4 ms·
> "artificially" amplifying information Isn't that the whole point of Twitter?
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
> "artificially" amplifying information
Isn't that the whole point of Twitter?
- sva_ 5y agoMaybe they mean that activity on the account has been retweeted/liked by bots a lot? Seems like social media engagement amplification is all the rage nowadays. Good way to get an account suspended, I suppose.
- q1w2 5y agoI think what they meant was that they detected bot activity associated with the account.
- logicalmonster 5y agoThere's multiple huge problems if Twitter takes this approach to rules enforcement even if they're genuinely trying to be honest and unbiased. 1) Every account on Twitter has "bot activity associated with this account": if for no other reason that random advertising bots retweet, follow, or like random people and posts to attempt to blend in as a genuine account and hide their true purpose. This reasoning gives Twitter essentially carte blanche to delete everybody, even assuming they were willing to be fully transparent about the evidence surrounding their bans (which they're not). 2) Bad Actors can easily sabotage accounts they dislike. Here's just 1 method how this can be done: there's 10,001 shady fly by night firms in India, Pakistan, Nigeria, Bangladesh, Vietnam, and other countries that offer services to "buy followers" or "buy retweets". It's trivial for somebody without programming skill and even a few hundred dollars to just buy mass spam and shill the hell out of an account (the lower quality the better) until somebody notices and that account gets banned. You don't even have to assign bad motives to Twitter to see the obvious problems here.
- afavour 5y agoI suspect a key difference here is “all of the users other twitter accounts”. If a bunch of accounts registered to the same email address all start boosting each other that’s probably pretty easy to detect, and distinct from someone else trying to do it to you.
- joshuamorton 5y agoYou appear to be assuming that the entire team of people at twitter who work on these problems either haven't considered or aren't able to address these issues. While there often are challenges with moderation and rules enforcement, this kind of stuff is pretty easy to address.
- dmpk2k 5y agoGiven that I have wrestled with 2) in a different context, I'm quite interested in hearing the various (hopefully realistic) methods to address it. Actually serious.
- logicalmonster 5y agoI would like to know too. But if you look at that profile, he says he works at Google. Think about that for a second. He claims this is an easy problem. But consider Google's approach to spam detection algorithms and see how there are so many false positives and innocent people getting screwed out of their ad accounts and livelihood. If this kind of stuff was easy, why hasn't anybody informed Google about it? I'm not trying to pick on anybody here, but I believe there's a level of arrogance in thinking that this form of sabotage is somehow a solvable problem unless you somehow have access to all communications on the planet.
- joshuamorton 5y agoI very specifically said that there were hard problems, just that this wasn't one ;) In this case, a fairly straightforward account age rule would get you like 95% of the way there. My twitter account, which is 7 years old and has a few hundred followers and tweets once a week isn't going to benefit from this. You don't ban it. Similarly, you don't ban a 7 year old account with 10s of thousands of followers that's been doing the same kind of tweeting for 2 years and recently got a bunch of bot follows. On the other hand, a 3 week old account with a ton of bot follows is suspicious. This'll miss older accounts that were unused and changed (e.g. if my account suddenly started tweeting 17x a day about divisive political content and suddenly got a bunch of bot follows, so you need slightly fancier approaches). You probably further improve this with some kind of multifaceted account realness score based on a pagerank like analysis of followers (following bots lowers your score, as does being followed by them). And ofc you still ban the bots, but you don't punish any accounts above a certain threshold of "real". The other part of it is that randomly sabotaging twitter accounts isn't going to happen very often, it costs money, and unless there's an ROI (extorting people), no one is going to do it except a handful of people for teh lulz or whatever. But importantly, most of those people will be bad at doing this kind of attack in a convincing way. There are lots of difficult problems, but OP chose one that doesn't happen and is straightforward to address.
- errcorrectcode 5y agoIt depends if Twitter's censors agree with the views expressed or not.
- mountainb 5y agoThere should be a federal law that requires that these moderation teams keep extensive records of their censorship work product in order to maintain their immunity. This censorship work product would then be have to be made available in discovery. Lawsuits challenging a censorship action or account suspension relating to censorship should be granted an exception to the otherwise binding arbitration agreement. The purpose of this would be to deter ad hoc political censorship, and to instead encourage these companies to move towards a more procedure driven censorship system in which they simply respond to court orders and leave everything else up. So, for example, if I sued the John Doe operating this account for copyright infringement or if a law enforcement agency won a court order to get the account taken down for posting illegal pornography, that's fine, that's how things are supposed to work. If instead the service is just arbitrarily censoring people, they have to keep strict records of their work products and produce those records in discovery. The companies would also have a hard time deflecting responsibility onto individual censors because almost anything that they could possibly do would be within the scope of their employment. Yes, this would make what most of these companies do with their censorship teams economically impractical. That's the point.
- joshuamorton 5y agoUnder what claim would you file a lawsuit against a private company about censorship? Or are you asking for the first amendment to be repealed?
- ttybird 5y agoI thought that the first amendment was about people rather than companies. In addition to that there are many products where companies have to display certain information, such as age rating for games, health warrnings on cigaretts, food content, allergy warning, nutrition labels, medicine side-effects, etc It is hard to classify censorship as speech for a site that it is all about user-content.
- kube-system 5y ago"artificial" is the key word -- it is referring to intentional manipulation rather than legitimate engagement.
- barney54 5y agoAnd what does that mean?
- kube-system 5y agoTheir own descriptions are quite detailed: https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/platform-manipulation https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/platform-mani...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoAgain...is that not the whole point of twitter? Their _entire_ business model is predicated on their algorithm manipulating engagement. There's very little "organic" engagement on social media any more.
- pohl 5y agoIs the point of your home to allow me to live there?
- mc32 5y agoIt’s building a community center but not letting the fat kids come play.
- kube-system 5y agoEvery community center I am familiar with has rules about the types of events that can be held there. Even more so when they're owned by specific interest groups.
- dang 5y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29484989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29484989.