8 ms·
>There is also a catch in the hypothetical - let’s assume that the utility gain for the gifted son from living in the suburbs would be larger than the utility g
by coldtea 5y ago
>There is also a catch in the hypothetical - let’s assume that the utility gain for the gifted son from living in the suburbs would be larger than the utility gain for the disabled son from living in the city. A pure utilitarian, then, must choose the suburbs. Nagel’s view is this: if you say that you would live in the city for the sake of your disabled son, despite it being the case that moving to the city creates more utility in total, you are not a utilitarian (at least in all circumstances), but rather an egalitarian. You value the equality of the boys more than you do maximising the overall levels of well-being.
The very idea that there is some measusable "utility" to compare in the two cases, independent from your moral values and sentiments, is inane.
>Let’s introduce another scenario: Imagine that the gifted boy has a total utility of 80, and the disabled boy has a total utility of 40.
What that "utility" unit would measure?
Money they can make for you? Their pontential on their own? Their future contribution to society (in what terms? monetary? intellectual?)? Any other of 500 factors (perhaps combined)?
What if you don't want to help build a society that neglects the needs of disabled people because of their lesser contribution, and thus your utility function - ie. your desired goal maximization includes helping the disabled son?
In the examples, it is assumed that ulility == favoring gifted son, which means the utility function you'll use is taken for granted (and the whole thing is presented as only a matter of whether you value utility or not).
- ad404b8a372f2b9 5y agoI have ambiguous feelings about that example, not sure if I'm just being woke. It does feel a bit stereotypical to use a disabled child as the first example of someone with lower utility. You wouldn't think of starting an example with a gifted son and a black son.
- tomrod 5y agoUtility is a fundamental concept in decision theory. Arguing it cannot exist is the opposite extreme to arguing that homo economicus, with superhuman evaluative strategies and no gaps in rationality, exists. People can compare their current situations to relative improvement, and often those are transitive (though not always). So in most reasonable cases the mathematical axioms needed for utility to be defined exist in a reasonable way, allowing for comparison through a formalized utility function. One can certainly mathurbate themselves with utility, and many do, but ultimately utility is a discussion to simplify communication (instead of primitives) about why people make preditible choices. It extends pretty quickly to revealed preferences. Of course, asking where preferences come from in the first place is a third rail.
- netcan 5y agoI disagree. OP is correct. Utility is a rhetorical construct. Sometimes it works well for describing morality, decisions, etc. Sometimes it's crammed in. Using it to describe the two sons decisions is cramming it in.
- tomrod 5y ago> Utility is a rhetorical construct It's a mathematical construct to show ranking of points in a topological space. With two simple axioms, comparability and transitivity, it is fairly well defined mathematically, though it typically enters the extrapolation zone at extremes.
- emn13 5y agoBut if the definition is barely more fleshed out than "some cost function", then the difference between utility, priority and equality as discussed in the article collapse; they're all the same thing. Cost functions, aka: utility.
- tomrod 5y agoCost functions are typically the dual for utility maximization under cost constraints. You are correct in that they are usually mathematically equivalent.
- emn13 5y agoYeah, I was struggling the find the best terminology for that, but given the ambiguity of the term "utility" in this context I though it better to avoid that ;-).
- geysersam 5y agoI'm certain nobody argues with you on that point. The question is: what does the fact that numbers can be ordered entail for ethics?
- 5y ago
- JoBrad 5y agoIf the “utility score” was an overall rating for quality of life, it might change your view? Whether I assign a numerical or qualitative value is (arguably) arbitrary: as a parent, I’m still calculating which actions I should take based on some scoring mechanism.
- coldtea 5y ago>as a parent, I’m still calculating which actions I should take based on some scoring mechanism. The key is that you do it: it's not imposed upon you in the form of a normalized/universal scoring rule.
- GavinMcG 5y agoWhich the article doesn't argue against. Instead, it assumes for the sake of argument that you've made a utility calculation whereby favoring the disabled son is the worse choice.
- netcan 5y agoInane, perhaps. I don't think these ideas can be separated from their time and place. Like most philosophical/intellectual movements, a lot of what they are is objections, dialogue and alternatives to previous ideas or competing ideas. To us, 2-300 years later, we don't necessarily need a concrete basis for secular morality. We also don't expect morality to be reducible to a simle principle like F=ma. To them, they were in a period where medieval theology was being replaced by secular philosophy and science. They expected morality to be solved like Newton and Galileo had solved problems in their domains. We don't expect this anymore.
- mannykannot 5y ago> In the examples, it is assumed that utility == favoring gifted son This is a misreading of the article, which assumes utility in helping either son. The point is that while a 'pure' or 'fundamental' utilitarianism would simply say one should choose the option that maximizes the total of this utility, the priority view says there may be rational reasons for using a weighted sum of the utilities, or include additional terms. This article should be seen in the context of moral philosophy, which (naively) might be thought of as an attempt to find a rational basis for ethics, but more realistically should probably be seen as probing the extent to which one can be rational about such matters. > The whole thing is presented as only a matter of whether you value utility or not. That is because it is a continuation of a discussion over the utility of utilitarianism that has been going on, in some form, since antiquity, and which picked up pace after Bentham formulated his Principle of Utility [1]. There are quite often cases where one can have a somewhat objective utility function, and this comes up repeatedly in urban planning, as it is often the case that a project that is beneficial to the community as a whole often has a downside for some (usually those living near where the project will be sited.) A purely utilitarian view almost always favors putting the burden on those who have little left to lose, and the priority view says there can be a rational basis for choosing an alternative. Somewhat ironically, the priority view argues against what you seem to find objectionable in simple utilitarianism. Perhaps it is also worth pointing out that when utilitarianism was first proposed, it was rather radical; prior ethical notions were mostly about obeying your betters (on Earth and in Heaven.) [1] https://human.libretexts.org/Courses/Lumen_Learning/Book%3A_The_Originals%3A_Classic_Readings_in_Western_Philosophy_(Lumen)/06%3A_Ethics_and_Morality/06.5%3A_Jeremy_Bentham__On_the_Principle_of_Utility https://human.libretexts.org/Courses/Lumen_Learning/Book%3A_...
- tzs 5y agoWhen the article talks about utility in its examples, it is not talking about some universal objective utility that all would agree on. It is talking about the utility that the person making the decision assigns which will depend on their moral values and sentiments. > What if you don't want to help build a society that neglects the needs of disabled people because of their lesser contribution, and thus your utility function - ie. your desired goal maximization includes helping the disabled son? Then you'd have a case where utilitarianism and egalitarianism produce the same outcome which is great when you can achieve it, but not very useful in an article that is trying to talk about when utilitarianism and egalitarianism produce conflicting outcomes.
- geysersam 5y agoUtilitarianism can never be in conflict with your preferences whatever they may be. This is by definition. If the utility values would conflict with your preferences, then those were not the correct utility values to begin with.
- jstummbillig 5y ago> What that "utility" unit would measure? Well, that's up to you, is it not? Who else could determine what you value and to which degree?
- steve76 5y ago> The very idea that there is some measusable "utility" to compare in the two cases, independent from your moral values and sentiments, is inane. There's philosophical charity, in the sense of your ability to put aside your judgments to listen and gain knowledge. That can be measured. Simply ask "You know this?" and count how many no's. There's some things we will never know that are very important, like dying or being created. From those you can get to real altruism. Caring for others is the natural state of humanity and makes humans strong, nice and beautiful. Selfishness is unnatural, weak, hateful, and ugly. Whatever created you cared about you and helped you, gave you the capacity for joy and happiness. Sooner than you think you will be abandoned by everything and those will be taken away and you will be in need. It's better for you to help others than just helping yourself. Personal sacrifice is not needed. It's not okay to be hurt or be a victim. Interior motives are irrelevant. It's better if everyone in the world is cured than just you while everyone else dies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vannevar 5y agoI agree, i think it's far more likely that those favoring the disabled child are simply rejecting the artificial and abstract notion of utility described in the hypothetical, and going with their own experience. Which is that the real-world utility to the disabled child is in fact far higher. I don't think anyone could read that hypothetical (particularly in the age of the Internet) and believe that putting a gifted child in a city would be significantly harmful to them.
- michael-ax 5y agonow you're touching on the limits of knowledge of those making choices and might be tempted to rate them. that's out of scope for the deciders at that level, the parents in that story. ... the point is that they know the situation best. and that utility lets them quantify the subjective to test-run the rationalizations going into their decisions. e.g. "maximising sum(log(utility))" like the comment on the article said. the only thing strange here is that philosophy deals with qualitative, not just quantitative domains. thus they tell these stories. :)
- vannevar 5y agoTrue, but the parents in the story are imaginary---their decision-making is not being tested. Rather, it's the observer who is being tested. But the story is so contrary to experience that is does not do what the premise of the article suggests it does: distinguish observers that care more about equality than utility. Because the premise is flawed (ie, that this is a valid test), it tends to moot the rest of the article drawn from that premise.
- toast0 5y agoThe city vs suburb is just a lazy shorthand to setup the hypothetical. If the issue is transportation time to a hospital, you could live in a suburb near a hospital. Some cities have excellent schools and some cities have awful schools and the same for suburbs. To make my own lazy shorthand, would you consider it significantly harmful if a gifted child is placed in a classroom where everyone else is behind grade level and the instruction is paced accordingly vs a classroom where instruction is paced at grade level or perhaps at an accelerated pace? If that's not enough, what if it's a rougher school where physical altercations are the norm. Sure, these days, there's the internet, the magical cornucopia of knowledge, but it can be hard to get the motivation to use it. All that said, my personal utility function measures a lot more utility for independence than for education and what not. If a better situation for the disable child may result in more independence for the disabled child, the gifted child is just going to have to make the best of a situation that's been decided for someone else's best interest.
- skipants 5y agoIt's just a theoretical value that philosopher's use to avoid the subjectivity of utility when making an argument. They are well aware it's subjective, but the subjectivity of utility is agreed upon and not of interest in these thought experiments. When someone says, "if I had a million dollars, I would take a trip around the world!" you don't chastise them for not having a million dollars. Well, unless you're my mother ;P
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 5y agoYou can patch it back up by replacing utility with something specific, although at the cost of its mysterious air. Let's say that the smart kid will... cure cancer if he's in the suburbs, but become a drug kingpin if he grows up in the city.