5 ms·
Utility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluative
by tomrod 5y ago
Utility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluative strategies and no gaps in rationality, exists.
People can compare their current situations to relative improvement, and often those are transitive (though not always). So in most reasonable cases the mathematical axioms needed for utility to be defined exist in a reasonable way, allowing for comparison through a formalized utility function.
One can certainly mathurbate themselves with utility, and many do, but ultimately utility is a discussion to simplify communication (instead of primitives) about why people make preditible choices. It extends pretty quickly to revealed preferences.
Of course, asking where preferences come from in the first place is a third rail.
- netcan 5y agoI disagree. OP is correct. Utility is a rhetorical construct. Sometimes it works well for describing morality, decisions, etc. Sometimes it's crammed in. Using it to describe the two sons decisions is cramming it in.
- tomrod 5y ago> Utility is a rhetorical construct It's a mathematical construct to show ranking of points in a topological space. With two simple axioms, comparability and transitivity, it is fairly well defined mathematically, though it typically enters the extrapolation zone at extremes.
- emn13 5y agoBut if the definition is barely more fleshed out than "some cost function", then the difference between utility, priority and equality as discussed in the article collapse; they're all the same thing. Cost functions, aka: utility.
- tomrod 5y agoCost functions are typically the dual for utility maximization under cost constraints. You are correct in that they are usually mathematically equivalent.
- emn13 5y agoYeah, I was struggling the find the best terminology for that, but given the ambiguity of the term "utility" in this context I though it better to avoid that ;-).
- geysersam 5y agoI'm certain nobody argues with you on that point. The question is: what does the fact that numbers can be ordered entail for ethics?
- mlac 5y agoI’ve always heard utility in the context of a utility function. Basically: f(u) = Wx*x + … + Wz*z, where x and z are variables that are impacted by decisions and constraints. Each variable is weighted for importance by the person / group using the utility function. So for a home buyer needing to get to a city, the utility of the house improves as the location to the city gets better, subject to the constraint that it’s not in the river. A home buyer utility function might also weight cost, neighbors, amenities, square footage, local pollution, safety, and any other meaningful variable for the buyer. Turning this into a quantitative formula can be cramming it in and quite hand-wavy, but ultimately it’s up to the person optimizing for their own utility to put in the variables and weights. These will be shifted by the person’s moral code (e.g. A Jewish person may highly value living in the city’s Eruv). On a political note, big government supporters believe the federal government can define a utility function for the country that is best for the greater good. People who believe in smaller federal government and governing at the local level believe the utility functions should be defined at the individual level if possible - subject to the constraints one does not infringe on others’ rights. There are benefits to both sides (some things we can’t achieve if everyone acts independently, some things create externalities, some things have too many edge cases and unintended consequences). I think the extreme of a shared utility function is communism, with an idea of central planning.
- tomrod 5y agoIf the math of utility is interesting to you, check out Hal Varian's microeconomics book (he is/was chief economist at Google) or the intro grad text for microeconometrics Mas-Collel, Winston, and Green. Utility theory's primitives are defined before the actual function. Social choice theory is covered in MWG -- arrow's impossibility theorem is absolutely fascinating! The field of mechanism design relies heavily on utility theory -- it's effectively the inverse of game theory, or, how to structure systems and incentives to get desired outcomes.
- coldtea 5y ago>Utility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluative strategies and no gaps in rationality, exists. It's probably more like arguing that leprechauns don't exist. The burden of proof [for its existance] is on those making up those "fundamental concepts in decision theory". I won't be taking it for granted just because they came up with it. In any case, I'm not saying utility can't exist. I'm saying some universal utility can't exist, or if you wish: sorry, guys, you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much. >So in most reasonable cases the mathematical axioms needed for utility to be defined exist in a reasonable way, allowing for comparison through a formalized utility function. If we could have a "formalized utility function" for "most reasonable cases" we'd hardly have different morals, political parties, and so on... It's mostly irrelevant (trivial) cases that have formalized utility functions. Everything else is political, that is up for debate based on interests, preferences, morals, and so on -- and especially based on idiosyncrasy. Even maximing one's life/health is not some constant. Many prefer to smoke, drink, eat, knowing fully well it might have them, because their utility function favors enjoyment over life span. Others might sacrifice their life for some cause or another.
- tomrod 5y agoAnd yet, the theory of utility works well under extensions of bounded rationality, with full acknowledgement of time inconsistent preferences. Utimately utility is a simplifying model of human behavior. > we'd hardly have different morals, political parties, and so on. This touches on where preferences come from, which utility theory is mainly silent on.
- bluGill 5y ago> you can't determine my utility function for me. I'll do it myself, thank you very much You have now stated that utility exists. At no place should any argument depend on some universal utility function that applies to everyone. The idea of a universal utility function is a useful simplification for some beginner classes, but quickly becomes useless for anything in the real world. In fact if there were a universal utility function(s?) economics wouldn't be hard to study, just a simple optimization problem that businesses would use. All that we need is for everyone to assign utility in some way. It doesn't matter if your function omits critical factors, applies the wrong weighting, or otherwise is a decision you come to regret. (note that this hindsight might be wrong because you don't really know what your regrets would be had you made the other decision) All that matters is at some point you weight all the factors you consider important and make a decision based on them. You can come up with a complex formula to put numbers to it, or just go with a "gut feeling" (in many cases others are involved - perhaps a spouse). Regardless you have made a utility function for your situation.
- emn13 5y agoRight, but if the essence of the question is by what function you measure utility, then the question as posed by the article is a moot point. utility, priority, equality - they're just slightly different cost functions for the utility. And it's not even the case that they're well-defined and clearly separated; some level of interpretation is going to be required regardless. For example, people routinely act as if money has a non-linear utility; we'll insure ourselves against stuff partially because being destitute is worse than the mere loss of money might suggest; i.e. each additional dollar is worth less. But exactly how you define those non-linear relationships, especially once you include stuff like happiness, health, and intend to aggregate over multiple individuals is clearly tricky, and it's not reasonable to expect any one simplified model to work well in all situations in reality. It's not even reasonable for that to be knowable or computable. So it's both perfectly reasonable to consider it ludicrous to label one such scenario as having "40" and "80" utility without having had the critical discussion of what that utility is measuring, while also conceding that the concept of utility is reasonable and... sometimes... enlightening.
- samhw 5y agoThanks, this was a really insightful comment (as someone who spent years of my life getting a graduate philosophy degree, before doing something more 'useful'). I think the concept of utility is clearly, uh, useful, and the reason that it's aversive to people is that they tend to bundle it up with a lot of the (sociologically, not logically) related views, which tend to be more problematic. Hedonic utilitarianism in particular turns a lot of people off, and partly for good reason. I'm deeply ambivalent about it, and I think the surrounding debates, and the assumed primacy of moral intuition in applied cases, are far harder and more open questions than most people reckon. But I can still see how examples like utility monsters, or gang rape being morally superior to garden-variety rape because there are more people to enjoy it, might make people feel like it's really on the wrong path.
- emn13 5y agoThose examples are hilariously egregious, yeah! It's slightly taboo in polite conversation to see increased utility there, yep. Thanks for the kind words, too.
- Helmut10001 5y agoUtility can be intrepret in many ways. Look at the social sciences and how they see minorities, e.g. disabled people. From the social scientist's view, one "utility" of these people is that they stabilize societies because they trigger empathy, which would otherwise be largely missing in a society that only aims for optimization. I want to emphasize that I find it generally humilitating to talk about utility and humans in one and the same sentence.
- michael-ax 5y agothink of it as a label for the process by which you decide to prioritize cleaning up different areas of your house -- and utility becomes a rational and humanizing thing. using it to prioritize your relations forces you to grapple with subjective and irrational things such as personal prefs, aspirations etc. so.. also rational and humanizing. this leaves using it to mess with others without them participating in weight-setting (democracy as a weight discovery mechanism?), that's where it gets messy. i fail to see where any of the three facets above make it humiliating to see where 'by priority' the most relative improvement can be made. i mean, this is all just fine talk about something innate to nature, no?
- dudeman13 5y agoI don't think GP is arguing that utility doesn't exist. I believe the GP is arguing that the OP is making arguments as if utility weren't subjective. If you can attach a number to decisions, you can just do the math. The thing is, attaching a number to make a non meta argument about decision making can be bollocks since the actual utility can be -9999999 for me or 9999999 for you. An utility function is a function of the decision making agent See the "independent from your moral values and sentiments, is inane" bit
- mudita 5y agoYes, utility as a concept in decision theory is great, but it’s not the same as the concept by the same name from utilitarianism. In my understanding, coldtea is doubting not decision theoretic utility functions, but utilities as they are used here. Most importantly a decision theoretic utility function is only defined up to any positive definite transformation. Inter-agent comparisons like "Imagine that the gifted boy has a total utility of 80, and the disabled boy has a total utility of 40” don’t make any sense in terms of decision theoretic utility functions.
- geysersam 5y agoIf someone has a special preference for egalitarian outcomes, this should be included in their utility functions. Telling someone their utility values for each of the choices is equivalent to telling them their preference. Asking for their preference afterwards is pointless, they have already been told their preference.