5 ms·
> How about an extension that disables video elements until you click on them ... Like how Internet Explorer treated Java applets towards the end on their days
by dragontamer 5y ago
> How about an extension that disables video elements until you click on them ... Like how Internet Explorer treated Java applets towards the end on their days.
No.
Short MP4 files should replace GIFs. MP4 files are more efficient than the terrible compression GIF files have. I've made a few video game pages where auto-playing MP4s were essential at giving the right message... discussion of tactics and "movement" of dynamic video game stuff is pretty common. (Any game requires the player to gain instincts that "predict the future", and short GIFs and/or MP4 files really help show off key moments).
Factorio thing I wrote a while back:
https://factorioguide.nfshost.com/backpressure.html https://factorioguide.nfshost.com/backpressure.html
- sroussey 5y agoNot sure why you are downvoted. Animated gifs are huge in comparison. One thing to note, however, is that it must be without sound. Auto playing sound of any sort is complete garbage.
- dragontamer 5y ago> One thing to note, however, is that it must be without sound. Auto playing sound of any sort is complete garbage. Agreed. I don't think I've ever felt the need to have autoplaying sound, and I struggle to think of any benefit from it. I'm willing to keep my mind open, if anyone knows of a good website that effectively creates an experience using autoplay sound, please give me it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sli 5y agoAll but demanding that the internet's users bend to the will of a single person's pet project is not likely to garner a positive response, if you must know.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> Not sure why you are downvoted. Because auto-playing motion is something I should be able to disable. It distracts me and I don’t want it. Ever.
- dragontamer 5y agoThere's the option of simply not visiting the webpages that offend you. I'm not going to change my writing / guide style just because some people outside of those gaming communities don't like the way they work. Its one thing if you were the target audience, its a totally different thing if you're just a meta-commentator talking about the internet in general.
- midasuni 5y agoMaybe that explains your results. Have a behaviour someone dislikes, they don't revisit, and thus don’t answer your survey question
- dragontamer 5y agoI ask on the community forums or on the Discords. These websites have no direct feedback mechanism. The feedback I get is like "That's a confusing paragraph", or "That's a bad strategy. You should be writing about X instead". No one actually cares about the auto-playing videos, unless they're not working. (On page X on Safari, that video doesn't seem to be working was one complaint I got... and then I had to transcode my MP4 settings to get it working there).
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> auto-playing MP4s were essential I never want auto playing videos. Ever. It is my personal preference and i should be able to express that in my browser, overriding your preference, as the author of the web page.
- nightpool 5y agoDo you have the same preference for auto-playing GIFs? If so then yes, we agree—users should be able to customize their user agent to serve their needs. If you don't, then I'd be interested to hear why. I don't believe any browser should treat GIFs and muted videos differently, and that was the crux of the GP's claim.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoAnimated GIFs are videos. They may not require a video tag, but they are videos by definition of using multi-frame images that change to simulate motion.
- notfed 5y agoGreat so the extension should disable gif animations as well, good point.
- Fnoord 5y agoIts too much abused. Just like gif was in 90s. The client has two important values: attention/time and battery. Your preference screws both. There's a couple of solutions to that (such as only looping once or for X seconds or not showing it). Either way, you think too much from content creator PoV, IMO. The web was made in such a way that clients are able to (massively) modify the content or the way it is shown. If you don't fancy that then you don't fancy one of the core foundations of the web. I use all kind of extensions to modify my web experience. If your PoV would become dominant, I simply would not use WWW anymore. Default experience matters because most people don't use extensions, or not the same ones (power users do) so you get your way anyway. And I don't get my way on Firefox Mobile because they decided to axe a lot of extensions, and I don't get my way on work Citrix because admins decided which extensions are worthwhile (they block all video stuff, btw).
- Supermancho 5y agoYou mean "yes and..." not no. Your post has no content explaining why you wrote "No." This is a bad habit that makes your sentiment confusing.
- cabalamat 5y ago> I've made a few video game pages where auto-playing MP4s were essential at giving the right message No. What you say is simply factually inaccurate. I've looked at the web page in your URL and it would be much better without distracting auto-playing video. The video should play then the user wants it to play. Is that really so hard to understand?
- pushrax 5y agoI agree completely. When there's a looping video below the fold, I'd rather start it with a click, instead of having to watch it up to twice just to see the clip from beginning to end.
- dragontamer 5y agoThen click the button to replay the clip from the beginning if that really is your problem. But you won't. Because the clips are 5 to 20 seconds long. So its faster to just wait for the loop than even to move your hand to the mouse.
- danachow 5y agoSeriously? It takes you 5 to 20 seconds to move your hand to the mouse?
- pushrax 5y agoI will seek when the option is presented. It’s either tiny or nonexistent though (e.g. for gifs, or if the author didn’t enable the video controls, which default to disabled in many browsers). I’m happiest when a video loads paused, and has a giant play button on it. How are you scrolling? When I’m browsing and reading my hand lives on the mouse. On mobile it’s even easier to click to play. In either case, clicking on a video takes less than 1 second. I do agree that extremely short loops can be a different story, but 20 seconds is by far over that time for me. 5 seconds is around the threshold. I’m sure this preference varies by person.
- 5y ago
- renewiltord 5y agoEveryone else here is wrong and you are right. The animated GIFs (as h.264 video or whatever) were the right play here. Safari didn't block no-sound-track video for this reason. It's a good reason.