8 ms·
Renault Zoe NCAP crash rating: zero stars [pdf]
- raxxorrax 5y agoI guess this will hit all electric vehicles at first. Due to the higher weight you will have more energetic collisions compared to fuel powered cars. Of course there are still differences by model.
- p49k 5y agoTesla Model 3: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/55749/euroncap-2019-tesla-model-3-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/55749/euroncap-2019-tesla-mod... BMW iX: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67239/euroncap-2021-bmw-ix-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67239/euroncap-2021-bmw-ix-da... Jaguar I-Pace: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/63559/euroncap-2018-jaguar-i-pace-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/63559/euroncap-2018-jaguar-i-... Nissan Leaf: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/62961/euroncap-2018-nissan-leaf-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/62961/euroncap-2018-nissan-le... VW ID3: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/64338/euroncap-2020-vw-id3-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/64338/euroncap-2020-vw-id3-da... VW ID4: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/64335/euroncap-2021-vw-id4-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/64335/euroncap-2021-vw-id4-da... Hyundai Ioniq 5: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67127/euroncap-2021-hyundai-ioniq-5-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67127/euroncap-2021-hyundai-i... Ford Mustang Mach-e: 5 stars https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/65695/euroncap-2021-ford-mustang-mach-e-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/65695/euroncap-2021-ford-must...
- lazyjones 5y agoRenault Zoe 2013 model: 5 stars https://www.euroncap.com/de/results/renault/zoe/8889 https://www.euroncap.com/de/results/renault/zoe/8889
- janoc 5y agoYes - and using fairly different criteria, with little emphasis on things like pedestrian protection or various safety systems (like automatic emergency braking). Which is where the current model lost big time as those are not available for it (due to cost reasons - the car is so expensive already that fitting some sophisticated automation would make it unsellable).
- Hamuko 5y agoI guess this is just more proof that the Mach-E is not a true Mustang: the Ford Mustang got 2/5 stars in 2017 and even after Ford changed the specs, it only got a 3/5.
- is_true 5y agoRenault is known for making coffins with wheels
- janoc 5y agoNot really, that's apples to oranges comparison comparing this to something like a Tesla, Ioniq or one of the large expensive electric SUVs. Something like Ioniq 5 is almost twice as big compared to a Zoe ... Zoe is an urban supermini, only slightly bigger than a Smart or Twingo. And with minimal equipment (no expensive assistive systems) to bring the price down because otherwise it wouldn't be possible to sell it. Zoe pricing starts at 32500€ (comparably or even larger sized Clio at about 15000€). It used to be possible to buy it cheaper - but then you needed to add monthly rent of the battery pack (battery pack was leased from the manufacturer, you don't buy it with the Zoe - Renault specialty) So there simply isn't either physical or pricing space for any fancy equipment like extra airbags, electronic safety/assistive systems, etc. - and that's where Zoe was losing big time in the NCAP tests.
- gambiting 5y agoI generally agree, except for this point: "because otherwise it wouldn't be possible to sell it." Like, Dacia is making their EV literally for 1/3rd of the cost of the Zoe[0], and yet they managed to get 1 star in ncap tests[1]. So no, I don't think it "wouldn't be possible" to include these better systems - it's just Renault being cheap and riding their brand recognition as Zoe is a pretty popular model. [0] https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/dacia-spring-ev-looking-very-positive-uk-sale https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/dacia-spring-ev-... [1] https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/dacia/spring/44197 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/dacia/spring/44197
- janoc 5y agoBut Renault and Dacia are not on the same level of tech. Dacia literally uses stripped "hand-me-downs" from old Renault models, i.e. everything where any R&D is long paid of. So of course they are cheap. Dacia certainly didn't get that one star because it includes any assistive systems (it does not). It is just slightly bigger so the protection of the occupants in the cabin is naturally better than in the cramped Zoe.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bmurray7jhu 5y agoTesting video https://youtu.be/HiOs1mCMH4Q https://youtu.be/HiOs1mCMH4Q
- ericpauley 5y agoThere are certainly some weaknesses here, but from the commentary and initial skim of the results it seems odd to call this a 0-star safety rating. I'd be curious to see what a 1-, 2-, or 3-star safety rating looks like in comparison. Update: Looking at the Euro NCAP star rating criterea[0], the primary reason this car was capped at 0 stars was its minimal safety assist features (14%, minimum for 1-star is 30%. While this balancing may make sense in other cases it seems odd in the case of active safety features. Is it really fair to call an otherwise perfect (though not in this case) car a 0-star death trap because it doesn't include driver monitoring (?) and radar? [0] https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67266/euro-ncap-assessment-protocol-overall-rating-v902.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/67266/euro-ncap-assessment-pr...
- p49k 5y agoHere's a 1-star electric vehicle for comparison: https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/66949/euroncap-2021-dacia-spring-datasheet.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/66949/euroncap-2021-dacia-spr...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kwhitefoot 5y agoAlso, effectively a Renault.
- toast0 5y agoCrash testing organizations have always been about advocacy. If you don't do what they find important, you get fewer stars and the negative attention that attracts. There's always a balance in this approach. If the people buying the cars also want the things the advocacy group wants, the star ratings are relevant and useful; if they don't agree, the ratings aren't super useful and a 0-star rating doesn't kill sales. (Although, often a 8 year+ design tapers off in sales anyway)
- radu_floricica 5y agoI wonder how much this is lobby by the car industry to raise entry barriers. Maybe against cheap chinese producers?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- terramex 5y agoAn article clearing it up a bit: https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/renault-zoe-given-zero-stars-euro-ncap-safety-tests https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/renault-zoe-give... Matthew Avery, Euro NCAP board member and chief research and strategy officer at Thatcham, told Autocar: “Every few years, Euro NCAP raises the bar by introducing new tests which either exploit new technologies or lift the hurdle to make manufacturers do better. If everyone is five-star, we need to lift the barrier." As a result of these alterations, he explained: “When we first tested the Zoe, it did reasonably well and had all the elements you needed back then to get a reasonable score. But if you've still got the same design 10 years later, you aren't going to score as well.” "The Zoe was launched in 2013 and received 5 stars with Euro NCAP protocol at that time. The Euro NCAP protocol has since 2013 undergone five changes. With the same equipment, a model can lose up to two stars in each protocol change. I was not aware how quickly and dramatically the tests change, it makes comparison between different models almost useless unless you read through entire test protocols.
- makeitdouble 5y agoWhat’s interesting is how the other makers still keep a decent score through the years. In Zoe’s case it seems they really optimized for the 2013 tests and had nothing to show for the more challenging tests.
- yourusername 5y agoAlso consider that the new NCAP ratings aren't about real safety. You can only get a maximum of 3 starts if you don't include nanny systems like lane assist, front assist, side assist, auto braking. For me this makes the NCAP rating useless as i don't care about such systems and would prefer a car that doesn't have them. I'd happily drive a 0 star Zoe.
- makeitdouble 5y agoLane assist can be seen as a quality of life improvement, but wouldn’t auto braking be a purely safety feature, with 100% life saving potential ? Also 3 stars doesn’t look bad to me if you meet the bare minimum standard. I mean, it’s fine and people will look at the prices to compare anyway.
- makeitdouble 5y agoTo note, Dacia Spring (also Renault group) got paned as well https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/dacia/spring/44197 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/dacia/spring/44197
- s1k3s 5y ago0 star safety: Meeting type-approval standards so can legally be sold but lacking critical modern safety technology Wikipedia
- glintik 5y agoZero stars - car body from paper?
- twic 5y agoDon't know why this is a link to the PDF, the web page has the same information (although hidden behind all sorts of tabs and toggles you have to click): https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/renault/zoe/44206 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/renault/zoe/44206
- tamcap 5y agoI think you just answered your own question ;-) .
- pantulis 5y agoI find interesting to compare these results with those of a 4-star car hailing from 1999, which could now be considered a coffin-on-wheels. (I happen to own one, maybe I should consider getting a Zoe!) https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/9749/euroncap_ford_focus_1999_4stars.pdf https://cdn.euroncap.com/media/9749/euroncap_ford_focus_1999...
- gambiting 5y agoI don't think these ratings should be considered as absolutes, not can they be compared between years. Your car was a 4-star car when compared against other models introduced that year - if you were to replace it with another 1999 vehicle, you'd need to look for the same level of standards applied back then. But yeah, of course it's going to do worse against a 2022 model - but it doesn't automatically make it a coffin on wheels either.
- Hamuko 5y agoWell, part of that is that crashing a 1999 Ford Focus into a 2021 Chevrolet Movie Theater will probably not be in the Focus' favour.
- numpad0 5y agoZero!? How!? Also I don't understand what it has to do with the fact that this is an electric propulsion car, 4-5 star NCAP rating had been basically standard for years IIUC.
- dm319 5y agoHave a look through recent NCAPs, there have been several 1-3 star ratings even in the last few years.
- dm319 5y agoI've had a recent fascination with the NCAP tests, and a lot of people aren't aware that they change almost yearly. I saw this [1] recent video recently looking at some of the worst crash tests, and it really drills home that good safety is to do with a good design rather than the class of car. It's also a reminder of just how scary a 30mph collision is, especially at just the wrong angle. We had a death on the road I live on recently where a relatively modren Mercedes hit a tree. It happened in the early hours of the morning so I'm sure this was > 30mph collision, one dead and two in a critical state. It reminds you that at high speeds these tests don't mean that much. I wonder if they will start to look at the rear seats more, especially for children. There is a high rate of serious head injury for children in anything other than the middle seat, and I feel this is something that is only starting to be looked at. Not to mention the 3rd row of seats doesn't seem to tested at all. Another interesting point is that this testing is voluntary. There are some very expensive cars on the road that not tested! [1] https://youtu.be/uFQkRpeC294 https://youtu.be/uFQkRpeC294
- perl4ever 5y ago>It reminds you that at high speeds these tests don't mean that much. That's a glass-half-empty outlook. Another way to look at it, is that when you're going 60, 70 mph, or more, nothing will save you, so you might as well drive anything you feel like, from a classic car with no airbags to a motorcycle. And I don't doubt that Mercedes was going a lot faster than 30. I see people going at least 50 on city streets posted for 30 just to get in front for the next traffic light.
- dm319 5y agoThe irrationality displayed on my daily commute made me so excited for self-driving cars - it's a shame we're further away from that than I realised. Yes, I alternate between a motorcycle and largish SUV to get to work. I had a hairy moment when my lane slowed suddenly from 70 > 20mph on the motorway. There was a car and a lorry in front of me, and car and lorry that looked like it was having trouble slowing behind me. To my right was a lane with a lorry doing 70 still, and to my left were barriers. For a split second I thought I was going to be crushed and there was nothing I could about it. Weirdly I fancied my chances better if I'd been on my bike as I could have moved to the side.
- soheil 5y agoIs it possible to receive negative stars?
- gambiting 5y agoNo - zero stars is still legally allowed to be sold. If it were to get below 0 stars, as in - actively unsafe - then it would not receive certification at all and not be allowed for sale(and in fact there were some cars that have been refused certification in the EU, some chinese designs that basically offered zero crumple zones and folded on themselves in a crash, that kind of thing)
- tialaramex 5y agoAll of these programmes, NCAP, EuroNCAP, and others like them around the world, are entirely advisory. The government makes rules for what you can sell, but the safety standards involved are much less stringent than you'd see in these advisory programmes. In some cases the same test centres are used (since after all they have the equipment) but the tests done are way easier than for say EuroNCAP. For example it has been years since the point where you weren't going to get anywhere in the advisory tests without airbags, but most places they aren't a legal requirement for new cars (there is often a rule saying they must work if they are fitted but no requirement to fit them). The funding is very different. For your car to be legal to sell new (at volume) you must pass the government tests, including in many countries a single destructive (ie writes off the car) test, and the government won't pay for that. If, say, Volvo, decided it wasn't interested in the UK market now that they're non-EU, it needn't submit new Volvo models, and then such new models just can't be sold in the UK no matter how safe they obviously are. In contrast the advisory tests are voluntary, often a manufacturer will pay for their products to be tested e.g. they might say to EuroNCAP, "We made a new mid-range family car, you can buy a basic model for about €40k so here's €40k" and then EuroNCAP buys a suitable model from a dealer (this avoid the scenario where a manufacturer ships the tester a specially hardened test vehicle) with their €40k and runs tests. But they don't have to pay, if Volvo decided they hate these tests, and won't pay for them, but they still provide cars for government tests, either the advisory test outfits buy the cars with their own funds or they don't test the Volvo models any more, but either way they are still legal to buy. I mentioned above that volume matters because of destructive testing. If you build your own car, from scratch, in most places the government says OK, fine, nobody does that, and obviously it's probably a death trap, but clearly there's only one of these we can't very well destructively test that one, so long as you meet some very basic requirements (e.g. no ludicrously over-size vehicles, nothing that's obviously going to kill other road users) you can drive that, although you may not be allowed to sell it to anybody as a car.
- robertkrahn01 5y agoDan Luu's "How do cars fare in crash tests they're not specifically optimized for?" comes to mind. https://danluu.com/car-safety/ https://danluu.com/car-safety/
- h1fra 5y agoRating system should always contain the year of the rating. It would help keep the context, basically if you show "5 stars 2013" -> "0 stars 2021", you understand that the tests has changed not the rating.
- mrich 5y agoDumb question, for a given model, how many cars are destroyed in such tests? Are they bought on the market or just gifted by the manufacturer?
- bigmattystyles 5y agoTIL the British spell curb (US) kerb.
- ectopod 5y agoWe Brits still curb our enthusiasm. Kerbs are just the things on roads.