7 ms·
> When public health officials in New York, Baltimore, and Chicago tried to enact regulations in the 1950s that threatened the industry's interests, lobbyists v
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
> When public health officials in New York, Baltimore, and Chicago tried to enact regulations in the 1950s that threatened the industry's interests, lobbyists visited legislators and governors to get restrictions lifted. They succeeded. When Baltimore's health department called for the removal of lead from paint, the industry countered by proposing and winning a "voluntary" standard, reducing the lead content in paint. When New York City's health department proposed a warning label saying that the product was poisonous to children, the industry rejected the "poison" label and lobbied successfully for another label that simply advised parents not to use it on "toys, furniture, or interior surfaces that might be chewed by children," and deliberately avoided mentioning that lead paint was poisonous. It hired public relations firms to plan out strategies to forestall threats to the lead market.
> The lead industry even sought to place the blame for lead poisoning epidemic on parents and children, claiming that the problem was not with the lead paint but with the "uneducable Negro and Puerto Rican" parents who "failed" to stop children from placing their fingers and toys in their mouths. Children poisoned by lead, the industry claimed, had a disease that led them to suck on "unnatural objects" and thereby get poisoned.
> But the industry wouldn't remove all lead from their products. It fought every attempt at regulation. Industry representatives threatened lawsuits against television stations such as CBS that aired popular shows like Highway Patrol in which the product was depicted as dangerous ... All this despite records that show that the industry knew that their product was poisoning children.
You know how many Americans have a weird dislike of government intervention. These are the guys that paid to make that happen.
- GordonS 5y agoThe level damage that lobbying has caused and continues to cause in the US is absolutely crazy - you could say poisonous. How can this status quo possibly ever be changed though, when the only people who could do so are the ones that benefit from it the most (corrupt politicians)?
- thewarrior 5y agoAnd then lead poisoned voters with poor cognitive skills are more easily manipulated into voting against their own interests or their poverty is used to polarize the rest of the electorate and achieve the same outcome.
- jeffbee 5y agoCOVID-19 survivors also have reduced cognitive abilities, equivalent to about 7 points on IQ scale, which isn't great for countries that have been hit with many infections. https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5370(21)00324-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/eclinm/article/PIIS2589-5...
- chrisco255 5y agoNo, they don't. This is a completely false statement.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoI dunno, I heard that people who had recovered from COVID-19, including those no longer reporting symptoms, exhibited significant cognitive deficits versus controls when controlling for age, gender, education level, income, racial-ethnic group, pre-existing medical disorders, tiredness, depression and anxiety.
- fartattack 5y agoWell if you heard it, it must be true
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wolfram74 5y agoCompletely false in that survivors all have 0 or positive impacts on cognitive abilities? or that survivors have a range of cognitive impacts, none or only some of which could be the equivalent of 7 iq points?
- random314 5y agoOP has cited the Lancet.
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoWhere these quotes are from? FWIW, the parent article's question is "why despite of lead being banned for 30+ years we're still getting cases of lead poisoning among children"
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoJust a random article on the history, I felt there was a weird vibe of "well kids are being made ill by this lead that's everywhere for unknown reasons" as if it was some natural and unavoidable tragedy, rather than a century long conspiracy in plain sight, driven by greed that got us here. Paint manufacturers were talking publicly about it in 1904. There's an American amazed at how good the US response to this threat is vs the UK, possibly overlooking that the UK government and industry basically banned it 15 years earlier than the US, massively reducing the scope of the problem. The Doctor that in America is held as being responsible for proving there was an issue only starting looking into it years after that change in the UK had happened, decades after attempts at legislation started. I feel there's an important point there that's worth thinking about.
- willcipriano 5y agoWhat you are missing is the government didn't regulate anything meaningful in the end. The government threatened to regulate something and that had it's desired effect, lobbyists were hired, dinners were had and campaigns were contributed to. Now having extracted it's protection money, it goes on to protect the organization that paid them with weak regulation to placate voters. This is the system working exactly as the regulators planned.
- AlexTWithBeard 5y agoWait. Are you saying there's no lead regulation in the US?
- willcipriano 5y agoRead the OP above, regulations were going to essentially end the lead paint industry, those were scaled back to the point of having little effect. It wasn't until later, when the lead paint companies no longer had money for lobbyists, that we saw meaningful regulation around it. Things like this are just shakedowns that happen in public, if they really wanted to pass regulations they wouldn't do the public "Sure would be a shame if someone regulated you out of business" song and dance at the start.
- MisterTea 5y ago> "Sure would be a shame if someone regulated you out of business" song and dance at the start. From the article: > "Baltimore's health department called for the removal of lead from paint, ..." > "When New York City's health department proposed a warning label saying that the product was poisonous to children ..." What song and dance are you talking about? The only thing I see are agencies doing the job they're supposed to do which is protecting the public while these greedy pig fuckers sabotage them.
- willcipriano 5y agoSee the words used "called", "proposed" not "enacted". The science and public health issues around this apparently changed once the lead paint companies made donations to the right campaigns and the regulators ensured that the lead paint firms had plenty of time to do that by loudly telegraphing their moves. If the mob wants to burn your store down, they'll just burn it down. They won't loudly pontificate on the issue unless they want you to try and stop them.
- munk-a 5y agoAnd it keeps happening again and again. The cost to society of prolonged lead usage can't be properly attributed to the damaging parties since they've all long since ceased to be solvent - ditto with the next wave and the wave after that. There is a real problem with insisting that regulations be lifted to allow business development and then ending up with tax payers suffering the long term externalities, we've seen it with global warming (and we're still not properly attributing any costs there) along with fracking and other environmental disasters. In my former state of Vermont a nuclear plant (Vermont Yankee[1]) tried their damnedest to avoid paying for contamination cleanup. This is a scenario we see play out time and time again. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_Yankee_Nuclear_Power_Plant#Controversy_and_operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont_Yankee_Nuclear_Power_P...
- hinkley 5y agoNot only are the companies insolvent, at this point half the perpetrators are probably dead. Just stall long enough and you'll never have to deal with the problems you created.
- philips 5y agoRelatedly, I have been working on a project[1] to encourage municipalities to implement stricter land use requirements on gas stations because responsible party searches so rarely pay out. Here is a funny (depressing?) quote from an Oregon DEQ report I read recently: "The site has a complex history, but the primary owner/operators have been Ron and Nancy Huddleston. The Huddlestons owned and operated the facility from the 1960s through 1979, when they sold the site to Tony and Michel Tocco. In 1987, the Toccos sold or gave the property and business to their son in-law, who after some difficulties running the store, returned it to the Toccos. The Toccos gave it back to the Huddlestons in 1988, who ran the store again until 1993. Finally, in 1993, the Huddlestons sold the store to Dewey Best (now deceased); Mr. Best operated the store until 1995, when he sold it to Harley Frisby, and operations continued under Kim and JeffBomark (Mr. Frisby's daughter and son-in-law). Mr. Frisby sold his interest in 1996 to the Bomarks, who declared bankruptcy in 1998. In May 1999, the bankruptcy court returned the property to the Huddlestons. Based on an ability-to-pay analysis of the Huddlestons, DEQ determined in March 2003 that they are unable to fund required investigation and cleanup activities. DEQ will continue to investigate other parties connected with the property to determine whether they may be responsible for cleanup costs." [1] https://postpump.org https://postpump.org
- colpabar 5y agoBut isn’t it the government that ultimately prevented the proposed regulations? Why am I supposed to ignore that?
- estaseuropano 5y agoThe interesting thing is that 'the industry' or a specific company doing obviously evil things is nothing but people. Somr researchers and spin doctors found the arguments. Some marketing expert(s) compiled that text. Another put it in a layout. Another signed off. Another contracted the print. Another printed. None of them took action to stop it - else we wouldn't see it today. The evil underlying modern American legal and ethical systems is the weird understanding of a company as a concrete thing. This means none of the people that took the steps above ever faced (or even feared) liability.
- bendbro 5y ago> You know how many Americans have a weird dislike of government intervention. These are the guys that paid to make that happen. > Americans > Weird dislike Sounds like European coping. > These are the guys that paid to make that happen A GAN's smooshed rendition of the closing line of every documentary. This style is distinctly le redditour. What exactly is your background? Regardless, nobody paid to make Americans dislike government, and if you crack open a history book you'll find that governments did that themselves. I'd recommend you start with the reasons for the bill of rights. That said we should ban the lead
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe government at the time of the Bill of Rights was voted for by, and therefore represented the interests of, about 6% of the population: > Generally, states limited this right to property-owning or tax-paying white males (about 6% of the population).[1] However, some states allowed also Black males to vote, and New Jersey also included unmarried and widowed women, regardless of color. Since married women were not allowed to own property, they could not meet the property qualifications.[2] Like the Magna Carta, and other historical staging-posts towards modern democracy, it was a step in the right direction, but somewhat ridiculous to hold it up as a reason to mistrust government generally.
- bendbro 5y agoI never argued that the bill of rights is a reason to mistrust the government. I am arguing that the bill of rights is evidence that Americans have had some unspecified reason to mistrust the government embedded in their culture since founding, well before the lead paint guys started buying power. > The government at the time of the Bill of Rights was voted for by, and therefore represented the interests of, about 6% of the population where that population is > property-owning or tax-paying white males So are you arguing that mostly white males dislike government intervention? If not, what subpopulation are you arguing it is that dislikes intervention?
- nightski 5y agoI have a different take. Americans dislike government intervention because they don't trust the government due to corruption and being so easily manipulated by corporate interests. Fix that instead of granting government more power to wield its corruption.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat is a lazy take. Americans are the government. By claiming that the government is corrupt, the implication is that you and your fellow Americans are corrupt. The solution has to be getting involved in governance, from local to state to even federal levels depending on your abilities. Which is unfortunate because there is still a salvageable amount of cohesion and trust in US society (free and fair elections, mostly good people with good intentions not explicitly seeking bribes, etc). At least, on a global stage, we are still in a relatively good spot.
- nickpp 5y agoIt’s first principles reasoning: the only motivation for politicians to become politicians is gaining advantages they can’t obtain in the private sector. And since administration jobs don’t pay that well, corruption it is.
- newbamboo 5y ago“your fellow Americans are corrupt” Yes! They are. And lead is the main culprit. Tv and sugar didn’t help.
- mandmandam 5y agoI honestly don't think any of that optimism is remotely warranted. And Americans are certainly very, very disconnected from the actual political sausage factory, thanks to corrupt media and corrupt law - why would you give them a pass here? I'm shocked that so many Americans are so blind to so much rot. You can smell it in the air. Even the Democrats are seemingly fine with executive orders, the Patriot Act, black sites, extrajudicial killings of American and other friendly nations citizens, smearing and torturing whistleblowers like Assange and Donziger. "On a global stage", America is seen as the number one threat to democracy and world peace, and has consistently been seen as such since Afghanistan. It's wild that Americans don't ever seem to grasp how they are seen abroad.
- ErikVandeWater 5y ago> weird dislike of government intervention History is the best reason not to trust the government, because it has been behind unbelievably evil things; and politicians have promised to solve every problem you can think of 10x over, enacted legislation to do so, and lo-and-behold they all still exist.
- ZanyProgrammer 5y ago[flagged]
- InitialLastName 5y ago> History is the best reason not to trust the government, because it has been behind unbelievably evil things; Government, being effectively the primary means that people have to organize themselves, is a force multiplier for human impact; it's intellectually dishonest to blame it for the unbelievably evil things people have made it do without crediting it for the unbelievably good things.
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoI didn't argue the government deserves no credit. Enforcing basic rule of law is essential for life to be anything but miserable. I argued giving it power to "intervene" has a proven track record of (at worst) causing evil things to happen, and (at best) not solving what it has sought to solve.
- InitialLastName 5y agoTo the topic of this article, it is largely due to government that we aren't still putting lead in our gasoline, paint and water pipes; most of the issue now is in the deteriorating housing stock that our (free-market-driven) development pattern (money goes into sprawl, leaving older, decaying housing stock in the hands of people who can't afford remediation, ditto at a local tax base level) hasn't updated.
- Rury 5y ago>I argued giving it power to "intervene" has a proven track record of... This argument seems kind of weird or hypocritical to me. Government is nothing other than a group of people. Same with corporations. Of course, when someone intervenes against what you want or against your morals, you're going to dislike it or may even deem it evil. As after all, that's your opinion. Problem is not everyone in society has the same opinion on matters, hence why politics is a thing. Perhaps if you think the government (people) shouldn't have power to "intervene", you (a person), or another group you approve of (yet again people) also shouldn't have power to "intervene" either? Not that you were arguing this, but... hopefully I've demonstrated my point.
- chaostheory 5y ago> You know how many Americans have a weird dislike of government intervention. We have plenty of government intervention, but as you've pointed out these regulations are created by lobbyists for their special interests
- dang 5y agoCould you please not post generic tangents like this? It's specifically against the site guidelines because it reliably leads to lower-quality, less on-topic, more generic discussion—all of which, unfortunately and predictably, we got below. Worse, shallow-indignant comments like this tend to get upvoted to the top, where they accrue mass and sit astride the entire thread, crowding out the interesting comments. That's where I found this one when I marked it offtopic (which downweights it). Doing that had a big effect - now there is a diverse assortment of interesting, informative comments for people to read when they first see the thread. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]