4 ms·
Many people are forced out of rural areas due to the availability of work. I would prefer a rural area with some land, but it's difficult to find a good job in
by giantg2 5y ago
Many people are forced out of rural areas due to the availability of work. I would prefer a rural area with some land, but it's difficult to find a good job in those areas.
- cheriot 5y agoThose people get screwed the most by high rent and long commutes... that are the direct result of prohibiting dense housing.
- giantg2 5y agoHow so? My comment is that many people who prefer living in lower density areas are forced out due to lack of jobs in those areas.
- kaibee 5y agoIf you had a smooth transition between high and low density, the total area covered by housing would be smaller. So oddly enough, even the lowest density housing would now be closer to jobs in the city. Furthermore, since public transport makes more sense for those in the 'middle'-density area, there would be less for those who choose to drive in from the low-density area. https://missingmiddlehousing.com/ https://missingmiddlehousing.com/
- giantg2 5y agoWhy don't we address the root cause - location and density of the jobs? No reason most of them have to be clustered together, or even in the same city as others.
- cheriot 5y agoBecause people moving to a city from a rural area have been making a lower salary and are now facing the high costs of a city. An engineer with a signing bonus can make the transition smoothly, but the people forced out of rural areas often don't get them. The corollary to high housing prices is that people sprawl outward for lower prices and end up with very long commutes. Around me, ~40% of SF renters are paying more than 30% of income on housing. I for get the portion of people super commuting (> 90 minutes each way) but the % grows when SF adds more offices. So prohibitions on dense housing screw over people that want a rural life, but are forced to take jobs in a city. They'll have a harder time even saving up to go back.
- giantg2 5y agoOk, so you assumed they moved to a city. "So prohibitions on dense housing screw over people that want a rural life, but are forced to take jobs in a city." According to the article in this post, people prefer lower density housing. I don't see how adding more higher density housing will meaningfully change that. Because as you make the commutes shorter, etc you entice more people to move there.
- cheriot 5y agoPeople prefer housing they can’t afford. Allowing housing of different densities allows people to optimize their trade offs.
- giantg2 5y agoCities do allow housing of different densities depending on location (zone). Why would mixed density make it any better, especially when the article/study already says people prefer low density housing?
- cheriot 5y agoNot really. In practice, there's a small area for apartment complexes and then a huge area for single family exclusive housing. In places without strict zoning, there's a whole spectrum of things https://missingmiddlehousing.com https://missingmiddlehousing.com The goal is that when prices go up, there should be a way for people to build more homes that have a reasonable commute.
- giantg2 5y agoThat depends on which cities we're looking at. We also have to look at percentage and not just area. If we're packing people in 10:1, then the space can be 5-10% of the area and hold a large portion of population. This may be sufficient based on the desires of the people (back to the article).we "The goal is that when prices go up, there should be a way for people to build more homes that have a reasonable commute." If they can't, then that should encourage employers to look elsewhere and move.
- Gibbon1 5y agoI think you are the path to where I am. Which is society is pay an very steep price so that upper managers can live where they want and force everyone else to come to them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikepurvis 5y agoHasn't one of the big lessons of COVID been that anyone can work from anywhere that there's a decent internet connection?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Hasn't one of the big lessons of COVID been that anyone can work from anywhere that there's a decent internet connection? No, one of the biggest lessons of COVID is that lots of people can't, and being in a field where you can can be a massive advantage in certain circumstances, which accelerates inequality when those manifest because it correlates strongly (though not perfectly) with higher income work.
- giantg2 5y agoMaybe as a Dev or similar, but that's not true for all industries. Even as a dev, there are many companies that don't allow fully remote, like mine.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> I would prefer a rural area with some land, but it's difficult to find a good job in those areas. Ironically, that's because we restrict density in cities. Suppose you have a city, San Francisco, ~17,000 people per square mile. About a quarter of what it is in Manhattan. For the same number of people, if the density was higher, the city would cover less area. And then the number of miles away from the city center you would have to go before you were living with cows would go down.
- giantg2 5y agoThe article in the post suggests otherwise. Right in the abstract it says that people prefer lower density. So if living in a rural area is now more attractive because it's a shorter distance, more people will choose to live there. There are entire regions with small cities and towns where the commute is already reasonable, but the companies choose to bunch together in the biggest cities. Just look at Appalachia - plenty of small cities to choose from with vacant factories to be repurposed, vacant housing from population shrinkage, etc. It all boils down to choices, and it's very difficult to influence those choices - where company locate, where people want to live, etc.
- marcosdumay 5y agoThe bottleneck isn't exactly number of miles until you see cows, it's minutes driven. That is, rural folks would be much happier if the city had more density and a great public transit system that integrates with cars. But just the density would make things worse.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI wouldn't call that being forced, I'd call that weighing your priorities and making a decision. Where I live, you can pay your own rent alone working a full time minimum wage job. If you're turning that down, the trade off isn't worth it. You would rather live in a densely packed place if it enables you to do professional work not available to you otherwise. It's always a trade off.
- giantg2 5y agoThat seems to imply there are enough jobs in the area for the population. That might be true today, but in the prior decade it can be tough to find a minimum wage job with benefits.
- betwixthewires 5y ago> with benefits Again, a trade off. Why are benefits sacrosanct when we talk about this? Why is anything? If a rural town doesn't have enough business to go around to support it's population, it shrinks. It becomes more rural. People make trade offs. Cities get denser. When it has enough business to support a larger population, it grows. When a city becomes unable to support it's population, it decays. People move away. There's an ebb and flow. But it is important to understand that nobody is being forced to do anything here, they're moving where their priorities are, no place is perfect, it's all about what you're willing to live with to get the benefits of where you live.
- giantg2 5y ago"Again, a trade off. Why are benefits sacrosanct when we talk about this?" Because we're talking about supporting oneself. You can't support yourself with a minimum wage job and paying healthcare out of pocket.
- betwixthewires 5y agoYes you can. I literally live in a small community of people who mostly work minimum wage service jobs and support themselves just fine, have disposable income even. That's my whole point. If you live in an urban environment it is hard to see how someone could do it, I understand, but you need to understand just how much cheaper it is to live in a place where you're not competing with 100 people for a place to live. When your rent is 350 bucks a month you can 100% support yourself on 1000 bucks a month, paying for insurance out of pocket.
- jltsiren 5y agoThose people voluntarily leave rural areas due to their personal preferences. They would rather have a good job in an area that can support them than live in a pleasant area with worse job prospects. People are rarely interested in living in dense urban areas due to the density itself. They are usually far more interested in the consequences of the density and the opportunities enabled by it.
- giantg2 5y agoIt depends on what you consider voluntary. If you can't get a job in your hometown, then it doesn't feel very voluntary when forced to move to support yourself (survive). Sure, it's a choice but there's pressure behind it. If someone says give me your wallet or I'll stab you, that's still a choice. I wouldn't call it voluntary. It's a choice of survival.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI've responded about this already, but nobody is really forced to move to the city. They can get jobs, just not the job they want. You have to provide a service to your local economy, and in small towns, that means mending fences and cooking barbecue and working on cars. Thankfully the low density also means you can afford to pay your bills doing jobs like that. Some people want to do something they consider more rewarding and meaningful, its like the age old trope of the small town girl moving to Los Angeles to be a movie star. They move to the city because it's a trade off, their priorities tell them that living in a more densely packed environment will make their life better. But at the end of the day, it is always a choice.
- giantg2 5y agoNobody is forced to do anything ever. Everything is a choice.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoExactly. People can even choose to die instead of doing something they don't want to do.