7 ms·
Why aren't thousands of gigabytes of abusive images removed from the web?
- Hekioi 5y ago:-(
- good8675309 5y agoOnly 15 years for being convicted of raping a little girl and murdering another? Then spends those 15 years in a cushy psych ward talking about his feelings. Only to be released when the traumatized girl is 30. What a disgusting nightmare that country is and any country that wouldn't have severe consequences for this type of pure evil. No wonder it's growing out of control, these evil bastards have calculated the risk and aren't afraid of the consequences. If that happened to my daughter you better believe he'd never rape or kill another girl again.
- api 5y agoYou can tell the argument against cryptography from "but child porn!" is in bad faith because child abuse of this sort is systematically under-investigated, under-prosecuted, and under-sentenced. If they really cared it would be a priority in terms of both investigation and sentencing, but far more is spent chasing drugs and sentences for small-mid size drug offenses are often much longer. Get caught with a big stash of meth? Go away for 10+ years. Get caught filming child abuse? Get a few years and some psych counseling, if that.
- junon 5y agoReplying here since the GP comment is dead. At least in the US, the psych system for such offenders is anything but "cushy"... Also inmates tend to absolutely _hate_ child offenders, so good luck in there.
- olliej 5y agoI mean sex abuse in general - Brock turner was literally caught in the act of raping a women and got 3 months :-/
- Eldt 5y agoI guess they think fucking children is less degenerate than smoking weed. Hah.
- dang 5y agoCould you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments to HN? You've been doing it a lot, unfortunately, and we're trying for the opposite here. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- hirundo 5y agoI've spent two decades plus now browsing the web, including my share of porn, but have yet to come across an unambiguous child porn or child abuse image. I don't doubt that many of you have. But I do wonder if it's a significant enough problem to justify the level of surveillance that would be required to wipe it out. "Thousands of gigabytes" is consistent with a single cheap hard drive. If that's the threshold for alarm then the alarm is permanent.
- api 5y agoI've trawled around the dark web (.onion) before for quite a while and have never landed on any CP. I did see a link once to something that looked like it could have been CP but of course didn't follow it. Point is that even in onion-land it seems that one can't easily find CP unless one is actively attempting to search it out. It's not something you are likely to be ambushed by.
- Jenk 5y agoI explored on Tor about 15 years ago, by just finding indexers and what not from the regular net. I couldn't avoid links to CP everywhere. For every "innocent" link I saw, there must have been multiple links (claiming) to be of CP stashes. I'd say the only thing comparable was the number of "hitman; Pay half first, half after" links.
- sokoloff 5y agoHow many of those do you guess were planted snares by feds?
- Jenk 5y agoNo idea, I kept away from them as best I could, but I did see comments (on the indexers that, I guess, were there for "rating" the links) lauding most of them as such. Honestly, it reminded me a lot of the early 90s www - that is that anything and everything just couldn't be trusted unless you knew the source outside of the web, too. (Like you know the author's personally, or you have confirmation it is a university site, etc.) and that put me off quite a lot. I really didn't fancy the idea of even accidentally opening the wrong link and seeing these images so I basically stopped using Tor altogether and haven't been back since.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sam_goody 5y agoI know a child who was repeatedly raped on video, and the perp kept on boasting to the girl about how he was trading the videos for stuff. He was eventually charged, and it was really really tough making a case against him. He argued that the stuff the girl said was implanted by the therapists, that her testimony was tainted, that he would counter-sue, etc. (He got one year!! which was more than I expected, and will soon be out to terrorize her further.) I have no doubt that there are many government services that are busy curating all this type of stuff [and I don't doubt they are mostly staffed by sickos, but that is irrelevant for this post]. I dreamed that there be some way I can upload a image of a victim, and be told if there is such a video in the DB - and then, with 100 proofs of identity, only she or her guardian would be able to access it. That would at the very least allow such perpetrators to better be convicted, and in the case where there are multiple kids in the videos or the videos are part of a group, it would help find the other victims and perhaps stop a lot of wickedness. I reached out to one British agency, and they told me that they have a collection of videos, that its existence is murky legally, and that they cannot help me search within it. But maybe someone somewhere knows how this could be done?
- bmmayer1 5y agoThis seems like an almost perfect use case for one-way image hashing.
- KarlKemp 5y agoIt’s not really a tech problem? They obviously have people that are allowed to look at the stuff, so they could look for evidence themselves. The total number of victims should also be quite manageable, especially if you know the timeframe, location, camera etc to narrow it down? From what the yandex image search can do, I believe a simple photo of the alleged scene of the crime might be enough. The problem, above, is that it’s the wrong person “investigating” this. You won’t get much support trying to find your stolen bike. Vigilante CP investigator sets of wvwey alarm bell there is.
- sam_goody 5y ago
- more_corn 5y agoI really like the new language of calling it child abuse imagery. It’s not porn, it’s abuse. We as technologists need to do a better job of building the moderation tools that help platforms act on abuse reports. At YouTube a staggering quantity of abusive videos were uploaded. The content moderation team had mandatory therapy, were provided with powerful tooling to glance at thumbnails without watching full videos and still people burnt out so fast 3 month contacts were the norm. There was a dedicated FBI liaison who’s job it was to collect evidence and report it. (Funny note, it was technically illegal for him to possess the evidence while collecting it to report it. This became interesting due to mandatory record retention during an unrelated case.) Better tooling allows platforms to quickly pull and report abusive content. We should all take this need quite seriously. I’d love to see some open source tooling around content moderation geared at stamping out abuse.
- good8675309 5y agoIs there a free API for small SaaS products to use to check user uploaded images for CP and other violent imagery? Seems like such a tool should be a funded public service. I think AWS has something but it's likely paid and I don't use them. I'm pretty sure these tools are only available to companies that have the budget for it. Imagine open source projects like Wordpress and Mastodon having the option to toggle on such CP scanning of user uploaded content that would use the API?
- _7gt4 5y agoPhotoDNA, but it requires a suite of lawyers since the material it uses to fingerprint is high res enough to make it identifiable again. Or create false positives.
- sirshmooey 5y agoCloudflare has the CSAM Scanning Tool for all accounts, not sure how well it works. https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-csam-scanning-tool/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-csam-scanning-tool/
- nonameiguess 5y agoThe article describes schemes where perpetrators share images via file hosting services by encrypting and sharing symmetric keys out of band. There is no way you can possibly identify the file content if they're doing that. The only way is for law enforcement to discover the nature of the photos by other means and then tell you which files are actually CSAM, which works perfectly well until somebody they haven't caught yet who still has local copies uploads again from a different Tor entrance using a different encryption key.
- KarlKemp 5y agoHosting encrypted zips en masse would also seem to be slightly shady? Sure, there are legitimate uses for that. But if it’s 90% of what your customers share on your platform, you might want to consider that it’s also legal not to host that type of file.
- Faelian2 5y agoThere are multiple studies linking the introduction of pornography to a diminution of sexual assaults : https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/all-about-sex/201601/evidence-mounts-more-porn-less-sexual-assault https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/all-about-sex/201601.... As horrifying as it sound. I wonder if we are not better off having child pornography around. I expect it would result in a diminution of child abuse. (That being said, I don't think there has ever been a study on the subject).
- Eldt 5y agoIf the sex dolls and anime aren't enough for them to stop then they should just be castrated.
- vanusa 5y agoIt would need to be AI-generated deepfake imagery of course (I can't see any justification for using real imagery of minors). From a harm minimization standpoint, it's worth investigating at least (and I do believe I've heard the proposal somewhere, already). However, it would require that we, as a society do something we don't yet seem ready to do: accept those folks with truly unsupressable desires of this sort as people, who deserve to be treated humanely and with compassion, if at all possible.
- codezero 5y agoThere is no such thing as child pornography, only child sexual abuse images. Hammer this into your head, children cannot consent, and pornography is a legitimate form of adult entertainment.
- horsawlarway 5y agoAt the risk of stating the very obvious... There are plenty of forms of pornography that do not require a literal subject to pose for picture or video. While I would be strongly against allowing distribution of real people, I find it much harder to argue against material that is generated. (whether that's art/CGI/cartoons/thispersonisnotreal.com/etc)
- 5y ago
- acover 5y agoCould it be a honey pot? Previous dark net repositories of child porn were used to find pedophiles and those creating the illegal content.
- junon 5y ago> Thousands of gigabytes Terabytes, even!
- aaron695 5y agoThey have named and shown a photograph of a father of a child sexual abuse victim. She is now identified. She's 15. She is still a child, as an adult she might consent to talk about this publicly and be identified, but until then there should be protections in place. Protections in law and media ethics.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bryanlarsen 5y agoHopefully the timing of this article isn't because of the new German governments pro-cryptography stance. https://www.euractiv.com/section/data-protection/interview/germanys-new-government-will-firmly-defend-encryption-key-social-democrat-says/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/data-protection/interview/g...
- guilhas 5y agoThe problem is when they are caught nothing happens. Even the currently happening Maxwell/Epstein trial will probably brush off most important people involved, and the human traffic in general. And Epstein had already been released before No prison time for Gates worker caught with child rape videos https://komonews.com/archive/no-prison-time-for-gates-worker-caught-with-child-rape-videos https://komonews.com/archive/no-prison-time-for-gates-worker... Bill Gates Met With Jeffrey Epstein Many Times, Despite His Past https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/12/business/jeffrey-epstein-bill-gates.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/12/business/jeffrey-epstein-... Once I was going around Facebook and there was a video, deleted later, of dead human bodies being dragged and cut in pieces, completely surreal and disgusting The problem is not only that the videos exist, most are probably not even be public, the problem is people is still being abused, and not getting justice. And who abuses, creates the videos and uploads, are not getting investigated
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoDo the topless pictures of Samantha Fox on page three of the british The Sun from the 80ies sixteen count as child pornography now? She was sweet sixteen then. /me bawls Touch me now... Edit: For those not in the know: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samantha_Fox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samantha_Fox