2021/10/05/the-connection-betwee... https://www.sapiens.org/archaeology/pseudoarchaeology-racism/ https://www.sapiens.org/archaeology/pseudoarchaeology-racism... https://hyperallergic.com/470795/pseudoarchaeology-and-the-racism-behind-ancient-aliens/ https://hyperallergic.com/470795/pseudoarchaeology-and-the-r... https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.364.6436.110 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.364.6436.110 Also, Even today white supremacists think Einstein was a fraud: https://christiansfortruth.com/albert-einstein-plagiarist-and-fraud/ https://christiansfortruth.com/albert-einstein-plagiarist-an... But that is harder to believe than "Dumb Egyptians couldn't make pyramids, so aliens did it..."
- bsder 5y ago> The ancient Greeks definitely had no technology that would have allowed them to do that Sure they did. Bronze is not that hard to work with. Simple silica (sand) abrasives cut through it quite well. Lapping makes things nice and flat. Accuracy is defined by your skill with tools. Hand sheet metal layout is a real skill even in the modern world: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DypIDbAVTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DypIDbAVTc
- anyfoo 5y agoThat some things in history took the span of multiple generations to finish was quite the revelation to me. The Cologne Cathedral took over 600 years to finish. As another example, this amusing video [1] tells the story of how King Louis XIV wanted a map of the entirety of his kingdom from Cassini, and how it was apparently Cassini's great grandson (4 generations over 120 years) who finally concluded the project. For some generations in the middle of such projects, I can imagine that their huge undertaking is just "something they do", essentially just their job, and from their point of view it has always been there, and will always be there to the extent of their lifetime. Do we still have anything like this?
- not-my-account 5y agoI am guessing that [1] pointed to this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTyX_EJQOIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTyX_EJQOIU I don't see the reference.
- anyfoo 5y agoIndeed, thanks. I went hunting for the video, but then forgot to paste it in (and am long past the edit window). :/
- not-my-account 5y agoHaha they’re classic!
- masklinn 5y ago> Do we still have anything like this? There are multi-generational scientific experiments e.g. the pitch drop or (hopefully) LTEE. Most significant archeological sites are multi-generational as well though I don’t know if we can describe them as a single work. One thing that’ll be interesting if we actually manage more than one generation is the software projects, the early luminaries have been passing for a while, the early architects of still extant software projects are going to start retiring or (sadly) passing en masse pretty soon. I don’t look forward to the obituary of donald knuth but I do wonder how tex and metafont will carry on.
- gh0std3v 5y agoI agree. To me, the ancient Greeks were an extremely advanced civilization and we don't often comprehend quite how rich their intellectual culture was. It turns out that Archimedes had actually discovered some of the foundational principles of integral calculus centuries before Newton or Leibniz even considered it [1]. In fact, Eudoxus — another Greek mathematician — had created a "method of exhaustion" which was essentially an informal, geometric method for computing limits (though he tried to make it as rigorous as possible) [2]. And if they don't impress you, then Euclid on his own is an extraordinary mathematician. The Elements is a modern mathematical marvel, with all of its theorems on foundational geometry and algebra stemming from 5 axioms. Astronomy was a critical part of many ancient cultures, from the Aztecs to the Indians (and of course, the Greeks). After some pondering, it makes sense why they would invest so much time, energy, and innovative zeal into creating a device as intricate as the Antikythera. I wonder how many other inventions and revolutionary ideas created by ancient cultures have been lost to time. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Method_of_Mechanical_Theorems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Method_of_Mechanical_Theor... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_exhaustion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Method_of_exhaustion