5 ms·
> Beware that semi-educated guesses are sometimes worse than uneducated > ones, since they are more plausible and not necessarily more correct. This is one o
by dotancohen 5y ago
> Beware that semi-educated guesses are sometimes worse than uneducated
> ones, since they are more plausible and not necessarily more correct.
This is one of the most insightful comments I've read on the internet ever.
This is why we shouldn't take medical advice from people who have read a few Wikipedia articles. This is why years of experience in e.g. software are necessary to even begin to understand how deeply hidden security issues can be. This is why self-driving cars still elude us, but will be so much safer than human drivers when they finally do arrive.
- dekhn 5y agoThe way I state the above point is: "The smartest people in the room are the most skilled at convincing people (including themselves) of a narrative that sounds logical but is wrong".
- sgt101 5y ago>This is why self-driving cars still elude us, but will be so much safer than human drivers when they finally do arrive. Isn't that just a by definition thing? My Tesla can already drive itself, I don't trust it and I don't think it's safe. When I get one that I trust and is safe then it will be safer than me, and by extension other humans. The problem is that the current generation of algorithms are brittle.
- blamestross 5y agoThe "just put a brick on the gas pedal" algorithm was particularly prone to crashing.
- dotancohen 5y agoYes, but it had the lowest CPU and memory footprint! There's also something to be said about the COTS hardware requirements and ease of installation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jl6 5y ago> This is one of the most insightful comments I've read on the internet ever. On the other hand, if I’m in the market for a guess, I’ll probably go for the educated guess rather than the uneducated one, because even though I recognize it’s not necessarily more correct, it probably is less wrong.
- ALittleLight 5y agoSometimes it's better to know you don't know than to think you know. If it's midnight and you're standing at the edge of a cliff you're better off thinking that you have no idea what's ahead of you than if you listen to a guy with "better than average night vision" telling you that there's a sidewalk ahead.
- MarcoZavala 5y ago
- Beltiras 5y agoBeing less wrong is probably as good as it ever gets.
- mnsc 5y agoIf you are, as you say, "in the market for a guess" that would imply that you are actively looking at different guesses and comparing the credentials of the guessers. Then you would _probably_ be right to choose eg. the guess from the virologist over the proctologist or the mechanic when you need a guess on how the Covid situation will unfold. But the issue might be that an "educated guess" in itself could be worse because you wouldn't base any major decisions on a mechanic that present an "uneducated guess" that "the virus will die down in a month" but if you have a crackpot chiropractor presenting themselves as a "certified doctor with an expertise in everything concerning the body" that says the same thing, you might be worse off in saying that this "educated guess" is worth basing your travel plans on.
- heavenlyblue 5y ago
- baq 5y agoyou might be interested in Kahneman's body of work, especially 'Thinking, Fast and Slow'.
- belter 5y agoI am afraid many times when talking about educated guesses we mean schooled guesses. The problem is that, more than once, we learn per Mark Twain's famous quote ...that schooling has a way of interfering with education...:-) Specially for subtle but critical concepts: "Researchers misunderstand confidence intervals and standard error bars" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16392994/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16392994/
- armchairhacker 5y agoI was thinking the opposite point: sometimes the experienced doctor or researcher made a mistake, and the guy who posted something on Reddit is correct. Usually not, but sometimes. Generally speaking, you should trust someone whose professional or experienced more than some random stranger. Especially if it's not one person but a large group of experienced professionals (most of the controversial "anti-science" issues today). But it's actually important to "do your own research", and not just listen to authority. Provided you actually know how, i.e. you can find accurate sources and distinguish fact from fiction. Because even the most qualified, unbiased, genius authority are occasionally wrong. The big issue today is that a lot of people don't know how to research and distinguish lies, but (although it's probably impossible for most) finding a way to teach someone how to find the truth, will always be more effective having some authority tell them the truth. Key example: doctors often miss symptoms and diagnoses that a patient can discover on their own. It's not that the doctor is stupid or unqualified, in fact they have way more medical knowledge than you. But the doctor only has a series of questions and maybe a few tests to make a diagnosis, whereas you have the full experience of symptoms and an internal understanding of your "normal". IMO people actually should "play Internet doctor" and research their symptoms, not to reach any 100% conclusions, but to suggest diagnoses and tests to their real doctor.
- dotancohen 5y ago> IMO people actually should "play Internet doctor" and research their symptoms, not to reach any 100% conclusions, but to suggest diagnoses and tests to their real doctor. I agree, and do this. But I never tell the doctor "I suspect that I have X", rather I tell the doctor "I've observed J, K, and L under Foo conditions" and let the doctor decide where to go from there. In short time we can learn to give the doctors better information, but we cannot replace their breadth of knowledge.
- armchairhacker 5y agoYeah sometimes people say "doctor I have X, I'm trying to get diagnosed with X". You're biasing the doctor to give you a diagnosis so you don't drop them, and you're biasing the doctor to ignore your symptoms because you're just saying them to get the diagnosis and maybe you just want to get certain medication. Even if you don't outright say it, you should never convince yourself you have a diagnosis. The human body is extremely complex and some particularly weird issues need patient research, doctor's research, and experimentation to solve.
- codexcodexcodex 5y agoHe's just saying n=1. Medical advice on the internet can be n=1, but read enough to get to n=100+, while still limited, can be quite valuable. I can't ask 100 doctors what’s wrong with me, but I can ask my question to hundreds in an online forum. They might lead me astray, but so can a single doctor’s misdiagnosis. A doctor can prescribe treatment that helps or harms, but I can ask a forum of people, with the same problem I have, if I should take his advice. I can't, however, ask 100 of his colleagues or peers if I should trust his advice, and that's why we end up with so many charlatans in medicine. But he's a doctor. Of course you can trust him! I don't know about the rest of you, but I've found a fair number of doctors to be mostly useless.