3 ms·
This is a bad title. Other trends since 1910 (the last 110 years) - Electromagnetic wave use increase via radio, television, cell and internet, and microwaves
by tomrod 5y ago
This is a bad title. Other trends since 1910 (the last 110 years)
- Electromagnetic wave use increase via radio, television, cell and internet, and microwaves
- Maximum altitude humans have reached
- Number of bodies on Everest
- Increase in pounds of enriched uranium and available thorium
- Increase in the number of people who have read work by Ursula K. Le Guin and Isaac Asimov
None of these have causal implications. But the article does connect a qualitative theory and show correlation -- suggesting the hypothesis could be a thread to chase down.
This is the key thesis:
> According to the cold chain hypothesis, the development of industrial and domestic refrigeration has led to frequent exposure of human populations to bacteria capable of growing in the cold. These bacteria, at low levels of exposure, particularly those of the genus Yersinia, are believed to be capable of inducing exacerbated inflammation of the intestine in genetically predisposed subjects.
EDIT:
Title: Crohn’s Disease: Is the Cold Chain Hypothesis Still Hot?
Abstract:
> Crohn’s disease [CD] is an inflammatory bowel disease of unknown aetiology. During recent decades, significant technological advances led to development of -omic datasets allowing a detailed description of the disease. Unfortunately these have not, to date, resolved the question of the aetiology of CD. Thus, it may be necessary to [re]consider hypothesis-driven approaches to resolve the aetiology of CD. According to the cold chain hypothesis, the development of industrial and domestic refrigeration has led to frequent exposure of human populations to bacteria capable of growing in the cold. These bacteria, at low levels of exposure, particularly those of the genus Yersinia, are believed to be capable of inducing exacerbated inflammation of the intestine in genetically predisposed subjects. We discuss the consistency of this working hypothesis in light of recent data from epidemiological, clinical, pathological, microbiological, and molecular studies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jessriedel 5y agoYour first point is misaimed. They don't just note the historical worldwide rise in refrigeration goes along side a worldwide rise in Chrohn's. They compare the timing for Chrohn's and refrigeration for different demographic groups in different countries and even, if I am reading this correctly, at the level of individuals. The other things you list will not vary in the same way at that level of detail, although one must of course be wary of multiple hypothesis testing, forking paths, etc.
- tomrod 5y ago> although one must of course be wary of multiple hypothesis testing, forking paths, etc. Precisely. My point was in agreement with another on the article: correlation may not be causation, but it can be highly suggestive of it as one drills down. Necessary, but not sufficient, conditions.
- epgui 5y agoSuggesting that there may be a causal link is entirely appropriate. It's a hypothesis, not a proof.
- tomrod 5y agoCorrect.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThe issue is your point was also long, mocking, and unnecessary.
- tomrod 5y agoRespectfully, I disagree with your assertions.
- Dylan16807 5y agoAll of them? You don't even agree it was mocking? And I'm pretty sure people know that correlation isn't the same as causation. I won't argue very hard for 'long'; the gratuitous examples weren't a big deal in isolation.
- tomrod 5y ago> You don't even agree it was mocking? Correct. Can you help me understand what verbiage you felt was mocking?