3 ms·
The biggest problem with all of this blockchain stuff is that all the incentives are around publicizing the scams. On the upswing, the scammer is trying to rec
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
The biggest problem with all of this blockchain stuff is that all the incentives are around publicizing the scams.
On the upswing, the scammer is trying to recruit marks for their pump and dump scheme, so they market their scam to as many people as they can.
Then the axe falls and the anti-blockchain take the opportunity to point out how everything is wrong and call for government destruction of the entire technology.
Meanwhile some open source developers are trying to decentralize finance and because they're not scammers, they have no marketing budget and nobody knows about what they're trying to do.
- tsimionescu 5y agoWho are these open source developers? What projects are they working on? Help them with some marketing, don't just claim they exist.
- baby 5y agoanybody working with threshold signatures and zero-knowledge proofs.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agohttps://github.com/ong/awesome-decentralized-finance https://github.com/ong/awesome-decentralized-finance But I'd actually be interested in hearing about ones I don't already know about. That's the thing I'm complaining about. Why is every story about some schmucks who are obviously on their way to jail or bankruptcy court and not any of this kind of stuff?
- actually_a_dog 5y ago> The biggest problem with all of this blockchain stuff is that all the incentives are around publicizing the scams. I think you want to differentiate between cryptocurrencies and other blockchain applications here, don't you? Everything[0] I've seen that could be characterized as a straight up scam has been someone pump & dumping their new cryptocoin. --- [0]: Except NFTs, at least as they've been used so far. The concept of an immutable, digital record of ownership of a thing seems good to me (think real property deeds, for instance). But, the idea of using them to claim "ownership" of a JPEG or something seems ridiculous to me on its face. Either I don't understand how it's supposed to work, or a lot of people have been very publicly taken for a lot of money via NFTs.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe best way to think about NFTs for JPEGs is as buying the "original" of a work of art, as opposed to a reproduction. Their value is the status value of rich people being able to say they own it, and their resale value is that some other rich person will want to be able to say that tomorrow. And it's a method of supporting digital artists or causes, e.g.: https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/16/22388548/edward-snowden-nft-freedom-of-the-press-stay-free https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/16/22388548/edward-snowden-n... Of course, the hype is stupefying. People expect that some no-name artist with no cause is going to be able to sell their NFT for a billion dollars.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoBefore I get into my comment, I do want to thank you and note that you're trying to be helpful here. I just don't think you've hit the mark. Regarding the analogy of NFTs to original art, that analogy breaks down almost immediately upon examination. You would compare the NFT to a certificate of ownership of a genuine original versus just copying the JPEG being like a reproduction. The thing is, a genuine original, physical artwork can't be exactly copied and distributed to practically the entire world, over and over again, just by issuing a command inside a computer. I get that an original Picasso is valuable just because it's the only one, and Picasso was a well known and respected artist. I can certainly hang a print or other copy of one of his works on my wall, but, it won't be worth millions of dollars like an original would be. I don't actually have any Picasso reproductions hanging on my wall, but I do own some original artwork, much by no-names, but some by well respected, listed artists [0]. I own these pieces because I have receipts of purchase, but, also, possession being metaphorically 9/10 of the law, because I physically have them in my possession. Because they're physical objects, me having them means nobody else can have them at the same time. Not so with the JPEG. In this scenario, I believe the NFT actually corresponds to my purchase receipts. After all, if someone sent the police to my apartment and claimed my artworks didn't actually belong to me, that's how I'd prove it. And, that seems to be what an NFT is trying to establish: that the holder of the token in some sense owns something essential about the thing it's referencing. Now, maybe I have this all wrong, and the NFT actually corresponds to a certificate of ownership of some kind of rights attached to the artwork. For instance, maybe the NFT is essentially a grant of the right of duplication. To which I say: well, okay... I guess if I don't hold the NFT, I can't duplicate the entirety of the work you own, because the NFT corresponds to ownership of something inherent to the work that can only initially be transferred by the creator of the work under the world's current copyright framework. But, again, I can just copy the bits of the JPEG and do whatever with it. I can take the images and remix them into a mosaic image of a hand right clicking a mouse [1] if I want. But, I can't claim that the resulting work is made up of 10,000 NFTs by whatever artist; because I don't hold the NFTs themselves, I don't hold that right. So, it's not like I "own a JPEG," but, I own a right associated with the JPEG, which is the right to say "I own this NFT associated with this JPEG image," and I can sell or transfer that right. That all to me seems like a distinction without a difference, given that the JPEG itself is, upon creation, a copyrighted work, and the original creator can sell or transfer that right without the associated crypto baggage. TL;DR: ¯\_(ツ)\_/¯ --- [0]: For those not familiar with the term, a "listed artist" is just an artist who has a large enough number of public auction records that those records can be used as a basis for valuing / appraising their work. [1]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/3abnwv/this-powerful-right-click-artwork-is-made-of-10000-nfts https://www.vice.com/en/article/3abnwv/this-powerful-right-c...
- bb88 5y ago> Meanwhile some open source developers are trying to decentralize finance and because they're not scammers, they have no marketing budget and nobody knows about what they're trying to do. I don't know how to separate open source blockchain technology from scams. The point of blockchains AFAICT is obscene profit if your "coin" becomes popular. Remove that and you remove most of the development on blockchain. Most developers seem to be in it for the money because well, why else would you be a developing blockchain? I've heard that the following are blockchain scams: * selling "magical" numbers which have no inherent value for state backed money. * selling coins when the developer controls the majority of them. * Elon Musk pumping Dogecoin on twitter without anyone knowing his true stake. * Tether not being backed 1:1. * Bitfinex using those Tethers to prop up the price of BTC when BTC price falls. Some of these to be clearly scams more than others, but the first one is why China banned Bitcoin mining in their country.
- feketegy 5y agoJust look at how the comments on Elon Musk's tweets look like. On every tweet, the top comments are almost exclusively crypto scammers.