3 ms·
Yes, this is missing the point that bitcoin isn't only about “Math”. Bitcoin is a peer to peer protocol even more than it is a cryptographic protocol. If you ha
by littlestymaar 5y ago
Yes, this is missing the point that bitcoin isn't only about “Math”. Bitcoin is a peer to peer protocol even more than it is a cryptographic protocol. If you have a private key but no access to the peer to peer network, you're not gonna do much with your bag of bytes.
(Btw, the enormous majority of bitcoin usage already goes through exchanges, just because it's almost the only practical way to use it so I don't really think this law is gonna change anything in itself)
- rfd4sgmk8u 5y agoI would say that as long as there is a communication channel provided to a person, they can interact with the bitcoin network. That is the great invention, a boring grey (digital) metal that can be transmitted over a communication channel. Plaintext channel level censorship can be circumvented by encryption and steganography. The blocks can be received by satellite today. Sending Transactions over SMS is a thing. This may exist today, but I assume in the future bots on WhatsApp will broadcast raw hex/base64 encoded transactions to the network for peers in restricted countries. Policing WhatsApp content is extremely difficult, we have seen in the recent years. One can restrict the centralized exchanges. One cannot control every communication channel, or prevent every ECDSA signature from being signed.
- littlestymaar 5y agoHaving full node connected to the chain through some whatsapp proxy is making exchange-less bitcoin usage even more cumbersome and dangerous than it already is. And it assume you can get this whatsapp proxy from a reliable source because it would be a pity if it was in fact a honeypot run by the government to find you (EncroChat-like).
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> Sending Transactions over SMS is a thing. This may exist today, but I assume in the future bots on WhatsApp will broadcast raw hex/base64 encoded transactions to the network for peers in restricted countries. Policing WhatsApp content is extremely difficult, we have seen in the recent years. If someone trusts a WhatsApp bot with their bitcoins, they brought it upon themselves.
- reginold 5y agoIt sounds like you may be missing some parts of how it works. A "transaction" is just a short string that includes a signature. It's impossible to manipulate or change. Therefore the only adversarial things the WhatsApp bot can do are 1. Not forward the transaction (I can tell relatively quickly by checking the mempool) 2. Doxx me/report me/etc by observing my IP, Whatsapp account name, and what wallet it is connected to. Besides that, I can put my transactions up on a billboard for all I care.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> 1. Not forward the transaction (I can tell relatively quickly by checking the mempool) You mixing things up here, the mempool won't help you since your whatsapp proxy could tamper it. The only reliable thing is the chain itself once your transaction has been inserted in a mined block. > 2. Doxx me/report me/etc by observing my IP, Whatsapp account name, and what wallet it is connected to. But when doing direct crypto transaction is a crime in your country, this is a more serious threat than “tampering the transaction” or anything. Going to jail, or being tortured by some gang who want your private key, or both depending how corrupt the police is in that country.
- reginold 5y agoHow can Whatsapp tamper with my transaction without my private key?
- littlestymaar 5y agoNot Whatsapp themselves, the proxying bot. And I'm not talking about tampering the transaction but the mempool (or at least the view you have about it) to make you believe they've forwarded the transaction. But as I said, this is not what matters: the doxxing part is the deadly threat.
- reginold 5y ago
- maccolgan 5y agoIf they wanted to make P2P protocols illegal, they will have to ban E2E encryption, I could be running the bitcoin protocol over Signal/Telegram/WhatsApp/HTTP. I could be transmitting signed transactions over the sneakernet over the border to a land where bitcoins are free North Korea style.
- littlestymaar 5y agoThey can make it illegal and call it a day. The successful crackdown of BitTorrent usage is a good illustration of that. The protocol is still here and you can use it, but the general public doesn't anymore. In the case of torrent, it causes seeding issues and severely limit the availability of non-mainstream stuff (finding non-Hollywood movies is hard for instance). In the case of bitcoin should the public don't use it anymore, the price would collapse, making the current mining unsustainable, and as the mining difficulty declines the robustness of the protocol reduces sharply, especially if state actors start buying the unused mining devices… BTW, the sneakernet is unsuited for most uses of bitcoin transactions: you don't just want to be able to transfer the token from one address to another. Most of the time a transaction is an interactive process: you send the money and I give you something in return after I've checked that I actually received the funds. This usage simply doesn't work well on the sneakernet, because of the very high latency.