13 ms·
If we take Bernstein at his word (and there's no reason not to), basically all the US media has secretly cooperated with the CIA. Is there any reason to think t
by bediger4000 5y ago
If we take Bernstein at his word (and there's no reason not to), basically all the US media has secretly cooperated with the CIA. Is there any reason to think this isn't going on right now? I mean, google "ken dilanian cia" for a good time. Then think: Dilanian is still a working journalist.
How is this congruent with a free press? Surely this willingness to cooperate with a spy agency that has done some very bad things over the years spills over to other areas. Am I supposed to believe that all these media cover current politics objectively, if they've enthusiastically cooperated with the CIA in the past?
- adolph 5y ago> Am I supposed to believe that all these media cover current politics objectively, if they've enthusiastically cooperated with the CIA in the past? Yes, that would be the point. Maybe more to the point: if you don't believe, you should believe the CIA has the power to make belief in other people. Moreover if you express non-belief you will be labeled a conspiracy theorist by society and shunned.
- Aperocky 5y ago> Am I supposed to believe that all these media cover current politics objectively LOL I don't need this article to tell me that, it's so blatantly obvious.
- bediger4000 5y agoYeah, me too, really. The media have a fairly conservative bias, despite all the Republican claims of "liberal bias". I thought this conservative bias came from media trying to keep Republicans from claiming "liberal bias", but now I'm wondering if the CIA has something to do with it.
- colpabar 5y ago> The media have a fairly conservative bias Can you explain what you mean by this, with some examples?
- boomboomsubban 5y agoAssuming you consider the antiwar stance "liberal," the clearest example of this I've seen is a study of the media stories leading up to the Iraq War. 71% of US sources were pro-war, 26% "neutral," and 3% antiwar. When "both sides" were presented, it was pro-war vs pro preparing more for the war. https://fair.org/extra/amplifying-officials-squelching-dissent/ https://fair.org/extra/amplifying-officials-squelching-disse...
- elzbardico 5y agoSo Biden and Hillary Clinton are Republicans? Because both of them were pretty enthusiastic about WMDs in Iraq
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThey're neo-conservatives, nobody was discussing political parties.
- colpabar 5y agoYes they were, the word "republicans" appears twice in the comment to which I replied.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoMy mistake. Nobody was discussing the media having a bias towards any political party, they were discussing the media having a conservative bias despite Republican's claim of a liberal bias. Like when the antiwar position gets 3% of the media coverage.
- bobthechef 5y ago
- specialist 5y agoCorporate media has an establishment bias. On balance, NY Times leans neither conservative nor progressive. But they are wholly committed defenders of the status quo. And if the status quo is Liberal, Neoliberal, War on Terror, or whatever, then so is NY Times. Most other medias fall within the Overton Window (boundaries for acceptible discourse) as defined by NY Times. Including explicitly partisan outlets like GOP.tv, OANN, breitbart, etc. -- Social media, on the other hand, has a troll bias. And given the quirks of human psyche, a bias towards fear and outrage, social media is best exploited by right wing actors. Not that left wing actors don't try. It's just not as effective, so left wing story lines have terrible traction.
- me_me_me 5y agoRelevant read: Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media Tl;dr Through subtle mechanisms, gov can promote preferred media outlets by giving them better/direct/scoops informations - resulting in better sales - resulting in better deals for ads - resulting in bigger profits. In turn, people in those media outlets are incentivised to shush descending voices/opinions by 'promoting' those into sport section or horoscope section. Its self selecting and self correcting mechanism.
- adolph 5y ago> Its self selecting and self correcting mechanism. Semantically: %/correcting/perpetuating/ Pedantically: %/Its/It's a/
- tempodox 5y agoYou overlooked one: s/descending/dissenting/
- imwillofficial 5y agoSelf correcting fits, as in the feedback mechanisms are arrayed in such a way that disobedience is punished without outside pressures. Simple loss of access to scoops cascades through the process until news company makes less money, so dissent would be swiftly taken care of.
- zionic 5y agoPerhaps “self corrupting mechanism” is a better term?
- herbstein 5y agoManufacturing Consent is such an interesting book. The framework of analysis Herman and Chomsky present is general enough that it, while approaching almost 40 years old, still very accurately seems to describe the current media landscape. Chomsky is a famous left-leaning anarchist, and I find it interesting that his analysis isn't "the media is too right-wing" or "the media is too left-wing". Instead, his analysis is primarily about how power begets power -- even at the level of the local paper. This[0] short 3-minute video does a fine job of letting him explain his position on media bias while not really going into the nitty gritty details. His books, however, do go into the nitty gritty details while still being relatively easy to read. For anyone interested in Chomsky I highly recommend "Understanding Power"[1] as the intro to his views on the world. It's not as detailed in every topic as many of his other books and is primarily conversational in style - owing to it being transcribed discussions with audience members after he has held a speech. [0]: https://youtu.be/x60pSXlwmNE https://youtu.be/x60pSXlwmNE [1]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/194805.Understanding_Power https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/194805.Understanding_Pow...
- theknocker 5y agoIt's not congruent with a free press and it undermines democracy. Otherwise they wouldn't be doing it.
- TechnoTimeStop 5y agoWait so an organization of the free worlds government wants to ensure media has context? WOW TOTALLY OVERKILL RIGHT? Better get back to murdering 60,000,000 people in China and disappearing anyone who disagrees.
- aww_dang 5y agoAs an example, Anderson Cooper of CNN proudly admits that he worked as an intern at the CIA. Do with that what you will. There's a prejudice to pejoratively dismiss these things out of hand as conspiracy theory. One could easily push back asking about naivete, but it isn't worth it. >"As a college student, I had a number of summer jobs and internships, including working at the CIA." >"Oh, yeah, in case you're interested, after I graduated college, I briefly worked as a waiter, but I decided not to make a career out of that job either." See also: "Operation Mockingbird" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird https://edition.cnn.com/CNN/Programs/anderson.cooper.360/blog/2006/09/my-summer-job-nearly-20-years-ago.html https://edition.cnn.com/CNN/Programs/anderson.cooper.360/blo...
- Victerius 5y agoAnd Princeton valedictorian and current professor of mathematics at Duke Lilian Pierce interned at the National Security Agency. Don't read too much into Cooper's very brief time at the CIA.
- itsyaboi 5y agoSlightly tongue in cheek, but that's probably what the CIA prefer you think.
- imwillofficial 5y agoAh so this other guy worked for a different place so we shouldn’t look to closely at Cooper. Makes total sense.
- cool_dude85 5y agoDon't know anything about the specific guy, but I wouldn't be surprised if there were 3-letter involvement in higher ed at some level. But the broader answer to your point is to consider the stakes and possible outcomes of clandestine influence of US media and of the Duke math department. It would probably very often come in handy to get favorable coverage, spike stories, influence hiring, etc. at major outlets, and not so often to do the same in the Duke math department. It's the difference between believing that the CIA is the one who knocked my mailbox over last night and believing that they were involved in the JFK assassination. Before considering evidence, we can provide many plausible reasons that the CIA may have wanted to assassinate JFK and few that they wanted to knock over my mailbox.
- pwned1 5y agoConsidering that the former Director of National Intelligence, who committed perjury before congress, is a regular CNN contributor and go-to guy for commentary, I think the answer is pretty clear.
- Victerius 5y agoYou should read his book, Facts and Fears. No perjury was committed. The question was incorrectly phrased and a lot of context was left out.
- cool_dude85 5y agoWait, he says in his book that he didn't commit perjury? Well, that lets him off the hook then.
- adolph 5y agoOr we can refer to Wikipedia in which Clapper’s excuse is (paraphrases) “I forgot” and “they weren’t supposed to ask about something classified” to which Wyden replied “he got the questions in advance so he could tell us not to ask about classified stuff.” Wyden then asked Clapper, "Does the NSA collect any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of Americans?" He responded, "No, sir." Wyden asked, "It does not?" and Clapper said, "Not wittingly. There are cases where they could inadvertently, perhaps, collect, but not wittingly." […] In Clapper's 2018 memoir, he provides a fuller explanation of the incident: ...because the NSA program under Section 215 was highly classified, Senator Wyden wouldn't or shouldn't have been asking questions that required classified answers on camera....my error had been forgetting about Section 215, but even if I had remembered it, there still would have been no acceptable, unclassified way for me to answer the question in an open hearing. Even my saying, "We'll have to wait for the closed, classified session to discuss this," would have given something away. ...I ought to have sent a classified letter to Senator Wyden explaining my thoughts when I'd answered and that I misunderstood what he was actually asking me about. Yes, I made a mistake – a big one – when I responded, but I did not lie. I answered with truth in what I understood the context of the question to be. On June 11, U.S. Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) accused Clapper of not giving a "straight answer," noting that Clapper's office had been provided with the question a day in advance of the hearing and was given the opportunity following Clapper's testimony to amend his response. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Clapper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Clapper
- webdoodle 5y agoThe CIA, through it's funding arm In-Q-Tel, bought into early [social media data mining firms](https://www.businessinsider.com/companies-funded-by-cia-2016-9?op=1 https://www.businessinsider.com/companies-funded-by-cia-2016...) as well.
- dr-detroit 5y agoABC news reported that facebook is just a CIA honeypot. Nobody cares... Charlie Wilson's War is a loveable Tom Hanks movie. People do not care even when something is directly harming them.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSee also "A Manhattan Project for Online Identity" (2011), by Alex Howard of O'Reilly Media, on the NSTIC (National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace) http://radar.oreilly.com/2011/05/nstic-analysis-identity-privacy.html http://radar.oreilly.com/2011/05/nstic-analysis-identity-pri... https://www.nist.gov/itl/applied-cybersecurity/tig https://www.nist.gov/itl/applied-cybersecurity/tig
- desine 5y agoGary Webb showed journalists what their choices were, so if the CIA wants media influence, they get media influence. edit: Also Michael Hastings, according to some. Webb was pretty blatant.
- fedreserved 5y agoGary Webb solidified the cias 2 prong approach in dealing with the media. Silver or lead. Take our money, or publish the truth or get suicided by shooting yourself twice in the head with a revolver.
- jcranberry 5y ago>If we take Bernstein at his word (and there's no reason not to), basically all the US media has secretly cooperated with the CIA. Is there any reason to think this isn't going on right now? There is a reason. Controversy which began in 1973 and spurred Congressional investigations and this very article led to the CIA to sign a 1977 directive that prohibited them from recruiting or impersonating journalists, peace corps, and the clergy. There was a loophole discovered in 1996 that allows the agency to waiver that directive in extreme circumstances and must notify the president, and a couple others (cant remember). This prompted a clause in the 1997 authorization act which codified into law that the CIA must notify both the house and senate intelligence committees and get a written sign-off with reasoning why its necessary from either the President or CIA director before impersonating or recruiting a journalist.
- tchalla 5y ago> There is a reason. Controversy which began in 1973 and spurred Congressional investigations and this very article led to the CIA to sign a 1977 directive that prohibited them from recruiting or impersonating journalists, peace corps, and the clergy. That doesn't mean they don't influence the media. The next time there are a sequence of articles on a particular country - you can think about when it plays up.
- realce 5y agoI'm not trying to go to bat for The Company but all sources of information "influence the media" and it's the job of a good journalist to get info from every source available to them, including intelligence agencies. The wording of "influence" is just too vague - prohibitions need to be specific. The CIA saying they'll deport your undocumented housekeeper if you don't print XYZ is one thing, them feeding information with "spin" on it to a journalist is another entirely.
- harry8 5y agoSpin is merely interpretation and framing. /You/ can de-spin anything you read when that's all it is and you should. Read stuff from biased sources that have a very different outlook to yours. Al-Jazeera, the BBC, NPR, PBS, even disasters like MSNBC and Fox are worth some attention despite their unbelievable amounts of spin. Lies are lies. It's not framing. It's not interpretation. It's "Saddam Hussein has weapons of mass destruction."[1] Spin that as we must go to war. Frame it as a global crisis. You can have a subtly or radically different viewpoint. When the majority of the country believe the deliberately planted lie, /spin/ is basically irrelevant. Influence the media is more about publishing deliberately fabricated lies designed for a given purpose and treating them as fact. It can get a country engage its army to kill when it otherwise would not want to do that. Doesn't get much more serious and less like /spin/, imho. [1] Or Russia pays bounties to kill American troops in Afghanistan and the President does not care. Exactly when the president is trying to execute policy (rightly or wrongly) on Afghanistan. It's not spin when it's a lie, treated as truth to mobilize public opinion where it otherwise probably would not go. Rightly or wrongly the American public overwhelmingly support the withdrawal from Afghanistan and did so under both Biden and Trump. For those who supported remaining in Afghanistan this should be a concern that such happens and seems not to have direct consequences when exposed. One indirect consequence is the increasing total mistrust of factual news reporting which is something of an issue in a democracy.
- DnDGrognard 5y agoHis boss during Watergate was a mate of Angleton and had been kicked out of I believe France
- dredmorbius 5y agoOn Bernstein's reliability here: in December 1977--January 1976, the House Intelligence Committee held hearings on this subject which strongly support Bernstein's claims through direct testimony of CIA officials and officers involved. Those were published in 1978, and are now available at the Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/CIAMedia1978Hearings/page/n3/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/CIAMedia1978Hearings/page/n3/mod... The New York Times ran a six-part series by John Crewdson concurrent with the hearings, based in large part on them though also independent research and interviews by the Times. I've compiled that series here: https://joindiaspora.com/posts/cdec9a80ce3b0139a0df002590d8e506 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/cdec9a80ce3b0139a0df002590d8e... “The CIA’s 3-Decade Effort to Mold the World’s Views” (1977-12-25) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/25/archives/the-cias-3decade-effort-to-mold-the-worlds-views-agency-network.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/25/archives/the-cias-3decade... “Worldwide Propaganda Network Built by the C.I.A.” (1977-12-26) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/26/archives/worldwide-propaganda-network-built-by-the-cia-a-worldwide-network.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/26/archives/worldwide-propag... “C.I.A. Established Many Links To Journalists in U.S. and Abroad” (1977-12-27) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/27/archives/cia-established-many-links-to-journalists-in-us-and-abroad-cias.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/27/archives/cia-established-... “Colby Acknowledges U.S. Press Picked Up Bogus C.I.A. Accounts” (1977-12-28) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/28/archives/colby-acknowledges-us-press-picked-up-bogus-cia-accounts-tells.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/28/archives/colby-acknowledg... “U.S. Correspondents Give Views on C.I.A.” (1977-12-29) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/29/archives/us-correspondents-give-views-on-cia-4-at-a-house-hearing-say-any.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/29/archives/us-correspondent... “Ex‐Envoy Says Risk of Exposure Negated C.I.A. Propaganda Value” (1977-12-30) https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/30/archives/exenvoy-says-risk-of-exposure-negated-cia-propaganda-value.html https://www.nytimes.com/1977/12/30/archives/exenvoy-says-ris... The total set runs about 50 pages formatted as PDF (ask me how I know). Markdown / HTML / ePub / PDF are available. As to current practices, the CIA have pinky sworn they totally wouldn't....
- TechnoTimeStop 5y agoColor me stupid here but would you expect an intelligence agency to do? Just sit back and go AFK while China takes over?
- citilife 5y ago> If we take Bernstein at his word (and there's no reason not to), basically all the US media has secretly cooperated with the CIA. Is there any reason to think this isn't going on right now? I mean, google "ken dilanian cia" for a good time. Then think: Dilanian is still a working journalist. Look at the number of former CIA, NSA and FBI directors / agents working as journalists or as advisors or make regular appearance to CNN alone. There's a whole rabbit hole you can go down. I recommend "The Plot Against the President" if you want a good insight as to how the news / government collaborate. https://www.amazon.com/Plot-Against-President-Devin-Nunes/dp/B08LMJ93LL https://www.amazon.com/Plot-Against-President-Devin-Nunes/dp... The portrayal is highly believed by the right, almost entirely ignored on the left, so it's worth a watch -- if only to understand gap in knowledge.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 5y agoSo now and again you'll hear a story about an anonymous source at some national security agency says this or that. That's actually a planted story authorized by said agency. You can tell because any time there is an unauthorized leak, you get a reaction like you did with Assange, Winner or Snowden.
- gadders 5y agoIt is going on right now. "And the answer is obvious: they all serve as mouthpieces for the same propagandists and disinformation agents of the CIA, FBI and other security state agencies. In this capacity, they dutifully write down and vouch for what they are told by those agencies to publish without any investigative scrutiny or confirmation. The most amazing part of it all is that when they try to malign independent journalists for not doing "real reporting” — real reporting like these corporate outlets do — this is what they mean by real reporting: getting a call from the CIA or FBI and being told what to say. And that is why they so often mislead and deceive the public with blatant disinformation in unison." https://greenwald.substack.com/p/corporate-news-outlets-again-confirm https://greenwald.substack.com/p/corporate-news-outlets-agai...
- beebeepka 5y agoI just wonder what kind of person downvotes comments such as this one. Because I can't think of a single honest reason to do so.
- mountainb 5y agoThe NOC structure gives the CIA a lot of flexibility internationally. You also have to realize that international anarchy is not just a buzzword, but is reality. When operating in weak states, cooperation with the CIA or taking NOC status is the cheapest source of security that you can get. The CIA also benefits from workarounds to its statutory limitations established by the CIA Act of 1949. It can do this through intermediaries. It can also grant individuals NOC status who are working internationally for a US corporation. As you might imagine, this provides a ton of flexibility. Most NOCs are not necessarily doing James Bond things, but they are forking over reports and other information to the CIA to help that agency to generate reports. The 'free press' is actually even worse than what you think, because so much of foreign reporting is just framed directly by the State Department's wires, press releases, and coverage. You don't even need to have Johnny N.Y. Times as an agent: just naturally they are ideologically sympathetic to what the State Department wants everyone to think by education, socialization, and active consumption of State Department propaganda. Johnny NYT then reads lots of State Department material, adds his own literary flair when he goes to report abroad, and then distributes it to the American retail news consumer market. This conveniently evades all the statutory limitations on domestic government propaganda. Journalists are already automatically suspected of being foreign spies, so they don't really make the best spies. An investor, attorney, or consultant is a much better informant because their information is going to be a lot better and much more relevant for US government purposes. You already have the entire press by default, so why bother putting them on the payroll? They will already do it for free and without being told what they have to do. Even then most know that if they are of particular service to the USG, they can get a sinecure later off of their servility while in the private sector.
- craigc 5y agoI’m glad people are finally catching on to this. The CIA has their tentacles in pretty much all aspects of society, and it has been that way for years. They have even admitted this openly: https://twitter.com/CIA/status/1034866941587087360 https://twitter.com/CIA/status/1034866941587087360 > CIA officers work as scientists, support staff, engineers, economists, linguists, mathematicians, secretaries, accountants, inventors, cartographers, architects, psychologists, police officers, editors, graphic designers, auto mechanics, historians, museum curators, & more! Curiously absent from that list is journalists…
- dragonwriter 5y agoThat tweet isn't an admission of the type you are claiming. (it's a list of things people on the overt CIA payroll do as their overt jobs at CIA, not a list of industries into which CIA employees work surreptitiously or in which the CIA recruits assets.)
- jjtheblunt 5y agoi'm glad you said that because i read the parent comment and thought how could that list have been so miscontrued.
- adamiscool8 5y agoIs there any reason to believe the CIA wouldn't have covert assets surreptitiously working in all those same roles, either domestically or abroad?
- craigc 5y agoOr maybe it is a mixture of both? Are you sure they don’t have covert people in all the very same positions? Does the CIA have its own internal museums, mapmaking companies, architecture firms? What buildings do their architects design? Employing an internal economist might be able to give you an idea of financial things going on in the world, but employing an economist who writes for a prominent media company or is on TV allows you to shape how the public THINKS about economics and financial markets which is much more powerful. Perhaps the tweet is not an open admission of this, but it doesn’t take a lot of effort to connect the dots.
- pphysch 5y ago> Is there any reason to think this isn't going on right now? The alliance between the corporate media and the intelligence community could not be any clearer. Looking past the endless barrage of yellow journalism in the traditional press, let's take a close look at Twitter. Last year, Twitter manually added tags to accounts deemed "foreign state media". Mysteriously, accounts like Radio Free Asia and Radio Free Europe, which are CIA cutouts directly funded by the US government, do not get such tags [1]. Look up RT, CGTN, etc for examples of this tag in action. Also last year, independent journalists dropped a bombshell report [2] on leaked documents detailing an anti-Russian disinformation operation that involves Reuters, BBC, and other "independent" news media groups. If you try to post [2] on Twitter, your post will be permanently marked with a visual warning banner about "hacked materials". AFAIK it is currently the only link that generates this response from Twitter. Ironically, this virtually guarantees its credibility, rather than simply dismissing it to the trash heap of crazy Qanon theories, etc. Finally, over the past few years Twitter has been officially releasing information on "disinformation" operations that occur on Twitter. Most recently, Twitter endorsed a report from the """independent""" (read: entirely funded by weapons manufacturers and Western governments) think tank ASPI which alleged to uncover a massive Chinese disinformation operation. I won't comment on the veracity of that report and encourage you to read it yourself and judge the quality of their "scientific" method. Regardless, it shows a clear alliance between Twitter and these special interests in the intelligence community. The related blog post from Twitter [3] is more worrying, because it suggests that your account can be removed if it engages at all with what is deemed to be a "disinformation campaign". Which might include liking or retweeting an apolitical tweet from an account marked "foreign state media", etc. [1] - https://twitter.com/RadioFreeAsia?s=20 https://twitter.com/RadioFreeAsia?s=20 [2] - https://thegrayzone.com/2021/02/20/reuters-bbc-uk-foreign-office-russian-media/ https://thegrayzone.com/2021/02/20/reuters-bbc-uk-foreign-of... [3] - https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/disclosing-state-linked-information-operations-we-ve-removed https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2021/disclosin...
- jevoten 5y agoIt gets better - paraphrased from http://ronpaulinstitute.org/archives/featured-articles/2021/april/10/how-bellingcat-launders-national-security-state-talking-points-into-the-press/ http://ronpaulinstitute.org/archives/featured-articles/2021/...: In 2019, the Twitter executive for the Middle East, Gordon MacMillan, was unmasked as an active duty officer in the British Army’s online psychological operations unit [1]. Coming at a time when foreign interference in politics and society was the primary issue in U.S. politics, the story was, astoundingly, almost completely ignored in the mainstream press [2]. Only one U.S. outlet of any note picked it up, and that journalist was forced of the profession weeks later [4,5]. [1] https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/twitter-executive-also-part-time-officer-uk-army-psychological-warfare-unit https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/twitter-executive-also-pa... [2] https://fair.org/home/media-ignore-unmasking-of-twitter-exec-as-british-psyops-officer/ https://fair.org/home/media-ignore-unmasking-of-twitter-exec... [3] Searching "Gordon MacMillan site:url" finds no relevant articles on theguardian.com, bbc.com, bbc.co.uk, nytimes.com, cnn.com, msnbc.com, latimes.com, theatlantic.com, or foxnews.com [4] https://www.mintpressnews.com/newsweek-journalist-tareq-haddad-quits-corruption-journalism/263667/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/newsweek-journalist-tareq-hadd... [5] https://www.mintpressnews.com/newsweek-tareq-haddad-quits-syria-douma-opcw/263292/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/newsweek-tareq-haddad-quits-sy...
- arthur_sav 5y ago> media cover current politics objectively Any person with half a brain knows that corporate media are just propaganda machines with political agendas at this point.
- complianceowl 5y agoSo true. Thankfully, I've found refuge in social media companies; Twitter, Facebook, Instagram? Pfffff! Beacons of free speech and truth bro.
- arthur_sav 5y agoSocial media is a medium, not the source. Following the work of independent journalists, in whatever medium you choose to consume, is the best approach atm.
- dude187 5y agoWell, previously that was the case, but that's why they started committing biased censorship. Now it isn't
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- FridayoLeary 5y ago>Am I supposed to believe that all these media cover current politics objectively I cannot begin to comprehend how anyone can consume the current political coverage and still believe it's objective. Also, of course not, nobody has ever suggested such a thing.
- bediger4000 5y agoYeah, the current political coverage really seems pro-Trump and anti-Biden. Biden's job creation is pitiful at 210K, where Trump's 200K was most excellent. Super obvious general pro-Trump bias obvious. Also, every issue is given a conservative frame, which is really weird. I think that arises from conservatives screaming "liberal bias" for 40 years, and the media bending over backwards to try to placate conservatives. Conservatives in turn, have realized that they can continue to scream "liberal bias" and get more favorable treatment. The media reinforce bad-faith claims of "fake news" or "liberal bias".
- colpabar 5y agoWhat are you talking about?
- orangepurple 5y agoWho is claiming a free press?
- justicezyx 5y agoI see no inherent issue with news agency cooperate with CIA or any other 3 letter agency, on projects for the good of the society and international community. The issue, as you probably having in mind, is that media lost their independence in finance, political protection, etc. Those then gradually corrupted their spirit and mentality. To the point that they start to produce contents that are easily nidged and manipulated. The first step of regaining media's strength is to rebuild a financial foundation for independent media. They should and must remain self-sufficient in support their own organization and employees. I'll be mocked for this, but, it seems to me that only such tech right available is crypto and block chain. I see no other tech even remotely close.
- rhizome 5y agoOr breaking up Facebook and Google such that they aren't able to commandeer all of the advertising dollars that would be required to "rebuild," at least under the currently dominant business models (which get further entrenched with every banking restriction imposed on independent businesspeople, but I digress).
- star-trek-fleet 5y agoThis approach will meet bigger resistance. The strength of capitalism is competition and freedom of innovation. Use new things to replace old things are the most constructive approach.
- burnafter291 5y agoIt's too bad we're not operating under a capitalist system, isn't it?
- Consultant32452 5y agoIt starts in the schools. Public school teachers train the children which news sources are "authoritative". And it doesn't matter how wrong they are, how much they lie, how bloodthirsty they are about any war, people do as they are trained. It's very common for TV news personalities to have direct ties to the intelligence community, and it's no surprise they are mouthpieces to the regime. Here's just one list of 15 former spooks working for the "news." https://dailycaller.com/2019/08/23/cnn-msnbc-15-spooks-mccabe/ https://dailycaller.com/2019/08/23/cnn-msnbc-15-spooks-mccab...
- handrous 5y ago> It starts in the schools. Public school teachers train the children which news sources are "authoritative". They basically don't have a choice but to teach them this if they don't want to grade a bunch of papers about how the UK royal family actually comprises lizard people from the Hollow Earth, or the Earth is in fact flat, or that the holocaust or moon landing were faked, or any number of more mundane bits of bullshit. Yes there's more to source evaluation, but a first pass of "is this contrary-to-common-knowledge truth-bomb coming from a source generally regarded as credible?" actually is a reasonable and helpful first step.
- elzbardico 5y agoBecause, of course, anything that differs from the mainstream narrative necessarily needs to be outrageous nutty conspiracy stuff.
- Consultant32452 5y agoThe training is effective.
- handrous 5y agoYes, because that's totally what I wrote. Anyway. No, but if you actually go teach a class of real children in this world of ours, today in the year 2021 when none of them have ever seen a card catalog and may literally not know how to use books ("what's an index?") and you're not unreasonable so you let them use the web because, realistically, that's what they're mostly going to use to find stuff out the rest of their lives, and they have not been taught to be wary of non-mainstream sources, I guarantee you'll get an avalanche of bullshit to read every single time you assign a research paper. 99 times out of 100 they won't find a deep-hidden truth The Man doesn't want you to know, but instead a bunch of crap. The skills to tease out the difference eludes a high percentage of adults. An 9-year-old writing their first research paper has no hope. It'd be cool if it were possible to transmit all our knowledge and abilities into kids instantly, but it takes time, both because of how learning works and how children develop over a period of years. This is an entirely reasonable first step, without which proceeding is hardly possible except maybe with a very few exceptional kids, but schools are tasked with teaching everyone. And, go figure, it's possible to do this and then later hand the kids Chomsky and Klein and cover propaganda and government and corporate lies and media complicity in same.
- oxymoran 5y agoWow, never heard of this dilanian guy but he is still at it and it’s directly related to the cia: https://news.yahoo.com/cia-chief-warns-russians-consequences-221755624.html https://news.yahoo.com/cia-chief-warns-russians-consequences... Interestingly enough, I did google for fun and I also DuckDuckGo’d. interesting differences. All the google results were articles from 2014 when the intercept broke the news. DuckDuckGo has much more current info, including the yahoo link I found.
- jweir 5y agoNot well known is that the CIA commissioned an animated version of Animal Farm. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Farm_(1954_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_Farm_(1954_film)
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoWell that’s interesting. I clearly remember watching that version in school.
- plantdude 5y agothe media operates globally because distribution is important & stories come from all over. outside of any sort of conspiracy around what the CIA could use the media to do... there are obvious operational benefits to working within the media or a similarly structured and distributed organization. the real question isn't did the CIA stop using one type of organization or did they find ways to use other types of organizations. is the CIA doing the work? are they taking advantage of all of the different organizations that oddly have some sort of social protection similar to diplomats. whether it's NGOs allowed into a country that is just kind of hard to get into... or some freelance photographers tagging along with a news crew as they report on a country ahead of an invasion. maybe it's just the adjust professor teaching abroad as a way to monitor certain foreign CS students whose parents are high value assets and all of their labs and most definitely the final is just a way to get malicious code onto devices they're going to bring home.
- jedmeyers 5y agoI’ll give you one more: is there any reason to think CIA hasn’t infiltrated HN comments right now?
- paganel 5y agoI don't see them interested in nerds and in nerd-culture, to be honest, eventually maybe there are some FBI or Secret Service lurkers in here, definitely some past or present NSA employees/collaborators.
- cbHXBY1D 5y agoNot sure about HN but there's plenty of evidence of intelligence agencies using Reddit to craft public opinion. Look at the demonization of the US's geopolitical rivals and the stories that get pushed. For example, questioning the Russian bounties story for a while would get you responses of "Russian bot". We know now the Russian bounties story was weak from the start: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/remember-those-russian-bounties-dead-u-s-troops-biden-admin-n1264215 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/national-security/remember-... Repeat ad nauseam for other geopolitical rivals.
- jessaustin 5y agoMaybe they've been too busy over at Wikipedia to have time for HN?