8 ms·
How new Linux users can increase their odds of success
- newsbinator 5y ago> Linux is the preeminent operating system for programmers and other highly technical computer users, for whom it can be suitably molded to purpose in a manner which is not possible using other operating systems. That could be so, although I'm in the opposite camp: MacOS is the preeminent operating system for me because it does the best job of getting out of my way and letting me work. I have no idea how to configure sound drivers on a Mac or what my current filesystem is (some version of APFS or something new?) because I've never been forced to learn as a prerequisite for getting work done.
- diffeomorphism 5y agoAnd you also have to do neither on linux. Also, just to compare apples to apples. If you buy a laptop with macos or linux preinstalled you of course have to do nothing because someone else did it for you. Install macos on a dell laptop and tell us how easy that was.
- neatze 5y ago> And you also have to do neither on linux. what makes you say this ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rhn_mk1 5y agoExperience? If you buy a computer with Linux on it, you don't have to care.
- pgcj_poster 5y agoI've ran Linux on 6 different consumer laptops, and I've never had to configure a sound driver. I have had to choose a file system, but only on Arch and Debian, which are targeted toward advanced users.
- newsbinator 5y agoThe reason macOS is so problem-free (relative to Linux) is that for practical purposes it "can't" be installed on all but a couple specific pieces of hardware. That's the trade-off I've chosen: MacOS is guaranteed to work well on my laptop because they were designed and built together, for each other. Put another way: the fact an apples-to-apples comparison to Linux is impossible is the reason macOS wins for me.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoI think you're ignoring the manufacturers of Linux laptops, like Purism or System76. Those are built together, for each other. Okay, maybe not as deeply as MacOS, but it's the only concern of those companies.
- newsbinator 5y agoYou might be right. I've never used a Purism or System76 laptop. If I can use it without ever having to know which boot loader I'm using (or what a boot loader is), what version of a given driver I have installed, which partition I'm writing to (or what a partition is), whether I'm currently logged in as root or as admin... ... that'd be comparable to MacOS, and it definitely opens the door to me switching to Linux if/when Apple takes a dark-enough turn. Now one might argue that every professional user, especially a programmer, should know what a boot loader is or what partition they should be writing to, since that's as basic a requirement to use a professional tool as touch-typing is. But I wouldn't agree with that; macOS abstracts away a lot of basic things, and that's why I like it.
- rhn_mk1 5y agoYou're not going to be disappointed when you give them a try then. They match your requirements so far. Sure, they have problems specific to them (e.g. losing encryption keys, some WiFi sticks unsupported by policy), but every ecosystem has rough edges you won't find elsewhere. BTW, there are more Linux-focused companies. Those two are just the ones I remember from the top of my head.
- 5y ago
- cassianoleal 5y agoI am at the same position right now, and have been for a few years. macOS stays out of my way and lets me get on with my work. That said, a lot of what makes me effective at my work comes from many years of breaking, fixing, bending and molding Linux to my personal and professional needs; from understanding filesystems, their pros and cons, from compiling the kernel with different options; from compiling software from source in order to get an obscure library compiled in so my GPU would be accelerated, etc. Granted, the entire Linux ecosystem is much more stable these days but those were good times for learning about computers just trying to get your own computer to work. :)
- rprospero 5y agoIt's interesting that you mentioned not needing to know about filesystems. About five years ago, I did a year of iPhone development and had to work on a Mac laptop. As part of this, I needed to get some files off an external hard drive I had, except the laptop wanted to reformat the drive every time it was plugged in. My Windows laptop and my Linux machine could read the drive just fine, but the Mac (and the guys at the Genius Bar) insisted that the drive was corrupted and there was no recoverable data. Eventually wound up using a Linux machine to copy the files I needed onto a thumb drive that the Mac had personally formatted. Took about ten trips to get everything copied over. The laptop lasted a couple of years before the motherboard failed. That hard drive is still going and hasn't had a single corrupted file.
- BossingAround 5y agoFrom the article, tips on challenges for users to show what sets Linux apart from other OSes: > 1. Learn how to use the shell. > 2. Find and install packages from the command line. > 3. Try out a tiling window manager, especially if you consider yourself a power user. > 4. Compile a program from source. At this point, the author would have surely alienated the vast majority of users potentially interested in Linux. I would venture a guess that even most engineers who use Linux at work (i.e. on their laptop) don't know what's a tiling window manager (since it's an implementation detail).
- sascha_sl 5y agoIt's a very long way to say "no, I don't want UX to get better, why don't you instead join us and become a linux nerd, from 0 to 100". It also implies these are the things that make Linux good over macOS and Windows, when I can think of a lot of other benefits, including essentially eternal support for a wide range of hardware, the best printing stack (sharing that with macOS somewhat), independence from Microsoft and Apple, extreme customizability of any component of the OS and choice in who to trust with putting together your base system (aka distro).
- sixothree 5y agoI would say those are all very much the things that make linux bad for new users. This article feels like it was written in 2015.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoThere's a lot of companies working on the UX for Linux. There's Ubuntu, ElementaryOS, Zorin... They're not for me though, as what I care about is pretty contrary to the idea of mainstream. I don't really care whether Linux makes it to the mainstream or not, why should that be everyone's goal? The lack of a unified direction might seems like a weakness of Linux but it's also its biggest strength. It's the reason it's the most used OS in the world now, when you include servers and Android devices. It's just so easy to adapt if you want to do something different. So let the techies do their techie stuff and let the mainstream OS vendors focus on their users :)
- Mikeb85 5y agoHere's how you really increase your odds of success: - Use all-Intel hardware - Use a laptop that comes with Linux (includes some Dell XPS series laptops and ThinkPads) - Install Ubuntu and don't change anything via the terminal Then Linux is every bit as easy and solid as any other OS, if not moreso.
- TwoNineA 5y ago> - Use all-Intel hardware Stopped reading there.
- stonecharioteer 5y agoWhy Intel? I'm on a Ryzen 7 ThinkPad and run Ubuntu without any problems.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoI am guessing they meant "Intel networking hw" (typing this on an Ryzen 7 Asus running Ubuntu too). But that's obviously too simple, it would be better advice to just say "find someone on the 'net who describes installing and using the distro you are considering on the machine you are considering". Though really I haven't had any serious hardware problems under Linux for years (but I have a small stable of machines I am not changing all the time).
- jeltz 5y agoI am pretty sure they refer to Intel networking and sound hardware. Because AMD has good stuff for both CPUs and graphics while I do not know of any reliable alternatives for networking and sound.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIt's not about the CPU. Intel makes everything and is known to have good Linux support. You can buy a system where "lspci" lists nothing but Intel hardware, and that system will run Linux well. So will many other systems. AMD CPUs and GPUs in particular are good. Nvidia not so much. The vast majority of network adapters are no problem, but a few stupid ones do exist. But it's easier to say "just get everything Intel" than to enumerate the entire hardware compatibility list.
- hnbear 5y agoI don’t know why these articles always focus on desktop use-cases where Linux isn’t strong, rather than ones where Linux is. If you have people willing and eager to try something new, teach its strengths. Rather than teaching a new desktop, teach things where Linux excels server-side. Eg. Setup a Pi-hole I use both win and macOS desktops at home and will not replace them any time soon with Linux, but have far more Linux devices for things like: - Pi-hole - homebridge - minecraft servers for my kids (with crafty) - Plex - Timemachine (netatalk + zfs) - photoframes using raspberry pi zeros + old cheap monitors But there are tons of great, interesting, education use-cases. I’ve found I only learn when there’s an interesting project with a rewarding goal. “Learn a new desktop” isn’t defined enough to stick. Spin up a usable new server proving a clear function is.
- mfer 5y agoRight now there is a popular YouTube channel talking about Linux on the desktop. The timing is related to that. It’s not an in general thing
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> I don’t know why these articles always focus on desktop use-cases where Linux isn’t strong Because this is what they are familiar with.
- howeyc 5y agoI think the biggest benefit of Linux is the likelihood of most of the software you are using to have some kind of terminal/shell/text-based interface which allows for automation of tasks if you are so inclined. Pipes are fantastic. I have on numerous occasions encountered a task I need to repeat on Windows with a GUI application and cursed to the heavens that there is no way to automate the task, incredibly frustrating. -- Yes yes, Powershell, but it doesn't do everything. Plus, all the commercial software available, chances are it doesn't have any such feature/plugins.
- flohofwoe 5y ago> Programmers also want to play games, so there has been interest in getting a good gaming setup working on Linux. (IMHO) This was hardly because of "programmer's desires", but because Valve desperately needed a fallback solution in case Microsoft is turning Windows into an iOS-style walled garden (and this was a very real possibility in the Windows 8 days, and probably will become a topic again depending on which "clan" at Microsoft has the upper hand). Before Valve got involved, "Linux gaming" basically meant getting Tux Racer to work.
- User23 5y agoLet's not forget Freeciv! And if you're old school, xpilot. It was probably the apotheosis of Unix gaming, in that it required a giant rc file to actually be fun.
- amelius 5y agoI currently have these problems with Linux: 1. Command line argument expansion is limited, so at some point you need tools like xargs which is far from perfect. This is strange on machines with gigabytes of memory. 2. Running "su - user" does not forward X. Messing with xauth is an unnecessary nuisance. 3. The unix tradition of piping commands is great. Extensions like Gstreamer are essentially using pipes but they use their own kind, which is awkward. 4. A modern linux desktop system uses a bunch of services, which are glued together like a microservices architecture. This has its problems; see any thread on microservices on HN.
- mfer 5y agoI’m currently reading the book, Design of Everyday Things. Suggestions in this post go directly against the teachings of successful product designers. I would LOVE for gnu Linux distros to have an amazing experience that delights people. First, people need to stop blaming the users who struggle with things. That includes telling them to learn some technical incantations or criticizing them when they don’t. That’s just covering up user experience issues in a design that needs work
- jancsika 5y ago> This means that the general public has access to the source code which makes it tick, and that anyone can modify it or improve it to suit their needs. But most of the OS code is maintained in such a way that only a small group of motivated users would be willing to fiddle with the build infrastructure necessary to even attempt modifying any of the core functionality. That, along with the long wait times of recompiling, is functionally equivalent to burying entire process of "modifying or improving to suit needs" behind a blockchain. E.g., you have to walk awkwardly through a tarpit to arrive at the modification. (Hint for Blockchain Fans-- that's a bad thing here.) It would be neat if there were a distro that shipped with all the build desiderata in place. So that I could at least go into ls.c or whatever and add a printf "all your base are belong to us" line and have it just incrementally recompile that single command. Bonus points for a browser repo that could do that. Let me add a menu option that reads, "Poop" in less than ten seconds. (Btw-- how are incremental builds for browsers? If someone wants to printf their way through a bug, what's the recompile latency like?) Edit: clarification
- bsdubernerd 5y agoThis is the job of your linux distribution: it's not just a pile of packages. It includes the bridges required to rebuild each package for the infrastructure of the distribution. If you really want to have everything rebuilding from source at your fingertips, you could already do that with gentoo and similar. Patching upstream sources and rebuilding is pretty trivial there if that's your thing. There are more to choose from. You probably won't be having the build infrastructure of all your packages "ready" all the time though, and things are taking a turn to the worse due to dependency bundling where each package has it's own independent copy.
- VTimofeenko 5y agoTo add to the Gentoo recommendation: ebuilds (effectively, build recipes) take care of pulling in build- and runtime- dependencies. They work with build systems (automake, ninja, meson, etc.) through reusable framework of eclasses, so it's not that hard to write an ebuild to install something that's not in the existing repos. With reference ebuilds and a bit of patience, one can write ebuilds for software written in languages one has no experience in. To be fair, there's Linux From Scratch, but I found it to be a bit tedious to build out everything and manage the dependencies by hand. Walking through a big dependency DAG manually is not very practical IMO. There's also Nix, but I am yet to learn how to work with custom patches there. I believe that it's possible, and Nix has a lot of other great features but hasn't been exactly Gentoo-like in my experience.
- unixhero 5y agoLinus Tech Tips is unwatchable drivel.
- swayvil 5y agoThis unnecessarily complexifies the subject. Download your free copy of Debian. Install it. There, you're done.
- shmerl 5y ago> The best operating system for gaming is Windows. Disagreed. Windows is just a system with most users, so games developers target it most. Linux is just fine for gaming.
- Shared404 5y agoFrom a technical perspective, you are of course correct. But from the perspective who wants games to Just Work? I'd like it to be otherwise but Windows still owns that.
- shmerl 5y agoThat has been improving a lot, and now Windows own advantage can be used for Linux gaming - you can run most Windows games on Linux. MS can of course mess it up, but that helps Linux grow now, eventually making more developers release for Linux proper.
- Shared404 5y agoI in fact do so! I daily drive Linux, and do 95+% of my gaming on it - I just also recognize that it is an 'unsupported configuration'. It works well enough for me and for many/most people, but it will never be as 'out of the box' as Windows, until the fabled Year of the Linux Desktop arrives.
- shmerl 5y agoSame, I do all my gaming on Linux. And it surely improved by a huge margin in the recent years. There are some issues to resolve yet, but it's surely usable for a wide range of people now and I'd totally recommend it even if Windows can be simpler to use in some cases.
- pdenton 5y agoPeople are spoiled nowadays. Computers used to come with a set of books. When I started with GNU+Linux 20 years ago, I read Running Linux 2nd edition back to back. GNU+Linux worked just fine back then, and it still does now. KDE was already a thing. To start with computers, I'd recommend the GNU Manifesto. Free software is important. These days, anyone using a computer without a FLOSS operating system on it is just ignorant. There's been TV ads. CDs by mail were free. There are magazines. Arch has a wiki. And to those who are willing to make their computer work for them again: welcome to the FLOSS community. Hope you enjoy it!
- butz 5y agoLearning shell for a new Linux user, especially coming from non-programming field could be difficult and might even turn them back to their old OS. "Help someone else out online" - this is useful, I might re-phrase it as "Find solution to your problem together", as learning and sharing knowledge with community is probably the most important thing for new users. Finally, all efforts should be documented and shared: blog post, video, live stream - we need updates to old "command line only" solutions, preferably using only GUI tools. And failure is a good thing too, as showing what you already tried might help others to propose best solution for your problem.