5 ms·
Who is MIT a turnoff for? It’s strictly more permissive on the consumer side than GPL is. Which isn’t to say anything about how a project ought to be licensed;
by woodruffw 5y ago
Who is MIT a turnoff for? It’s strictly more permissive on the consumer side than GPL is.
Which isn’t to say anything about how a project ought to be licensed; just that MIT enjoys overwhelming popularity with newer projects.
- rackjack 5y agoMIT vs GPL brought up again? Flame war! Flame war! Flame war!
- darthrupert 5y agoOk, let's go! You're stupid and probably ugly for wanting a flamewar!
- nirse 5y agoNo, he's right. We're rubber and you're glue!
- cakrome 5y agoWhat I know is if projects use permissive licenses, the software end users getting is usually proprietary. Copyleft is designed to prevent that from happening.
- torstenvl 5y agoIt doesn't matter if some other project is proprietary. The proprietary company's proprietary product was always going to be proprietary. What matters is whether they contribute back anything to open source. And it's a hell of a lot easier to get Legal to sign off on contributing back bug fixes and enhancements on a piecemeal basis rather than adding a recurring obligation to the books.
- karatinversion 5y ago> The proprietary company's proprietary product was always going to be proprietary. A lot is companies would have preferred to have proprietary operating systems, but the Linux license prevents them.
- zaarn 5y agoPlenty of companies aren't hindered by the Linux license as they are not required to give you the source most of the time, they just point you to their SoC vendor. Or worse, they just don't use Linux and use BSD or Windows Embedded instead. I don't see this as a valid point.
- josephcsible 5y ago> The proprietary company's proprietary product was always going to be proprietary. The point of copyleft is to make this not true. Most companies don't have the resources to reimplement Linux from scratch, so they won't be allowed to make their drivers/kernel modifications proprietary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- torstenvl 5y agoI know that's the theory, but I don't see that happening in practice. See, e.g., TiVo, Android, NVIDIA drivers...
- signa11 5y ago> Who is MIT a turnoff for? It’s strictly more permissive on the consumer side than GPL is. well, ever wondered why router vendors include GPL license paper in the box? this [1] is why... [1] https://www.crn.com/news/applications-os/205100091/busybox-settles-gpl-lawsuit.htm https://www.crn.com/news/applications-os/205100091/busybox-s...
- GhettoComputers 5y agoDidn’t they just switch to toybox? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toybox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toybox
- buzzert 5y ago> It’s strictly more permissive on the consumer side than GPL is. You have been misinformed. The GPL is a much better license for users. MIT is arguably better for the authors because they can deny certain freedoms to their users (the ability to change the code on a system, for instance).
- GhettoComputers 5y agoGPL3 or GPL2? After what github did with copilot, Chinese companies that don’t release source code, or western companies that do the same I don’t see any ways to enforce them, you just need to trust the authors or the users. Has there been a landmark case that solidifies any of this? Chinese companies don’t follow US IP either so I find it hard to believe they can do anything.
- woodruffw 5y agoAgain, not interested in arguing the actual ethics of the licenses. But I think most people would consider a license that allows modification without demanding redistribution to be more individually permissive than one that requires redistribution. Companies love MIT and it’s ilk, because it’s more permissive of their (arguably poor) behavior.
- TuringTest 5y agoThe fact that you need to add a specifier for that 'individually' permissive says everything about the difference in the licenses' goals.
- josephcsible 5y agoIt's more permissive, true, but it's not more free. As an analogy, consider that taking away people's permission to own slaves didn't make society less free.
- deadbunny 5y agoHow does MIT prevent users changing the code? They have explicit permission to take the code and change it however they want.
- pjmlp 5y agoApple, Sony and Nintendo are quite happy with it. FreeBSD and clang communities, maybe not so much.
- gtsop 5y ago> Who is MIT a turnoff for? For me. I want my software to be as much gplv3 as possible. Not trolling. Also not arguing, it's just the way I roll.
- gtsop 5y agoI would honestly like to understand why the downvotes. I am giving a blatantly honest answer of a case of people like me who would be turned off by a licence. I don't expect anyone to necesserily agree but I don't get why my opinion is being downvoted. Is it insulting or irrelevant to the issue or what?
- johnisgood 5y agoI think it is a valid answer to a question that has been posed. I think the reason for the down-votes is that you did not elaborate on as to why MIT is a turnoff for you, and/or why you would rather prefer GPLv3 over MIT. ...or perhaps they did not like the last part of your comment, the "it's just the way I roll" one.
- gtsop 5y agoMaybe you're right. I thought it is understood why pro-gplv3 people like the licence. Just to elaborate then, I personally want my software to use gplv3 because I side with the ideological/ethical aspects of free software. I want to support projects/teams/orgs that build this future. An mit licence would allow a company to capitalise on the community's effort withought giving nothing back. Or even worse, make modifications and deliver closed source blobs to users. I personally do not like that. Thus, I wouldn't support/use this library. To be clear, I am not running 100% gpl software atm, but I see it as a journey going there, slowly transitioning.
- bayindirh 5y ago> Who is MIT a turnoff for? For me, for example. I personally prefer my foundations on xGPL (preferably V3 and later), because some company or set of companies just can't fork and run away with it. I personally consider computing utilities and compilers essential infrastructure and their sustainability while being completely transparent are critical for me.
- Aeolun 5y agoBut I work for a company, and I want to run off with these things.
- bayindirh 5y agoWhy obeying GPL and sharing your improvements is bad? RedHat built a company on that model? Provide value and GPL won't threaten your business model.
- Aeolun 5y agoIt’s not bad, it’s just that I’m not allowed to. I don’t like to inflict that on others. Seeing something useful and then having to do it myself anyway because I cannot use it due to the license is painful.
- KZerda 5y agoI'd argue the opposite. xGPL makes it easier for the founding company to just run away with it. We saw it with MongoDB, where it being AGPL means one company can control and unilaterally relicense it. Other examples I'd see of being GPLed doing little to nothing to prevent such shenanigans are any Oracle owned GPLed properties -- Java, MySQL, and VirtualBox all have user-hostile projects and misfeatures added even with the GPL. Conversely, permissive Free projects like LLVM and Postgres have had a lot harder time with one company controlling, because its non-copyleft nature means that everyone has a fair footing in controlling the direction.
- bayindirh 5y ago
- josephcsible 5y agoMIT is a turnoff for potential contributors, not for users. A lot of people don't want to see their work that was done without compensation end up in some company's proprietary fork.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoIs it much better that they just credit them in some obscure notes nobody reads?
- josephcsible 5y agoThe major issue is that the companies don't want to, in CC terms, "share alike". Attribution is a lesser concern.
- GhettoComputers 5y agoWouldn't you run into the same problem with a company that runs linux computers and never contributes back?