3 ms·
Excellent. I hope they fix the deliberate botch they made of the use of ID cards as key carriers. As far as I know the hardware is fine but the Bundestag fucke
by gumby 5y ago
Excellent. I hope they fix the deliberate botch they made of the use of ID cards as key carriers. As far as I know the hardware is fine but the Bundestag fucked up the infrastructure.
Germany should look to Estonia who, IMHO, gets it right.
- Hendrikto 5y agoI, and a lot of people I know, microwave their German ID cards immediately upon receiving them. Bad enough that German citizens are required by law to have a valid ID card in the first place (see Ausweispflicht). Something pretty unique and a relic from the third Reich. We don‘t need more data on them. It will be leaked, it will be misused, it will have exploitable mistakes. ID cards should stay a dumb piece of plastic.
- gumby 5y agoI wouldn’t bother to do that myself, though it’s harmless since there’s essentially no infrastructure support for the chip in DE, which is my complaint. The chip only contains the info readable on the card plus what you want to store there (public keys, basically) and can’t be read remotely. I agree with you that mandatory ID cards are an affront to human rights, but you are sadly wrong to consider it unique to Germany. Quite the contrary: apart from commonwealth countries and the USA they required by all other OECD countries and many others besides (e.g. India, China, Malaysia, Russia…) Their origin predates the nazi era too. For example passport system was introduced on a “temporary” basis during WWI but rather than revoking it several countries used it as the foundation of their ID system.
- vlovich123 5y agoWhat are the differences in infrastructure and what choices did Estonia make that are better? Is it possible that a 83x larger population has different infrastructure needs and it’s not that Estonia did an outstanding job but that Estonia’s problem space is much simpler?
- solarkraft 5y agoPossible, but unlikely. The same principles tend to apply.
- gumby 5y agoWell, this isn’t what I was talking about but to your size point: there have been security bugs in the infrastructure which Estonia has been been aggressive in addressing, unlike DE, but that also matters in EE because they actually use the infrastructure. When the chip IDs were rolled out in DE the Bundestag didn’t put in place any rules requiring that that banks or others be required to use the PKI (even only when offered and available) to protect and authenticate personal information. So of course the banks didn’t bother. Without any major use case, nobody else did either. This was claimed at the time to be a way to let business lead, but really it was because business were happy not to have to provide extra privacy protection so lobbied against it. Compare that to chips in credit cards in the 1990s: they really cared about protecting money so put in all sorts of rules to make the use mandatory.