5 ms·
Refreshingly hype and agenda free reporting, as usual from Derek Lowe. And still "[vaccination] is better than a naive immune system" with the conspicuous gap
by h2odragon 5y ago
Refreshingly hype and agenda free reporting, as usual from Derek Lowe.
And still "[vaccination] is better than a naive immune system" with the conspicuous gap of where "already infected / recovered / might not have had symptoms even" might go.
"effective vaccines actually suppress variant formation" is going to get him yelled at for supporting antivaxer arguments, I bet.
- jaywalk 5y ago> "effective vaccines actually suppress variant formation" is going to get him yelled at for supporting antivaxer arguments, I bet. And yet you call this simple, scientific fact that wouldn't have been remotely controversial two years ago an "antivaxer argument"
- Retric 5y agoWhy is that supposed to be an antivaxer argument? It doesn’t mean an effective vaccine eliminates variant formation.
- jaywalk 5y agoI have no idea, I'm not the one who said it was. Even though the Covid vaccines don't prevent infection and transmission, by helping the body fight off the virus they absolutely do help prevent variant formation.
- landemva 5y agoVariants are developing in animals like cats and deer, and spreading back to humans. The sooner we get to variants that are highly transmissible with only cold-like effects, the sooner we can stop the nonsense about trying to prevent variants.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- metamet 5y agoThey also do reduce infection and transmission, just not completely prevent it all the time.
- jaywalk 5y agoThey definitely do not reduce transmission, at least not with the currently circulating variants: https://www.ucdavis.edu/health/covid-19/news/viral-loads-similar-between-vaccinated-and-unvaccinated-people https://www.ucdavis.edu/health/covid-19/news/viral-loads-sim...
- Retric 5y agoThat doesn’t support your argument. Although vaccinated people with a breakthrough infection are much less likely to become severely ill than unvaccinated, the new study shows that they can be carrying similar amounts of virus and could potentially spread the virus to other people Could potentially spread is not the same as saying their equally likely to spread. Fewer infections and less severe cases both reduce transmission to the general population at least in the short term. Long term it may be that effectively everyone gets either COVID and or the vaccine.
- jaywalk 5y agoWhen I say they don't reduce transmission, I mean (and the article backs up) that an infected vaccinated person transmits the virus just as much as an infected unvaccinated person. Probability of infection between the two groups is a different subject.
- Retric 5y agoThey specifically say: “Our study does not provide information on infectiousness.” That said, if people are equally infections while sick, but their sick for a shorter period then their less likely to infect others.
- kgwgk 5y agoI don't think it's an antivaxer argument but if you develop the reasoning it really becomes somewhat controversial. The problem is that vaccines are not completely effective (efficacy goes down with time, is lower against new variants, there are breakthrough infections, etc.) so variant formation is not completely supressed. Everything being equal (given one exposed or even one infected person) you may have less variant formation with vaccines. But when you have more infections you will end up having more variants. That the number of infections would increase as people's behaviour adapted to the lower fatality rate was not unexpected: people take more risks because the prognosis of an infection is not so bad anyway, once infected they may have a mild, undiagnosed evolution and still contribution propagation... And it's no longer an hypothetical scenario. In many European countries there are more infections now than ever before.
- sv123 5y agoI don't keep up with antivaxer arguments, and maybe I'm daft, but doesn't that mean if everybody were vaccinated then fewer variants would show up?
- neuronexmachina 5y agoYeah, I'm not sure how what the other commenter is saying follows from what Lowe wrote.
- Barrin92 5y agoyou gotta explain to me how that's an antivaxer argument because suppressing variant formation is a good thing. As he explains in the very next sentence strengthening the immune response lowers the risk of prolonged battles and chances for mutation which is what we want
- sigg3 5y agoAnti-antivaxer, i think.
- rafale 5y agoIs he saying the current vaccines are not efficient? I still don't get what makes covid different from the flu. Yes, covid is a little bit more deadly, but other than, why don't we just accept it as part of our lives like we did with the flu?
- landemva 5y agoFear sells.
- Retric 5y agoOver 700,000 (edit it’s now 800,000) dead Americans is about 20x as bad as the flu even with all of these measures, that’s huge. But even that understates the difference when you measure years of life lost. The flu typically kills the extreme elderly or people with extremely compromised immune systems. Aka they might die at 94 vs 95. COVID on the other kills people who are relatively much healthier, someone that dies at 75 vs 95 lost 20 years not 1. This is also why people 70+ are almost fully vaccinated in the US. For that age range it’s an extremely serious disease with a high chance of killing them after infection.
- dev_tty01 5y ago>This is also why people 70+ are almost fully vaccinated in the US. For that age range it’s an extremely serious disease with a high chance of killing them after infection. Older people certainly dominate the vulnerable groups, but there are many other people living with various forms of immune system dysfunction. This is why the rest of us need to mask, vaccinate, and get boosters to minimize our chance of propagating the disease to the more vulnerable parts of our population. Not doing so is basically saying you don't care about other people.
- stolenmerch 5y agoVery honest and good faith question. Until when? What are the specific metrics for when we don't need masks or non-tweaked vaccines tailored to yearly variants like normal flu shots? At some point we need to say "if you are immunocompromised you need to take special precautions like you always did before covid". Just wondering out loud when that should be because for some of us it's sooner rather than later.
- nobody9999 5y ago>"effective vaccines actually suppress variant formation" is going to get him yelled at for supporting antivaxer arguments, I bet. Are you implying that since variants exist, then the vaccines aren't effective? That's not what the data shows[1]. I'd point out that South Africa, where the Omicron variant was first characterized, vaccines have only ~30% penetration in the population[0], making it a good reservoir for mutated variants to spread. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/covid-vaccinations https://ourworldindata.org/covid-vaccinations [1] https://www.news-medical.net/news/20211123/Systematic-review-finds-COVID-19-vaccine-efficacy-remains-high-for-at-least-six-months.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20211123/Systematic-review...
- nradov 5y agoThe current thinking is that new variants are most likely to evolve in immunocompromised patients who experience prolonged infections. While I encourage everyone eligible to get vaccinated, the vaccines aren't very effective in people with malfunctioning immune systems. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/covid-variants-may-arise-in-people-with-compromised-immune-systems/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/covid-variants-ma...
- mlyle 5y agoNo, but increased vaccination rates and resultant lower case rates mean the conditions that are ideal for the formation of variants arise less often. (Yes, I know the vaccine isn't completely sterilizing, but it still has significantly tamped down the degree of spread).
- metamet 5y ago> While I encourage everyone eligible to get vaccinated, the vaccines aren't very effective in people with malfunctioning immune systems. Isn't the fact that folks with malfunctioning immune systems are surviving rather than dying evidence that the vaccine is working? Granted, their survival has the side effect of a prolonged infection, but immunocompromised folks don't fare well against COVID.
- nobody9999 5y ago