3 ms·
Apple media services terms includes things like: > You may not use the Services to: - post a dishonest, abusive, harmful, misleading, or bad-faith rating or re
by Jensson 5y ago
Apple media services terms includes things like:
> You may not use the Services to: - post a dishonest, abusive, harmful, misleading, or bad-faith rating or review, or a rating or review that is irrelevant to the Content being reviewed
To me it seems like those rules could ban you for just about any reason. I mean, what is even a "bad faith" review? Do you need to assume good faith on the company if you had a bad experience?
- xmprt 5y agoAlso, what is a harmful review? Pretty much any 1 star review is harmful however, in many cases, they are deserved. So if I get horrible service and leave a 1 star review, is that grounds for banning me?
- Jensson 5y agoI wonder if Apple has a system where companies can report your reviews as harmful and if enough such reports comes in maybe Apple auto bans you?
- kube-system 5y agoThat clause is pretty specific. This is the clause by which they can ban you for any reason: > Apple further reserves the right to modify, suspend, or discontinue the Services (or any part or Content thereof) at any time with or without notice to you, and Apple will not be liable to you or to any third party should it exercise such rights.
- Aeolun 5y agoI’m inclined to believe a court would find otherwise, regardless of what it says in the TOS.
- mewse 5y ago“Bad faith” is a common, normal term that has a well-accepted concrete legal meaning [0]. In this context it basically means posting a rating or review which doesn’t match your actual opinion. For example, crowd-sourced vote brigading (where you don’t have an opinion at all but are just voting in the way someone else told you to vote). Similarly, reviews along the lines of “This app only deserves four stars, but currently it has an average five star rating so I’m going to give it a one star review to try to bump the average rating down toward what I think the average should actually be” would be reviewing in bad faith. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_faith https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_faith
- Jensson 5y agoHow would they detect this though? A bot looking for things like this would easily catch a lot of innocent people. Even a real human would.
- fay59 5y agoThis is your periodic reminder that not all problems have a technical solution. There probably is no bot scanning for this. If it’s ever enforced, it must be through manual human action.
- Jensson 5y agoOr companies can report reviews and a bot react when lots of such reports triggers? I think the best solution would just to block the relevant capabilities related to the ban rather than deleting the whole account based on some strange activities. Why doesn't companies do this?
- nikanj 5y ago1) Have a group of humans perform this 2) Notice group of humans costs money 3) Replace group of humans with shitty ML/AI/Neural Net/XML/Blockchain
- shkkmo 5y agoA bad faith review would be a review made in bad faith. It seems rather redundant given the four preceding adjectives but serves as a catchall for reviews made with bad intentions (such as selling reviews...etc). The word I would pickout as the most ambiguous is "harmful"... harmful to whom?