5 ms·
In my opinion, most of the problems with today's email systems could be solved if the recipient system would require an ε payment to the recipients' public wall
by dotancohen 5y ago
In my opinion, most of the problems with today's email systems could be solved if the recipient system would require an ε payment to the recipients' public wallet. I don't care what the value of ε is nor in which digital coin it is. But there should be a negligible cost to send email, and a benefit to the receiver.
I would even go further and alot email priorities, each high priority requiring a higher payment. So my bank notifying me of an attempted login might pay a little more, but that message goes to the top of my heap. Whereas aunt sally's digital birthday card cost her near nothing and I'll get to it when I'm done with all the attempted logins to my bank.
The best part of this system is that it really does not require actual money to be exchanged. If one prefers, he could just mine the coins he uses to send the mail with. That's a feature, not a bug, to keep the system inclusive for all low-volume senders but far less so for spammers. It also makes scamming far less lucrative.
- teddyh 5y agoPlease read https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt and check all boxes that apply to your post yourself. Ideas such as yours have been around since the mid-1990’s and have been debated to death since then, so much so that the aforementioned template was created.
- tomjen3 5y agoThat template essentially shot down any discussion of fixing email in the open source space, and so companies like Slack, Google and MSFT were able to create walled gardens that can only be interacted with by their systems or by email senders they consider secure enough. If, instead of creating that template, somebody had made Thunderbird send PoW headers and priotize those that had it, maybe we would have been in a freer world.
- teddyh 5y agoAnd yet, nobody who could have made that change in Thunderbird thought it would be a good idea to do that. This is how ideas are evaluated and either adopted or rejected.
- pixl97 5y agoYea, there's about 0% chance that PoW would fix anything. Much like how bitcoin miners run in javascripts these days, victims would have born the brunt of the computing expense.
- rtpg 5y agoDoes everything need to devolve into sudoku-solving coins that the makers can try to profit off of? If we’re building all this tech for coins or digital stamps, it seems like the existing system could work fine by rolling per-contact email addresses to give out. Traceability without having to kill any polar bears. Apple is already offering this through their Apple Sign-In
- dotancohen 5y agoFor what it's worth I have never used any of the cryptocurrencies. It just seemed to me that this is a viable solution to a difficult problem - a way to associate a cost with a behaviour that we'd like to limit, in a way that does not prevent the poor, disadvantaged, or those who wish to remain anonymous from participating.
- xfer 5y ago> in a way that does not prevent the poor, disadvantaged, Yeah mining coins totally doesn't exclude poor people. If it costs less than the profit spammers make they will use it. You can't just handwave the thresold away, and pretend you are solving the problem by just asking for money(thereby excluding large swaths of people). Just use your iMessage.
- emacsen 5y agoThis is probably the worst part about any kind of payment based system, whether it be money or proof of work- these systems do reflect the disadvantages of the economies of the world. That said, since this problem already exists in the world, it is often overstated. If a stamp is a reasonable cost, and only a one time cost, it will be largely invisible. 25 cents (a price set by the recipient) to send a message from a stranger won't have a big impact on most people, and it's important to recognize it's only the first time. It's further important to know it would even be possible to refund the cost of the stamp back to the sender once the message is sent. The recipient could have a button that says "Return stamp" which would then let the sender re-use or in some other way organize the stamp. Now let's contrast to today... Let's say I want to send a message to a big movie star or a CEO. The chances that I will be able to get their address is relatively low. Even if I do, they likely have someone they pay to filter their messages before it gets to them.
- ericbarrett 5y agoYou've gone full circle and reinvented HashCash, the algorithmic predecessor to Bitcoin :) http://hashcash.org/ http://hashcash.org/
- dotancohen 5y agoInteresting, thank you.
- cabalamat 5y agoMaybe new-email could be linked to a cryptocurrency?
- nonameiguess 5y agoIn case readers aren't aware because the comment doesn't say, the Bitcoin proof of work algorithm was invented by the designers of Hash Cash as an e-mail anti-spam measure, more than a decade before anyone ever thought to use it for currency. They're effectively the e equivalent of postage stamps, with prices that dynamically adjust to whatever level is needed to deter spammers. Just as with stamps, someone eventually realized they could be traded for more than face value, and like with limited-edition collector's stamps, someone eventually realized you could make "non-fungible" versions and try to trade them for even more than face value.
- civilized 5y agoThis idea is not bad. I would just add that there should be an option for parties with mutual trust to exchange without cost. Your bank is going to increase your fees to cover the cost of sending mail to you, so the process is a pointless waste of resources in that case. This illustrates the need for a free mechanism between parties that trust each other.
- C19is20 5y agoMy bank just sent an email "A surprise for you!!". Open it up ..it's a link to my app to login to see a useless budgeting report I've been suffering with for over a year. That should cost them.
- teddyh 5y ago> That should cost them. It could, if you choose, cost them your business.
- civilized 5y agoLike I said, they can just charge it back to you, and no law is going to completely prevent them from doing that one way or another. So I think it's a waste of time with a party you already have a paid service agreement with.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoi suppose if your inbox auto-replied with an ACK you could just instantly repay the postage
- jeltz 5y agoGiven how much SMS and phone spam there is I am not sure this would work.
- dotancohen 5y agoThis is a proposed email spam mitigation, not an SMS spam mitigation.
- jeltz 5y agoYes, but SMS are way more expensive for the spammers to send than I assume this proposal for mail will be and there still is a ton of SMS spam. The issue with spam is that it is lucrative and I do not think a small fee will fix that.
- amelius 5y agoYeah, but as others have pointed out, I know my bank, and I know my aunt, so wouldn't a properly implemented signing mechanism just solve the problem? I know that PGP failed, but with a better implementation and greater support it just might work. This would also solve phishing, where the attacker would be willing to pay a few cents per attempt.
- nonameiguess 5y agoFor institutional senders, this is what DKIM already does. Your bank has an e-mail domain registered with a CA somewhere that other e-mail domains, such as wherever you receive mail, trust.
- jagger27 5y agoToo bad that even if I setup DKIM correctly Google still black holes my email.
- trulyme 5y agoThis is something that is missing from the OPs list of problems with e-mail. There is an "extended" version of it by a certain bigtech company that a lot of people use, which is not completely interoperable with e-mail. Just enough to confuse people into thinking that it is, but not more.
- amelius 5y agoYes! But that's not a solution for aunt Sally, though indeed it solves the phishing issue.
- cabalamat 5y ago> if the recipient system would require an ε payment to the recipients' public wallet And allow recipients to whitelist senders who don't need payment.
- minimilian 5y ago> If one prefers, he could one could
- jcranmer 5y agoAs noted by other people, your idea, especially in its final version, has already been proposed. The basic problem with the proposal is that it fundamentally misunderstands how the economics of spam works. Especially when it comes to the idea of using proof-of-CPU time to generate the cost to send mail. Spam generally comes from compromised machines, so the people who would actually be paying the cost of sending mail are not the spammers, but those who own the compromised systems. In effect, you'd be making everyone but the spammers pay for their email. (And the idea of being able to pay extra to get higher priority is going to be a godsend to spammers--historically, spammers were the most eager to implement anti-spam technologies such as SPF because of the boost it gives the spam.)
- dotancohen 5y ago> using proof-of-CPU time to generate the cost to send mail. Spam generally > comes from compromised machines I see, thank you. You are correct, but it would greatly reduce the quantity of spam. Additionally, such compromised machines should now become (how to word this) more-unusable :) which may accelerate incentive to resolve the issue.
- littlestymaar 5y agoThe parent comment isn't talking about proof of work it's talking about actual payment. In practice payment system are much more rarely compromised (or at least it doesn't last long) and if you could compromise someone's payment system you'd not bother sending spam, you'd just take the money and run.
- jasode 5y ago>The parent comment isn't talking about proof of work it's talking about actual payment. I think he was replying to this that the gp wrote: "The best part of this system is that it really does not require actual money [...] , he could just _mine_ the coins he uses to send the mail with."
- littlestymaar 5y ago
- jodrellblank 5y agoWhy would you prefer and value your bank sending you some automated valueless security theater[1] over your relative sending you a human to human birthday greeting? And why would you build the system so that, for everyone, personal communication is expensive and burdensome, and for every company, mass advertising is cheap and easy? (Relatively cheap, because companies have vastly more money than individuals). This applies whatever the cost values is; if it's low, it's low for spammers. If it's high, it's high for individuals. And wherever "low" or "high" is, someone you like will think it expensive enough to be in the way and someone you dislike will think it cheap enough to be no problem. [1] if the bank stopped the attempted logon, I don't care. If the login was actually me messing up, I already know. If they didn't stop the logon, then they didn't detect it was fraudulent and wouldn't be emailing or calling at all.