7 ms·
Secretive Prisons That Keep Migrants Out of Europe
- 1cvmask 5y agoStep 1. Destroy country Step 2. Fund concentration camps Step 3. Talk about human rights to other countries
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> Step 1. Destroy country Removing Libya's dictator was entirely on France's hands, you're casting your net to wide blaming the whole EU bloc. Countries like Poland or Portugal had little to gain from Libyan Natural Gas and had nothing to do with the power vacuum created in Libya.
- questiondev 5y agowow, this is something i didn’t even know about until i saw this post. makes a lot of sense now with how people are ignoring other crisis around the world. that’s sad
- the-dude 5y agoA US newsoutlet reporting about the refugee crisis in Libya and not a word about Gadaffi. New York is really far from the Meditterenean.
- vanusa 5y agoWell, he is basically old news by now.
- the-dude 5y agoHe is still very relevant regarding said refugee crisis.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Mizza 5y agoWe came. We saw. He died! cackles maniacally
- jareklupinski 5y agoThere's a whole paragraph about him, you need to grep an alternative spelling: > Europe had long pressed Libya to help curb such migration. Muammar Qaddafi, Libya’s leader, had once embraced Pan-Africanism and encouraged sub-Saharan Africans to serve in the country’s oil fields. But in 2008 he signed a “friendship treaty” with Silvio Berlusconi, the Italian Prime Minister, that committed him to implementing strict controls. Qaddafi sometimes used this as a bargaining chip: he threatened, in 2010, that if the E.U. did not send him more than six billion dollars a year in aid money he would “turn Europe Black.” In 2011, Qaddafi was toppled and killed in an insurrection sparked by the Arab Spring and supported by a U.S.-led invasion. Afterward, Libya descended into chaos.
- the-dude 5y agoI stand corrected, I searched for multiple variants of spelling of Gadaffi. Never seen the Q-variant before.
- ragnot 5y agoIt comes from the arabic spelling of Gadaffi: قذافي The ق at the beginning is a mix between a glottal stop and a k sound (depending on the dialect). There's no real way to spell it in English, hence the variants. This is similar to Osama/Usama (أسامة)
- Rzor 5y agoYes, there is. Did you even read it or just searched for his name?
- 0xbadc0de5 5y ago[flagged]
- vore 5y agoIt's not against the law to seek asylum in Europe. I think bringing up the idea of rule-following to people who are in dire straits is dismissive of their plight.
- RobertRoberts 5y agoIsn't this the crux of the matter? If you pass through hundreds of miles of safe land to get to a 4th or 5th country, don't you think that should automatically disqualify you for asylum?
- vore 5y agoA lot of these migrants are traveling via sea from the coast of Africa to European countries, no? The article posits that the EU is funding the Libyan government to intercept these boats and put them in offshore detention -- what safe land did they pass through? Would you consider Libya a safe country for their ultimate asylum if they're being detained in these horrific conditions?
- 988747 5y agoHow about those who buy plane tickets from Iraq to Belarus and then try to go through Polish border to get to EU? Also, which country in North Africa is currently not safe to be? I'm not aware of any war currently happening in Lybia, Tunisia, Egypt?
- martin8412 5y agoThey're not Lybians escaping Lybia.. They're Subsaharan Africans trying to get to Europe because they don't like where they were born, which is understandable, but is not grounds for asylum. The reason the EU asks the Lybian coast guard to intercept is because German NGO ships are patrolling just outside the maritime borders waiting to ferry people to whatever unlucky Southern European country is forced to accept them.
- itqwertz 5y agoWhy do they strive for Europe? Economic refugees are in for a surprise when they actually make it to Europe. Maybe it’s better than what they had, but there is no doubt in my mind that they aren’t getting the warm welcome social media activists portray.
- krono 5y agoThey've been "weaponised"
- Schiendelman 5y agoIt’s simple, and you said it: It’s better than what they had. The places they are coming from are terrible.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoBecause it’s better than where they came from, usually.
- DeusExMachina 5y agoPeople are replying "it's better than what they had" but that's often not true. Many are promised something that does not exist, go through lot of danger only to discover that they were better off where they started. But now, they can't go back. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQ_fz9EW5Iw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZQ_fz9EW5Iw
- flyinglizard 5y agoWhat is an “economic refugee” anyway? Are Norwegians immigrating to USA “winter refugees”?
- itqwertz 5y agoNo, I assume that most of them flew across the Atlantic and went through US border control. We don’t have waves of Norwegians attempting to cross the US borders illegally on ships, like the EU has with African/Middle Eastern immigrants. There are ample social services and NGO help in the EU that immigrants can take advantage of. Such programs don’t exist in most ME/African countries. Ironically, Norway and other Scandinavian countries do have these programs as well as stable economies.
- ipspam 5y agoThis is what happens when people push things like open borders. It creates a problem that must be stopped, and legally. A refugee has the right to claim asylum in the first country they set foot in, not the 5 or 8th one of their choosing. The natural response to open borders thinking is to enforce this result. Beyond that, it's a little hard to stir up an emotional response. If these people truly are fleeing something terrible, this place isn't so bad.
- rebuilder 5y agoThe EU migrant problem is, from my perspective as an EU citizen, the real elephant in the room that everyone talks about but still doesn't quite appreciate the depth of. We have a union that claims to be be committed to human rights such as the right to seek asylum. That union recently experienced serious political unrest after receiving a bit over a million migrants around 2015 and clearly the political leadership decided that could not happen again. So the problem was offshored to Turkey, and to some extent Greece, and I'm sure to some North African nations in deals I'm not aware of. This is going to be horrific, frankly. Whatever you think of the ethics of the whole business, it's pretty clear that politically, EU leadership is not willing to face another migrant crisis. Unfortunately, the EU also doesn't seem able to do a whole lot about the root causes of the crisis, namely political instability and war south of the EU borders. So what that leaves is the EU turning a blind eye to the problem, trying to get the authoritarian states on our borders to deal with the problem in a deniable fashion instead. It's not going to work in the long run. People move across borders when they need to. Where it's all going, I don't know, but it's going to be a big, big problem for the EU if the conflicts in the Middle East and Africa can not be stabilized.
- AinderS 5y ago> So the problem was offshored to Turkey, and to some extent Greece, and I'm sure to some North African nations in deals I'm not aware of. Surely you mean the problem was offshored to Europe, and now (part of) Europe is onshoring it back to the Middle East? Contrary to popular belief, Europe is not the only place in the world suitable for asylum.
- marchingtomars 5y agoLet those people stay back and fix their own countries. The countries of the EU and The Americas all went through wars-- in some case several wars including civil wars, to get where they are now. I think war is a part of nature-- whether a petri dish, a savannah, or a human "nation". Disputes over resources are a part of nature. Migrants, stay home. If you're really so valuable to an economy, go and stay valuable in your own economy. Oh wait-- Maybe we should drain all of our resources to pay for migrants. And then, yay, some country can come invade our country because we'll be poor too!
- black_13 5y agoIf you were looking a looking for a place to recruit future jihadist here would be a great place to start. Ppl who were abandoned or disaffected by Europe in general the west. This would great chance to act with humanity a missed opportunity.
- olivermarks 5y agoGaddafi's government had tight border controls and prevented illegal entry into europe. Since Libya fell the country has become a prime route for migrants seeking to cross the borders into europe. 2014 Vice film https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/europe-or-die-storming-the-spanish-fence/560a80dc018ed64734b82654 https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/europe-or-die-storming-th... Now Libya is again a barrier to european entry as Vice and now Ian Urbina /nyt describe. https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/europe-or-die-libyas-migrant-jails/560a8197e5ca6a9f34617846 https://video.vice.com/en_us/video/europe-or-die-libyas-migr...
- hogFeast 5y agoWow, some of this stuff is truly incredible. You have "activist groups" assisting human traffickers, that is very surprising (these groups are very suspect, the person who led one of the largest "activist group" in Calais was having sex with migrants...apparently this is rife). You have someone who works for a nonprofit claiming they are a journalist when they are, unsurprisingly, imprisoned for doing things they shouldn't be doing. The author describes the danger of Libya at great length but the implied solution is: just let everyone come in...ofc, makes perfect sense. Just generally, is it a good idea to enter a country that is in a state of war in order to illegal migrate to another country (which, btw, has very open routes for people to seek asylum legally)? No, it is not a good idea.
- lordnacho 5y agoI was getting the immigration story of a friend the other day, as I often do. How did a brown guy end up in the UK? I've been even more keen on it since my parents died, having left me in a part of the world where I'm clearly foreign. To be fair I did move around a bit myself, but Western Europe is not that big. In our family we have horrendous stories. People who fell in the water, terrible fights breaking out in the camps. People feeling so desperate they sent their kids to foreign countries under false pretences. As we were talking, it struck me that there's no right to free migration. There's all sorts of other things in the human rights convention, but going where you want somehow isn't one of them. This is despite the economic orthodoxy being that mobility, particularly of capital, is good. I do get it. It's not actually a plus for absolutely everyone in the receiving country. Perhaps they compete for jobs or housing. There's legitimate concerns about people bringing values that aren't compatible with existing ones. Or they might commit crimes. But there's also a lot of evidence that future generations assimilate. You'll meet plenty of darker skinned people in Europe who pretty much think the same as anyone else. They take a job, they pay their taxes, they root for the national team.
- dash2 5y agoIt's true up to a point, but there's also a lot of evidence that multi-ethnic societies don't work very well. See e.g. Alesina and La Ferrara, 2000. "Participation in heterogeneous communities" or Alesina, Baqir, and Easterly "Public goods and ethnic divisions" or Putnam "E Pluribus Unum".
- RobertRoberts 5y agoSome reasons a migrant should be automatically disqualified for asylum. 1. Traveling through a safe/peaceful country and not requesting asylum there first. 2. Attacking anyone protecting the border of the country you are apply to asylum for. 3. Destroying border barriers of the host country. 4. Committing any violent crime while applying for asylum in the host country. 5. Prostituting minors or other asylum seekers while in the host country. Maybe a lot of other reasons, but otherwise some compassionate method for dealing with migrants should be worked towards.
- cultofmetatron 5y agowhite nations screaming "woe is me! too many immigrants" after spending the previous century completely dismantling the institutions of the countries those immigrants came from creating the very conditions that cause these people to flee? cry me a river. you don't get to live in relative luxury paid for by the rape of another country without bearing some responsibility for the fallout that creates.
- cultofmetatron 5y agoI'm imagine all the downvotes here are white people uncomfortable with their own history. Deal with it. you can't understand the modern migrant crisis without understanding the last 200 years of colonialism and exploitation. Hell, its still going on. just look at the chocolate trade or diamonds or a forced free trade that allows rich devloped countries to push commodities into africa preventing local production from being financially viable. Its rich europeans continuing to drive poverty in africa.
- dash2 5y agoThat might be true. There's actually, contrary to stereotype, little consensus among historians about whether imperial rule made Africa richer or poorer. The past half-century of independence has also not unambiguously improved the situation. Lastly, you claim that forced free trade makes Africa poor, but the last time people acted on that theory, they tried import-substituting industrialization, and it (cough) did not work very well.
- cultofmetatron 5y agoAfrica is trying to get from zero to one. Its not surprising to me that independence after having all their institutions destroyed would not result in an immediate rise to prosperity. It takes leadership with vision and a distinct lack of selfishness to push a truly long term vision. I'd argue that africa is still reeling from cultural trauma. Fixing that is going to be difficult. As far as import substituting industrialization. The devil is in the details. There are as many ways to do it wrong as to do it right. In many countries, its cheaper to buy a bag of onions from europe than to buy locally grown. Thats not right. I dont' have all the answers but some degree of controlled import-substituting industrialization needs to be done and informed by people who've spent considerable time studying the economy. As a start, Europe could easly bring people from africa to study civil engineering, modern agricultural practices which they would then bring back with them along with financial assistance to bootstrap the very institutions that they destroyed. Expensive? sure, consider it reparations.
- jetsetgo 5y agoEU migrant problem is their own creation. They go to wars in middle east in america; destroy countries, kill innocents and then cry about migrants pouring in. Continuously dump their waste and trash in Africa. EU has created the largest electronic waste landfill in Africa.
- zerr 5y agoRelevant: Why don’t refugees fly? https://www.liberties.eu/en/stories/why-refugees-do-not-take-the-plane/16316 https://www.liberties.eu/en/stories/why-refugees-do-not-take...
- martin8412 5y agoI'm sorry, but I don't buy what some German NGO says. German NGOs are the ones responsible for ferrying illegal migrants to Europe.
- zerr 5y agoYou can bing :) that phrase and see other resources, e.g. https://blogs.berkeley.edu/2016/02/11/why-dont-refugees-fly/ https://blogs.berkeley.edu/2016/02/11/why-dont-refugees-fly/
- peter_retief 5y agoI couldn't find the archived version but I did find this https://www.npr.org/2021/11/29/1059861708/secret-prisons-in-libya-keep-migrants-out-of-europe https://www.npr.org/2021/11/29/1059861708/secret-prisons-in-...
- throwaway47292 5y agoofftopic: Why are they making webpages like that? What is wrong with few <h3> <p> and <img>, the page will be 10 times easier to read.
- YetAnotherNick 5y agoBeing inconsistent on migrants irks me a lot. Entire developed world is paying someone to stop the migrants before they could cross the border and treat them without any humanity. And on the same time, many of those same countries' government heads gives pro migrant speeches. The entire case somehow hinges on whether the immigrant is successful is crossing the border which gives worst incentives to the migrants as they are ready to risk the life to cross it. Germany is ready to pay Turkey to treat the immigrants badly, but couldn't do it itself. I think either we should remove the life threatening non humane solution deployed outside the border or treat immigrant as bad when they enter. This way immigrants would have clear incentive of what they are about to get and not take any life threatening decisions in crossing the border.
- dash2 5y agoA lot of people here are saying the problem is open borders, we need to control immigration, and sure, I agree. But this seems to miss the point of the piece: at the moment we're trying to control immigration by outsourcing the job to very poor, very unstable neighbouring countries. This leads to horrible cruelty and human rights violations. (Did anyone else see the graphic of bed space in the prison and think of the layout of an 18th century slave ship?) We need a way to solve this very difficult problem which doesn't absolutely violate the most basic decencies that Europe has prided itself on since the Enlightenment.
- c0mpassion 5y agoI just don’t see how we can keep a good conscious and turn away these people. Their countries aren’t poor because of pure luck of the draw, they are poor because European powers have exploited and extorted these countries. They remain poor because of neocolonialism. They are getting poorer because of climate change, caused in a large part because of the European industrial revolution. Most migrants don’t leave because it’ll be a great adventure or on a whim, they leave because there is nothing left for them or they want a better life for their family. You don’t get in a boat unless the water is safer than land. Some of the comments in this thread are pretty heartless and dehumanising, would we not want the exact same for our families? How can we discuss tougher borders being the solution, if the result is camps like these?