10 ms·
Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire
- brink 5y agoCancel your prime subscription, you don't need it. I canceled mine 3 years ago - couldn't handle the feeling that I was feeding the beast.
- DaveExeter 5y agoIf this article is correct, you are not "feeding the beast" by subscribing to Prime, you are taking food from the beast, since Prime is subsidized by Amazon.
- mint2 5y agoIf you have prime, you’re ordering a lot from Amazon. (Because otherwise why have prime) so having prime is feeding the beast unless analyzed with an excessively narrow bounding box. Whereas if one doesn’t have prime, there’s many other retailers.
- DaveExeter 5y ago"The losses Amazon sustains on Prime’s free shipping and selling goods below cost are how it maintains its monopoly power." According to this article, if you use Prime, you cost Amazon money.
- lil_dispaches 5y agoMaintaining monopoly power > losses
- cgriswald 5y agoNo, that's not what the article says. What the article says is that if you subscribe to Prime and purchase a certain amount, type, and quantity of goods in some configuration you might cause Amazon a loss. If you subscribe to Prime in any other way, Amazon might make less profit, but you're not costing them money, you're 'feeding the beast.'
- mint2 5y agoAs others point out, those “losses” are more than made up by the customer lock in effects and market dominance they bring. A sale on item “x” is not a loss if it’s net effect is to bring in massive profits. If there was no overall monetary benefit to prime it would be peculiar for Amazon to keep it.
- bduerst 5y agoAmazon inflates prices to include shipping costs on prime goods, despite the subscription giving free two day shipping. It's most obvious on smaller items that typically only cost only a dollar so, but with Prime free shipping they include the shipping cost in the price. The customer pays for the prime shipping.
- pwenzel 5y agoCancelled mine recently. I had to get back in the habit of shopping from other retailers. It's been just fine.
- GordonS 5y agoI like mine. Aside from package delivery (which isn't really a big selling point for me, TBH), my family and I watch a lot of content on Amazon Prime Video, and listen to a lot on Amazon Music. I find it good value for money. Now, rant about Amazon Music incoming! What I don't like though is all the spam Amazon does in Amazon Music to try to get you to upgrade to Amazon Music Unlimited - honestly, it's absolutely relentless! Multiple times a day it brings up a full-page and/or popup nag, and sometimes even does it in the middle of a track! I've been a member for several years, and must have said "no" thousands of times by now - you'd think the system would have realise by now that all they're doing is damaging good will.
- akhosravian 5y agoWhat mechanism would the system have realized it has damaged good will? You said you haven’t canceled your prime subscription, but have you started using the service less? I think this is a case where the relentless A/B testing ubiquitous in modern tech fails: how would one even measure this long term sentiment that may not affect user behavior for a very long time?
- cgriswald 5y agoAn A/B test should probably measure user complaints. A complaint is an indicator that a user’s usage pattern may change in the future. Of course, it may not. Although, as a user I’ve learned to complain by canceling (and explaining why when possible).
- GordonS 5y agoI meant if I was building just a system, it would be obvious to me not to nah that much, or even to provide a means to not be bothered again for 6 months or whatever. You're right that it's difficult to measure goodwill over long timescales, but IMO not everything needs to be 100% science driven - the team behind Amazon Music must know that excessively, relentlessly nagging already paying customers is going to a not them.
- C19is20 5y agoThanks for the heads up.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoIs it not a clue for regulators that nobody even dares to be quoted by name in such articles?
- Spivak 5y ago> That’s because more than 60 percent of Americans looking to buy something online start their product search on Amazon, rather than a search engine. > Steve has tried to escape Amazon’s grip by selling on other platforms. But he’s had no luck generating more than a trickle of orders on these sites. Kinda gives the game away, right? You're either sharecropping on Amazon's land or Google's. There is no scalable way for companies to reach their markets that doesn't involve something being the portal that people use to do product discovery. Whatever business finds themselves in this position will by its very nature wield disproportionate market power. You can't "break up" Amazon, Google, YouTube, Apple, and the countless other people who act as discovery portals into different markets -- you can only regulate them. > It would help if he could lower his prices on these sites, he says, but Amazon effectively blocks him from doing so under its “fair pricing policy.” You can't get the benefit of free marketing by being listed on Amazon and then try to screw them over by lowering prices on your own sites. This isn't monopoly power inasmuch as businesses not realizing that they're trying to get advertising and discovery for free without paying the piper.
- nsonha 5y agoHuge opportunity for alternative search engines but most of them don't do paid results
- jessaustin 5y agoThis is a strange understanding of "screw them over". Lots of products are sold for a range of different prices, and have been throughout economic history. Amazon appoint themselves "lowest-price king" because they can, not because they have some sort of moral right to that position.
- viro 5y agowhy should a business be allowed to overcharge Amazon customers? Your product should have a price not a Amazon price and a Shopify price.
- jessaustin 5y ago
- francisofascii 5y agoThe statistic that stood out to me: "For every $100 sellers earn in sales, Amazon is taking $34, up from $19 in 2014."
- mediaman 5y agoThe report suggests Amazon is taking 34% of third-party sellers' revenue. This sounds like a lot, but "revenue" in this case is the retail sales price of the goods. Traditionally, in a wholesaler-retailer model, the retailer "keystones" their cost on the good, meaning they arrive at the selling price by doubling their cost. This is of course a somewhat antiquated idea now (markups are generally lower now) but it gives you an idea of typical gross margins before selling costs (doubling the cost would give you 50% margins). 34% means that Amazon is keeping 34% of the retail price of the product as profit. That doesn't actually strike me as particularly high. It's not low (Costco is much lower, with 15% selling margins) but it's not particularly high either. The article goes on to complain about advertising costs. Welcome to retail! Are you ready to play slotting fees? End-cap fees? Promotional and coop fees? Most big retailers do this. I know of not-huge companies that pay millions per year, in advance, to a home improvement retailer to secure exclusivity over an entire shelf. It's one reason why selling to retail is annoying (versus selling to businesses), because almost all big retailers are extractive and prioritize their profits over great prices to consumers. But this article comes across as if they don't know anything about retail. There's a good argument that this kind of behavior is perhaps Day 2 behavior - the conversion into a big company that pushes for margins above all else. But it's not different from traditional retail.
- jjtheblunt 5y ago> 34% means that Amazon is keeping 34% of the retail price of the product as profit. <...> (Costco is much lower, with 15% selling margins) then later > But it's not different from traditional retail. Aren't these contradictory?
- aidenn0 5y agoCostco is not traditional retail. If you compare Amazon's margins to Costco it will look bad, if you compare it to a cosmetics store, it will probably look good. The (now old fashioned) rule of thumb was 50% margins, but as GP pointed out margins are lower now. 34% is within the ballpark of a brick-and-mortar store.
- 5y ago
- thayne 5y ago> That’s because more than 60 percent of Americans looking to buy something online start their product search on Amazon, rather than a search engine Even if you use a search engine, most of the top results are usually amazon, or a website that links to Amazon. At least in my experience.
- Scoundreller 5y ago> more than 60 percent of Americans looking to buy something online start their product search on Amazon I’d say it’s worse in other countries. The US probably has the most developed non-Amazon e-commerce market out there. In Canada, doing an eBay search too is usually a non-starter, and there we have fewer niche online retailers in the first place. Other countries without an e-commerce market right now risk becoming 100% dependent on Amazon.
- simonke 5y agoTo give you some insight about the situation in France: > It is very difficult to maintain diversity. Challengers can hardly face the leader head on. Amazon's dominance in e-commerce can always be put into perspective, as it only represents 13% of commerce in France today. Its position is much less dominant in France than in the United States. Except that e-commerce is far from having reached its saturation point. Translated with Deepl Source: Interview wiwth Philippe Moati, https://www.lenouveleconomiste.fr/philippe-moati-la-force-damazon-cest-dabord-la-faiblesse-de-ses-concurrents-90158/ https://www.lenouveleconomiste.fr/philippe-moati-la-force-da...
- nsonha 5y agofrom the title, I thought Amazon actually invested in toll roads. It sounds like an interesting idea if we could make big tech build infrastructure for the public.
- rkk3 5y ago> alleging that its pricing policy functions as an “anticompetitive restraint” that has “artificially raised the price of goods to consumers across online marketplaces” They are arguing that Amazon policy of having the lowest price for listings, artificially inflates the prices? So in order to not inflate prices, Amazon needs to raise prices???
- jessaustin 5y agoThey could leave their prices as they are. The suggestion is that they should stop punishing vendors who sell for less through other stores.
- mint2 5y agoSellers are not allowed to price lower on other online sites, how does Amazon setting a minimum allowed price not keep prices higher? Are you thinking of if Amazon had instead set a maximum allowed price policy?
- rkk3 5y ago> not allowed to price lower on other online sites Except the the policy is you cannot list on Amazon at a higher price, because they can only dictate the terms of their platform. Are they setting a minimum or a maximum? "Setting a price on a product or service that is significantly higher than recent prices offered on or off Amazon" [1]https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/G5TUVJKZHUVMN77V https://sellercentral.amazon.com/gp/help/external/G5TUVJKZHU...
- TheCoelacanth 5y agoThe two statements are logically equivalent. If you can't list at a higher price on Amazon than anywhere else, then you also can't list at a lower price elsewhere.
- rkk3 5y agoNot really, you have to make several huge assumptions for them to get close to logical equivalence like 1) ALL PRODUCTS ARE LISTED ON AMAZON 2) ALL PRODUCTS ARE LISTED ON AMAZON BY THE ORIGINAL UNIQUE MANUFACTURER Are two major ones.
- xiphias2 5y agoI don't understand the amount of hate for Amazon. I travel around the world, and whenever I was in the US and ordered from Amazon, got my package the same or next day for a very cheap price, I thought of moving to US just because how much easier it makes life there.
- mint2 5y agoBecause they know the actual cost of the convenience. The cost is far more than the item price being deducted from ones bank, there are externalities.
- shepherdjerred 5y agoI think it's mostly ethical concerns. Poor treatment of workers, anti-competitive practices, supporting a billionaire, etc.
- barbazoo 5y agoNobody is saying that they're not doing a good job. For me it's about the externalities such as poor treatment of their workforce, tax avoidance, worsening the consumption culture and environmental impact.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoAll of us play several different roles in life. Child, parent, employee, employer, friend, colleague, enemy, competitor, producer, consumer, activist, defendant, victim, oppressor, buyer, seller, exploiter, exploited, citizen ... Amazon is an amazing thing when we're wearing our consumer hat. Not perfect, but really deeply amazing. But if you put on some of the other hats, it's no longer so clearly a good thing. Wearing our consumer hat all the time ("Cheap! Fast! Great!") is not a positive thing for the overall structure of society.
- legitster 5y agoAmazon is consistently ranked near the top of trusted organizations. In real life I only know 2 or 3 people who might actually complain about Amazon. But being big means you draw more attention. And journalists love to give them attention.
- gumby 5y agoIncluding AWS and other products, Amazon’s total revenue is about 2% of total retail revenue. Calling it a retail monopoly is a bit of a stretch, to say the least. I try to avoid doing business with Amazon but I think arguments should start from a reasonable basis.
- Guest42 5y agoI'd claim that retail is such a vast category that it is entirely monopolistic.
- vishnugupta 5y ago> Amazon now pockets a 34 percent cut of the revenue earned by independent sellers I'm curious how this compares with other channels. I guess there's a wide range of spectrum; from having their own online/offline stores all the way till Amazon/Ebay etc.,
- jjoonathan 5y ago> “fair pricing policy.” Even though some competing platforms charge much lower fees, if Steve lowers his prices on another shopping site, Amazon’s algorithms punish him How the hell is this legal? Who do I donate to in order to start the ball rolling on making it illegal?
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most-Favoured-Customer_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most-Favoured-Customer_Clause
- jjoonathan 5y agoThanks for pointing me to the name. These things are gross, and we need to get rid of them ASAP. The whole spirit of market capitalism is "players are allowed to be relentlessly self-interested but we rely on competition to keep them in check." MFCs clearly undermine competition and therefore undermine the very foundation of our economy.
- aidenn0 5y agoThey exist on the other side of too: Discover typically charges the merchant lower fees than AmEx does when you checkout at a retailer. However the merchant is forbidden by it's agreements with AmEx (and Visa, and Mastercard) from giving you a discount if you use Discover card.
- jjoonathan 5y agoYou'll never guess what I think about credit card interchange fees and the contracts that prevent these prices from being exposed to the customers who could force Visa, Mastercard, and Discover to actually compete on price.
- jessaustin 5y agoThis should also be illegal, but one wouldn't expect much movement on this issue during the presidency of "the senator from MBNA".
- nayuki 5y agoI'm not going to speak for the Amazon situation. But comparing it to toll roads in the real world is disingenuous. Untolled roads are paid for by public taxes, they encourage driving, and people who don't drive end up subsidizing people who do drive.
- legitster 5y ago> To sell $10,000 worth of clothing today, Steve explains, he must pay Amazon $1,700 in referral fees and spend another $1,500 to $2,000 on ads So hold up... the "fees" include fulfillment and optional advertising expenses? And it's still only 34%? That's a bargain! In brick and mortar retail, you are lucky to get 50% margin on a product, and that's just in the stocking (fulfillment) costs - let alone advertising! It's also worth noting those referral fees are not just free money for Amazon - they are buying ad space on other sites on behalf of their customers (likely at a loss). So their report that Marketplace is secretly crazy profitable is mostly bunk - it basically assumes Amazon incurs no costs to ship and advertise products. The real problem they are dancing around here is that Amazon allowed the direct inclusion of international storefronts in the marketplace. Companies abroad can operate at much lower margins, and the traditional e-retail business model (buy from wholesalers, resell at markup to consumers) basically doesn't make sense anymore.
- listenallyall 5y agoA major advantage Amazon has over traditional retailers is that it will sell anything from anywhere, in fact it seems to prefer no-name brands from random Chinese factories over more established brands. Go try to buy power tools from Home Depot. It's Ryobi, Bosch, DeWalt, Craftsman, Makita, etc. Amazon has a ton of random brands at prices 30-60% less. The same holds true in many, many categories of goods. Camping gear. Lighting. Cookware. Surely some of these goods are inferior -- but given how much manufacturing has moved to China, some are just as good as name brand items. I think most retailers are overestimating the importance of familiar brands vs bottom line price.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoAmazon has mastered the art of selling cheap, crappy goods. At some point Walmart was the leader in this strategy but now Amazon has taken over the lead. I am increasing dreading to buy from Amazon because when you look for something you get 20 different listings of the same looking product with sketchy reviews. Their search also seems very manipulative sorting and showing and hiding of filter criteria based on probably an algorithm that benefits them.
- listenallyall 5y agoBut the quality of name brand goods has declined. The cheap, crappy stuff isn't all bad, some is quite good. I think more people are abandoning brands as they realize they paid a premium for a non-premium item. I think more people are embracing no-name stuff (with a return policy) than "dreading" it as you describe. (and yes, Amazon's algorithm benefits Amazon)
- antisthenes 5y agoWhat people in this thread aren't getting, because they're not in the industry as a 3rd party seller: Amazon is double dipping, because not only do you pay them a 15% fee to sell anything on their platform, now, increasingly in order for your products to get ANY visibility and traction, you also have to spend ~15-20% on advertising in order for your products to not get relegated to the 2nd or 3rd page, where customers won't go. This isn't because Amazon is evil. This is mostly because Amazon became too successful, so now where 4-5 sellers used to compete in a category, you now have 30+. So now you have no choice but to get them into a bidding war with each other for front page space, eating into their margins. Who's the main beneficiary of this? Amazon, of course. What's scummy of them is that they fully recognize this, yet refuse to reduce their 15% fee. In the past, the fee represented money paid to Amazon for your products to be visible on their platform (and for hosting product data and images). These days if you JUST pay the 15% fee, you will get literally 0 visibility and never get off the ground. But that's not all folks! Another way they're being scummy is having piss-poor algorithms that prevent you from raising the price on a product and disabling the listing for something they consider a high price. Well, obviously if you've created a system where you take 40% of the 50% markup, you constrain the 3rd party seller to never making more than 10% margin. Remember, this 10% must pay for 1. Returns 2. Employees that manage the catalog 3. Employees that manage order processing 4. Employees that deal with Amazon customer communication 5. Developers that make integrations for fulfillment purposes and help develop software to make catalog management easier. Is it any wonder then when this big brother is telling you to stop hitting yourself, while using your own hand to do so, that people get mad? Yet ANOTHER way they're being scummy is blatantly ripping off successful products, pushing them down, and promoting Amazon Basics brand or whatever they have now, selling the exact same thing. Tails I win, heads you lose indeed.
- aronpye 5y agoI think one solution is to force Amazon to charge itself seller fees on its own products and listings like Amazon basics products. That would help prevent it from anti-competitively under cutting competitor listings on price.
- Svettie 5y agoSome lively debate on this on Amazon's own Seller Forums: https://sellercentral.amazon.com/forums/t/amazons-toll-road-article-not-relevent-to-this-fbm-seller/937522/110 https://sellercentral.amazon.com/forums/t/amazons-toll-road-...