7 ms·
> However, once again, politics and dismissal of “unfair” tactics led to a lack of bolstered defense at Pearl Habor and an unwillingness to restructure the U.S.
by ceejayoz 5y ago
> However, once again, politics and dismissal of “unfair” tactics led to a lack of bolstered defense at Pearl Habor and an unwillingness to restructure the U.S. Navy.
We still haven't learned from this.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002
"After the war game was restarted, its participants were forced to follow a script drafted to ensure a Blue Force victory. Among other rules imposed by this script, Red Force was ordered to turn on their anti-aircraft radar in order for them to be destroyed, and during a combined parachute assault by the 82nd Airborne Division and Marines air assaulting on the then new and still controversial CV-22, Van Riper's forces were ordered not to shoot down any of the approaching aircraft. Van Riper also claimed that exercise officials denied him the opportunity to use his own tactics and ideas against Blue Force, and that they also ordered Red Force not to use certain weapons systems against Blue Force and even ordered the location of Red Force units to be revealed."
- quantified 5y agoAnd yet the only way we fought for independence against the British back in the day was by doing it “unfairly”. We’ve so lost touch with our mojo.
- dTal 5y agoIt is frightening that the world's largest arsenal is under the control of such an irrational institution. Here's a favorite HN comment of mine, about the US Navy - "zero capability to accurately assess risk or fix problems beyond punishing people when things inevitably go wrong". https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15120369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15120369
- kingcharles 5y ago> Here's a favorite HN comment of mine, about the US Navy - "zero capability to accurately assess risk or fix problems beyond punishing people when things inevitably go wrong". This sums up the whole US justice system too.
- Steltek 5y agoI recall an HN comment that the Van Riper story leaves out some details. Like, while he used motorcycle couriers, they were simulated. In network terms, they had low latency and no "packet loss". But it sounds funny, so it gets repeated without the qualifications. Same thing with the F-15 vs F-22 fight, where the F-22's had to visually identify targets before engaging, stripping them of advantages. That said, I don't think the US Navy is prepared for drone zerg tactics. I hope I'm wrong.
- foxyv 5y agoEven the MQ-9 has a top speed of 200 knots. Way too slow to overwhelm defenses. Most drones are hardly better than a typical fighter jet or a cruise missile. Cruise missiles have been around for decades now and we have pretty good defenses for them. Drones cheap enough to be produced in massive quantities cannot carry enough payload to be effective against modern ships unless you are in such a short range you may as well shoot a shell at the target. However, the autonomous F-16 project is something else. Small radar cross section, datalink guided missiles, AIM-120Ds and ship killer missiles on an autonomous fighter platform is just scary.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Way too slow to overwhelm defenses. Doesn't much matter if the battle group runs out of ammo. They've only got a few hundred anti-aircraft missiles between them; hundreds of drones wouldn't be fun to have to deal with. Imagine a thousand of something like these: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/military/kamikaze-drones-new-weapon-brings-power-peril-u-s-military-n1285415 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/military/kamikaze-drones-new-we... lining the Strait of Hormuz.
- enkid 5y agoThey don't have to use a missile to shoot down every drone. [0] That being said, it's a good question, how many drones could a destroyer shoot down, between the missiles, CIWS systems and other defensive equipment? I have a feeling it's a lot, but I have nothing actually supporting that. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phalanx_CIWS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phalanx_CIWS
- PKop 5y agoHappened again recently [0] "Royal Marines commandos 'dominated' US troops and forced them into a humiliating surrender just days into a mass training exercise in the Mojave desert, it has been revealed today. British forces took part in a five-day mock battle at the US Marine Corps' Twentynine Palms base in southern California, one of the largest military training areas in the world, and achieved a decisive victory against their American counterparts. The Royal Marines, along with allied forces from Canada, the Netherlands and the UAE, destroyed or rendered inoperable nearly every US asset and finished the exercise holding more than 65 per cent of the training area, after beginning with less than 20 per cent. Combatants used paintball-style training ammunition, which fires with reduced pressure and velocity, along with hi-tech simulators for heavier firepower like artillery, and live ammo on expansive ranges. Seeing no opportunity for victory, American combatants asked for the exercise to be 'reset' halfway through the five-day exercise, having taken significant casualties from British commandos. " [0] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10159949/Royal-Marines-commandos-force-troops-humiliating-surrender-training-exercise.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10159949/Royal-Mari...
- ceejayoz 5y agoResets, on their own, aren't an issue, and the goal is for one side to win and learn something. If you can slip two exercises instead of one into a five day visit, why not? There's nothing in that article that asserts the sort of "reset, then script it to ensure the 'good guys' win" scenario from the 2002 case.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- triactual 5y agoThis does make great propaganda for the Brits until you know that they were actually part of a larger element, under the command of US 7th Marine Regiment. This exercise demonstrated integration of NATO commando forces and modern tactics against outdated tactics.
- clutchdude 5y ago
- chaostheory 5y agoI remember this one, thinking it was isolated prior to knowing about the Pearl Harbor exercises. Is declaring “unfair” tactics just a US Navy tradition or do other branches do the same thing?
- q1w2 5y agoWhat I find even more interesting, was that the US demonstrated for Japan the winning tactic to attack Pearl Harbor... > Unbeknownst to the U.S. military at the time, we now know that Japan had been watching Admiral Yarnell’s 1932 mock attack with keen interest. > Tokyo’s spy organization in Oahu had observers across the island that relayed information back to Japan - which studied and absorbed the lessons the U.S. Navy failed to learn. This speak volumes about how the results of war games need to remain classified. ...in the same way you would want a pen-test you've contracted out to remain confidential. If it's public, you give your adversary a blueprint for attacking you.
- Kalium 5y agoHaving occasionally worked with pen-tests, I think perhaps a different lesson is in order. If you can find it in a pen test, so can your adversaries. You have no way of knowing if they've done so already. The best way forward is to address the issues as quickly as is reasonably possible. Secrecy protects the pen-test findings document, but not your vulnerability. The map should never be confused for the territory.
- baud147258 5y ago> Red Force was ordered to turn on their anti-aircraft radar in order for them to be destroyed active search radars would be very visible targets and be targetted by any opposing force, especially if they are planning for an air drop, no? I don't disagree there was some egregrious rules, but I don't think it was one of them
- wikidani 5y agoI also believe it wasn't. Western air forces put a very big emphasis on SEAD operations. And given the fact that they are simulating an attack on soviet made (which they have fought against on multiple occasions) air defence just turning off the radar is delaying the inevitable.
- wikidani 5y agoThere's an issue with Millenium challenge though. General Van Riper gamed the system heavily. For example, he claimed to use motorcycle messengers instead of radios, but transmitted on radio anyways. He also tried to "use" fast attack craft carrying silkworm anti ship missiles that wouldn't even fit on the type of craft he described on the exercise. It's also worth noting that many wargames are similarly scripted to account for external factors
- pmezard 5y agoInterestingly, "Shattered Sword" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shattered_Sword https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shattered_Sword) a modern book about the battle of Midway, from the Japanese point of view, starts with something similar. Japanese navy did wargames before the attack, and one of the admiral of Red Force acted similarly to what the American navy did, positioning his force north-east of Midway, and inflicted heavy damages to the invading force. Yamamoto, the author of the plan and the navy top chief, shut him off and forced everyone to replay following his rules, ensuring the success of his plan. I recommend the book, well written and approachable to casual readers like me. A lot of details about carrier operations, fog of war and visual representations of attack vectors and bomb hits and their outcome. Also, Drachinifels had a good session/interview about the book with Jon Parshall, one of its author: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN79g34wjQA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN79g34wjQA
- jeffdn 5y agoAn excellent book! Have you read Ian Toll's books about the Pacific War? Similarly well-written and super in depth.
- credit_guy 5y agoTo this I would add Craig Symonds' "The Battle of Midway".