17 ms·
I suspect Assange doesn't regret this. I kind of get the impression that becoming a martyr was a sacrifice he was prepared to make if he managed to rip off the
by pydry 5y ago
I suspect Assange doesn't regret this.
I kind of get the impression that becoming a martyr was a sacrifice he was prepared to make if he managed to rip off the mask and expose the unbridled imperialist evil lurking underneath the "civilized press conference veneer" presented by the US government.
- mrsuprawsm 5y agoIt's a bit of a sad sacrifice, though. Nothing (significant) has changed about the US's imperialism as a result of his disclosures, it's just mildly more acknowledged.
- goodpoint 5y ago> mildly more acknowledged This is already a very big achievement for just one individual. How many people, activist or not, have been killed without anybody noticing?
- h0l0cube 5y agoMuch was made of upholding the promise to withdraw troops from the Middle East in the last US election. You can bet Collateral Murder and a number of other Wikileaks publications helped sway public opinion of the US military presence in the Middle East
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- user3939382 5y agoThe sad part is how few people even know what he published, especially juxtaposed with his sacrifice. If I go talk to the average person about Snowden or Assange they know little to nothing about what they revealed.
- enriquto 5y ago> If I go talk to the average person about Snowden or Assange they know little to nothing about what they revealed. You are doing good, then. Need to keep talking to more people!
- hellojesus 5y agoI agree, but to me it's troubling so many people simply don't care. Every time I try to talk to my wife about what the government's doing/has done, she stops me and says, "I really don't care. So long as I can keep living my life without interference, why would I care?" This also happens when I try to explain basic economics to her. I find most people I talk to simply don't care so long as they get to enjoy living their dreamy lives.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pydry 5y agoI think he probably had more of an effect than is obvious. Activism raises the political price to governments of making bad decisions. When the powerful change their position as a result of activism, they always try conceal it - the effect is far in excess of what they let on. In that light, I always found this story of the 6 scared, cold, humiliated and alone mothers of soldiers protesting outside the White House preventing nuclear war with Vietnam somewhat inspiring. https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/johann-hari/johann-hari-protest-works-just-look-at-the-proof-2119310.html https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/commentators/johann-har... (The connection is tenuous, but it's not completely unreasonable.)
- zepto 5y agoIn assange’e case, the opposite is true. They were avoiding paying the cost before his leaks. Now the reputational damage is done and so there is less for them to avoid.
- sharikous 5y agoIt very much depends on the context. In this particular case the US government managed to establish a deterrence too my making him an example. So I would say the effect is actually in the other direction. That is less activism of that type, not more. And the connection is not only tenuous. You are making a very general mild claim based on scant evidence. Your consideration is valid but very weak.
- Retric 5y agoActivism isn’t the point. Yes, governments make it hard and will go so far as to actually kill people. It’s still a moderating influence and a feedback mechanism before civil war. I may not agree with them or even care about the issue, but I still respect the sacrifice.
- lenkite 5y agoMost left journalists were dancing in joy when Assange got arrested. They never forgave him for exposing the Clinton emails and ensured he was heavily character assassinated over the next several years. He also became a victim of the #MeToo movement at its height. He was openly called evil/narcissist/etc in many "opinion" pieces. All the other important stuff he revealed never got the level of attention it deserved.
- elif 5y agoYep. 100% this. After 2016, i went from getting "oh you radical crazy commie" looks wearing a wikileaks shirt to immediately "oh you're a republican, let me guess you listen to alex jones and joe rogan?"
- alexvoda 5y agoI believe somewhere in here lies a fundamental problem with today's society. We have reached an absurd level of polarization. Any opinion you hold that is in contradiction with someone else's opinion, qualifies you for membership of the opposing camp. We should really work on depolarisation.
- user743 5y agoThe establishment is the enemy, not each other. Also, I'm not sure where this "keep friends and family separate from business" idealogy came from, but business is just organizing production. If we're not going to try to hold those keys with our friends and family, then elites will hold them for us. Side note-no actual progress can come until there is sound money again.
- TakuYam 5y ago> The establishment is the enemy, not each other. The problem with the premise that the establishment is a lot like The Matrix. Some people are so hopelessly enamoured with the establishment that they will do whatever it takes to defend it.
- hota_mazi 5y agoYou're forgetting he tried to reach asylum but was stopped midway, and while he was stuck in limbo, he applied for multiple asylums, all of which were rejected. Not really the mark of someone who wanted to be a martyr as opposed to someone like Navalny, for example. More an indication of someone who didn't really know what he's doing and became an accidental but very effective Russian agent who ended up being a major contributor to shaking the very foundations of democracy in America.
- chx 5y agoThis is what so many people forget -- he almost surely (but frankly, even the contrary wouldn't surprise me any more) didn't start out as a Russian agent but most certainly became one.
- mariusor 5y agoEven if that was the case at any point, I doubt that currently he's still willing to be a martyr. He now has children and a partner that I imagine he'd like to spend time with.
- vanusa 5y agoWhat matters here is rule of law (and the fact that we live in a time where it is being increasingly eroded) - not Assange's internal psychological machinations.
- shadowgovt 5y agoRule of law is being followed. A lower court judge ruled that there was a risk that Assange's well-being could not be safeguarded in the American system. A higher court judge reversed that ruling on assurances from the US that his well-being would be guarded. Now they have an opportunity to an appeal to a still-higher UK Court. What's inconvenient here is that the rule of law is operating in the context that the US and UK are allies and therefore take each other's statements on good faith. The United States assures he will be protected, they are not an enemy nation, and there are extradition treaties between the US and the UK. Unless the UK has some kind of carve-out for countries with bad track records of keeping their word, that might be sufficient to satisfy the rule of law.
- vanusa 5y agoIt is perfectly fine to debate the prudence, or lack thereof, of the High Court's decision. My point is that, in this context, speculations as to whether Assange secretly desired this outcome, due to some supposed martyr complex ... are plainly irrelevant.
- jollybean 5y ago"he managed to rip off the mask and expose the unbridled imperialist evil lurking" That's a bit absurd given showed the total opposite: Gigabytes of diplomatic cables of highly sensitive data revealed a US Diplomatic Corps trying to do a decent job in a world rife with ugly corruption. The 'Arab Street' saw the information and they saw the US trying to assuage and nudge brutally corrupt leaders. The cables didn't unite Arabs against the US - they exposed the ruthless corruption of their own governments and 'united' them against their own governments. I was in Tunisia near the time of the revolts and I can tell you the thing that pissed them off the most was probably the fact that their disgraced PM had Canadian citizenship (i.e. citizen of convenience, as many do) and simply flew to Montreal to enjoy Canadian Constitutional protections and avoid prosecution. It's shocking that someone could read about Arab governments doing 'very bad things', the US government trying to stop them, and then come away with the notion that the US is the bad actor. It speaks to some kind of deeply held ideology or perspective that can make facts that point one way, seem like they point in the other direction. Assange will have to face trial given the fact that he may have explicitly helped Manning break into systems of National Security, which is definitely illegal. I don't think he did, but there's been some evidence made public that indicates that it's possible. Soon we'll have a court case and see the evidence.
- pydry 5y ago>The cables didn't unite Arabs against the US - they exposed the ruthless corruption of their own governments I'm sensing that you believe that this is something you think that should have been concealed from them for their own good. >It's shocking that someone could read about Arab governments doing 'very bad things', the US government trying to stop them, and then come away with the notion that the US is the bad actor. Collateral murder is mostly what people are condemning. Also what this extradition was all about. It's weird that you seem to believe that the war crimes are not relevant to the discussion about whether the US is "the bad actor". Well, perhaps not that weird. Your reply suggests that you may have been part of the institution that committed and covered up the war crimes (unless you were in tunisia for a different reason). >Assange will have to face trial given the fact that he may have explicitly helped Manning break into systems of National Security, which is definitely illegal. Oh yes. Exposing US war crimes IS definitely illegal - more illegal than committing them, apparently. Just like Rosa Parks sitting at the back of a bus - that was illegal too.
- brandelune 5y agoI suspect Assange does not want to be tortured and murdered and thus does not want this. Are you insane ?
- zepto 5y agoI doubt the US intends to murder him.
- antihero 5y agoExcept the time they were plotting to murder him, of course.
- zepto 5y agoYes, when he was a fugitive potentially in possession of state secrets. I’m not saying it’s ok - just that now he’s in custody it’s a little different.
- mmcwilliams 5y agoIt might be the case right now but it came out earlier this year that the CIA was entertaining this idea in 2017. This [0] appears to be the originating story and there are corroborating accounts in many other outlets. [0] https://news.yahoo.com/kidnapping-assassination-and-a-london-shoot-out-inside-the-ci-as-secret-war-plans-against-wiki-leaks-090057786.html https://news.yahoo.com/kidnapping-assassination-and-a-london...
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It might be the case right now but it came out earlier this year that the CIA was entertaining this idea in 2017. CIA, DoD, and lots of agencies “entertain” lots of ideas, and even develop plans, for lots of things that never get close to being policy.
- kdomanski 5y ago
- shadowgovt 5y agoIf he was willing to be a martyr, he would not have holed up in an embassy seeking asylum for years.
- hekette 5y agoWilling to be a martyr does not mean that he wouldn't try to avoid it.
- dane-pgp 5y agoIt's remarkable how casually people demand sacrifices of others as a condition for taking their activism seriously. There's basically no limit to how much someone can demand, e.g. "Well, if he was really committed to transparency, he would have tried breaking into the White House with a camera", or "If he was really prepared to risk dying to bring these leaks to people's attention, he should have self-immolated in front of the US embassy". Personally, the metric I use is, if someone has achieved more for a good cause than me, and suffered more for it than I would, then they are a martyr for that cause and deserve my respect.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoMy sense, and I don't think it is a popular opinion on HN, was that Assange became, perhaps unwittingly, a pawn of Russia. Selectively releasing documents, which is how I see it, doesn't show an even hand of justice exposing "the unbridled imperialist evil". I'm no fan of Assange. But I also have not read a lot about Assange so I may be ignorant.
- fredestine 5y agoyeah, a pawn of russia. just like trump. yet it is biden who said yes to the biggest russian infrastructure project for germany with the pipeline. the narrative of being a russian pawn doesnt work. everyone loved assange until he underlined the oblivious corruption of clinton and hence contributed to make her loose rightfully so the election. I am no trump fan and I am for a non partisan vision of the world. a vision where freedom means telling the truth even if it hurts yourself or your political leaders. Assange is a victim of usa and it is sad to bring russia to the equation
- willis936 5y agoEveryone loved Assange until he [entered politics, played favorites with information disclosure, and demonstrated that he is more mercenary than martyr]. I wonder why.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoPutin would assassinate him if he exposed too much. That's incentive enough to cater to Russian interests.