5 ms·
This paper is a good rebuttal to talking points like this tweet that crop up from time to time: https://i.redd.it/b57t1w5jllb61.jpg https://i.redd.it/b57t1w5jll
by pydry 5y ago
This paper is a good rebuttal to talking points like this tweet that crop up from time to time: https://i.redd.it/b57t1w5jllb61.jpg https://i.redd.it/b57t1w5jllb61.jpg
(I was trying to look up a similarly awful article referencing EMTs earning $minwage + $2 I saw a while back but googlefu is failing me)
- bloqs 5y agoI must be missing something because to me that's literally the point - the minimum wage should cause other, more complex work wages to rise?
- pydry 5y agoYes, the tweet above presumes that they wouldnt and that it would be somehow unfair if a minimum wake hike meant that a teacher got paid minimum wage. Most arguments against raising the minimum wage are bullshit but they all get trotted out regularly because profits are at stake.
- DocTomoe 5y agoIf all wages rise (and in turn, cost of living rises accordingly, because now people can afford to pay more rent), nothing will have changed.
- stavros 5y ago"No it does not. Raise teachers' salaries."
- RankingMember 5y agoYeah, what's the deal with this crabs in a bucket mindset that underlies memes like that? It's like the creator wants to perpetuate stagnant wages.
- teekert 5y agoIt's shocking how little we pay the people that spend so much time with our kids.
- bsagdiyev 5y agoIt’s a big problem. When we moved to NC my girlfriend started working at my son’s school (preschool). The $17/hr she gets is considered the top end of the pay range for her job… $17/hr! She’s got a college degree!
- randomdata 5y ago> She’s got a college degree! Is that significant? The preschool I send my child to's child care provider has a boat. Neither factor into my purchasing decision. Everyone is going to have hobbies of some sort outside of work. How much I will pay isn't going to change depending on what hobbies they have chosen.
- bsagdiyev 5y agoYeah that makes no sense. I would prefer my child is taught by someone who is at least accredited by the state. Of which a college degree is typically required. My point though was that she attended college and earns a shit wage, whereas I didn’t graduate high school but fell in to tech. Most tech jobs provide absolutely no value to the planet, mine included, compared to the value a teacher provides children.
- randomdata 5y ago> My point though was that she attended college Your point is unclear. What difference does this make? She could have once travelled to the moon, but that wouldn't make her participation in the same job worth more. The buyers of services pay for the work being done, not for what you may have done in the past. They do not care about your hobbies. Do you think people are paying less for the software you help create because you didn't graduate from high school? Of course not. They couldn't care less. They are only concerned about what the software can do for them. > Most tech jobs provide absolutely no value to the planet, mine included, compared to the value a teacher provides children. Problem is that childcare doesn't scale very well. A single person can only care for so many children, especially when they are young. This means that the cost can only be distributed across so many parents. If the cost to the parents is too high, the parents will stay home and provide that care themselves. In contrast, a 99¢ app across many millions of customers provides very nice scalability and a fortune for those involved in it. Per customer, the childcare provider is paid substantially more, but is limited to how many customers they can have. Perhaps someone with a college degree should be using their experience to solve for the scalability issues, but a hobby one had in the past is no indication that they have interest in continuing with that hobby, so it is unrealistic to place that expectation on anyone.
- mdorazio 5y agoI read that comment to be implying that teachers are underpaid. Are you sure it's meant the other way?
- vultour 5y agoThis is one of the worst arguments one could ever make. Literally the same as telling someone your salary and they go "wow, you're so overpaid, I make less than half that!". No motherfucker, you should be making more money. It's insane that instead of advocating for higher salaries people will attempt to drag each other down.
- pydry 5y agoPretty much every argument against raising the minimum wage is disingenous in some way, but a lot of profits are at stake so we will get to hear them all eventually.
- sovnade 5y agoBut this is the goal, and it works. The people who own the media don't want wages to go up. Lobbyists, anti-union groups, etc...it's much easier to get 2 lower income people mad at each other than to justify their own income to them. Outrage and anger is an easy sell and unfortunately that's what the 24/7 for-profit news cycle is.
- ralfd 5y agoBut what is the end game here? Salaries are also the prices we pay for services/products. If everyone has higher salaries than everyone has to pay more => Inflation. And we are back to square 1.
- colanderman 5y agoThe price we pay for services and products also depends on the cost of energy, raw materials, real estate, etc., required for those services and products, the price of which is fairly independent of minimum wage and is determined by supply & demand.
- wonderwonder 5y agoThis is a terrible rebuttal. It essentially says because society has decided to underpay the people that look after our kids for 8 hours a day, that no one else should be able to make money either. The correct take should be teachers are woefully underpaid for the work they do which includes looking after our kids in the event of a school shooter. Strange to me that so many people rally to keep their fellow citizens down. Not the good rebuttal you think it is.
- giantg2 5y agoTeachers in my state make a good living. I know some that make more than I (dev, MSIS, 10yrs exp.) do. Granted we're in the top 10 states for teacher pay. Some other states are woefully underpaid, but it's not universal.
- ahtihn 5y ago> in the event of a school shooter. The probability of this happening at any given school is so incredibly low it's really not worth factoring into any decision-making at all.
- wonderwonder 5y agoStatistically true but tell that to every school district that forces the teachers to lead live shooter drills every month. With that said though, shooters happen and teachers are in charge of ensuring the safety of their class when it does. Whether it happens or not its part of the job description. How would it play if there was a real school shooting and the teacher just ran away abandoning her class?