5 ms·
>Utility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluativ
by coldtea 5y ago
>Utility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluative strategies and no gaps in rationality, exists.
It's probably more like arguing that leprechauns don't exist.
The burden of proof [for its existance] is on those making up those "fundamental concepts in decision theory". I won't be taking it for granted just because they came up with it.
In any case, I'm not saying utility can't exist. I'm saying some universal utility can't exist, or if you wish: sorry, guys, you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much.
>So in most reasonable cases the mathematical axioms needed for utility to be defined exist in a reasonable way, allowing for comparison through a formalized utility function.
If we could have a "formalized utility function" for "most reasonable cases" we'd hardly have different morals, political parties, and so on...
It's mostly irrelevant (trivial) cases that have formalized utility functions. Everything else is political, that is up for debate based on interests, preferences, morals, and so on -- and especially based on idiosyncrasy.
Even maximing one's life/health is not some constant. Many prefer to smoke, drink, eat, knowing fully well it might have them, because their utility function favors enjoyment over life span. Others might sacrifice their life for some cause or another.
- tomrod 5y agoAnd yet, the theory of utility works well under extensions of bounded rationality, with full acknowledgement of time inconsistent preferences. Utimately utility is a simplifying model of human behavior. > we'd hardly have different morals, political parties, and so on. This touches on where preferences come from, which utility theory is mainly silent on.
- bluGill 5y ago> you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much You have now stated that utility exists. At no place should any argument depend on some universal utility function that applies to everyone. The idea of a universal utility function is a useful simplification for some beginner classes, but quickly becomes useless for anything in the real world. In fact if there were a universal utility function(s?) economics wouldn't be hard to study, just a simple optimization problem that businesses would use. All that we need is for everyone to assign utility in some way. It doesn't matter if your function omits critical factors, applies the wrong weighting, or otherwise is a decision you come to regret. (note that this hindsight might be wrong because you don't really know what your regrets would be had you made the other decision) All that matters is at some point you weight all the factors you consider important and make a decision based on them. You can come up with a complex formula to put numbers to it, or just go with a "gut feeling" (in many cases others are involved - perhaps a spouse). Regardless you have made a utility function for your situation.
- nemetroid 5y ago> You have now stated that utility exists. Only in the context of a single person. The argument presented in the article, as well as ideas like the "utility monster" are based on the idea that the utility scales of different persons are comparable. This is not the same thing as a universal utility function, but almost as outlandish.
- jstummbillig 5y ago> The argument presented in the article, as well as ideas like the "utility monster" are based on the idea that the utility scales of different persons are comparable. The article makes no implicit or explicit statement about how one defines a/the utility function, but I see no reason to believe the author thinks it's a universal function.
- nemetroid 5y agoAs indicated in the sentence directly following your quote.
- chii 5y ago> utility scales of different persons are comparable. but a decision is only made by one person, so only that person's utility function matters. A different person, using their own utility function, would come to a different conclusion and make a different choice. So while there's no universal utility function, it doesn't matter as long as the decision maker's utility function exists (and it does, by tautological argument). In the article, the utility values of 80 and 40 for the boys are the outcome of the parent's utility function. The boys don't get a choice, and so their utility functions don't matter.
- nemetroid 5y agoThat's fair. The article uses phrasing like "the disabled boy has a total utility of 40", suggesting that the utility is an attribute of the boy, but I guess it would become wordy and repetitive to phrase it any other way.
- guerrilla 5y ago> The burden of proof [for its existance] is on those making up those "fundamental concepts in decision theory". I won't be taking it for granted just because they came up with it. What? It's trivial. People want things. Things that satisfy wants have utility. You can just look this up. It's pretty basic to modern economics and philosophy.[1] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility
- samhw 5y agoYou're just defining satisfaction of wants as utility. "Things that satisfy wants have utility" is a statement of a definition, not a synthetic claim. There are plenty of measures of utility other than hedonic ones (or volitional ones, or whatever exactly your definition is specifying).
- guerrilla 5y agoYes, because that is what's meant by the word in this context.
- samhw 5y agoI'm aware, but my point is that you're not making a synthetic claim - you're not proving the (axiological) meaningfulness of a concept. You're just saying "I use this word 'utility' to describe the satisfaction of wants". It doesn't really answer any of the questions that were posed, about how you can measure and compare the 'want-satisfying-ness' of different things. How do you measure the degree of want? How do you measure the degree to which a want is satisfied? How do you compare those across human beings? If by 'trivial' in your original comment you meant 'trivial' in the technical sense[0], then I'd agree with that. "I define 'utility' as 'satisfaction of wants'" is a statement that neither predicates nor proves anything of the world. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triviality_(mathematics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triviality_(mathematics)
- guerrilla 5y agoIt does answer the questions by reformulating them in exactly the way you did, which immediately highlights the GPs confusion: They somehow missed the subjective and relative aspects of the concept as it is used. There is no objective and absolute measure of want-satisfying-ness (or whatever). > It's probably more like arguing that leprechauns don't exist. > In any case, I'm not saying utility can't exist. I'm saying some universal utility can't exist, or if you wish: sorry, guys, you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much. This is what I'm responding to.
- mcguire 5y ago"In any case, I'm not saying utility can't exist. I'm saying some universal utility can't exist, or if you wish: sorry, guys, you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much." The article does not posit a "universal utility function", nor does it require determining anyone's individual utility function. It merely requires that utility functions exist and that a comparison of the resulting utility is meaningful. "If we could have a "formalized utility function" for "most reasonable cases" we'd hardly have different morals, political parties, and so on..." Only if you have a universal utility function. Which you are the only one proposing.