3 ms·
It's not a scam. It's a parody of the USD back when it was on the gold standard. Why is a fixed supply a bad idea for a day to day currency? Just look at Bitco
by imtringued 5y ago
It's not a scam. It's a parody of the USD back when it was on the gold standard.
Why is a fixed supply a bad idea for a day to day currency? Just look at Bitcoin.
A currency is effectively a public good, it's needed to facilitate trade. People sell stuff for currency and this creates a chain of transactions. If someone saves money beyond what they intend to spend, it's like damming a river. There are less transactions on the other side, in extreme cases no transactions may happen, which means an infinite chain of transactions has been interrupted. If the owner of the dam periodically releases the water (spends the money) then people downstream don't mind it. However, the dam owner may abuse his power and charge these people for the privilege of not having their water drained. (real interest) People get indebted to the dam owner but at least the infinite chain of transactions is no longer interrupted.
However, there is a problem with this. The dam owner makes it harder to make a living. Everyone starts building their own dam because it is more profitable than working. Suddenly, there are droughts everywhere even though there is no lack of water in the dams. That's how you get a 30s style depression. It's like panic buying money instead of toilet paper. All these Bitcoin investors are panic buying into it, for whatever (possibly valid) reason.
When you think about it, a fixed supply currency is meant to be exclusive for elites that don't want to give up their power.
In my opinion we might be in a mini depression (Japan and euro area) since 2008 or maybe even 2001. Our money systems are more flexible than a gold standard, however, pessimistic outlooks prevent banks from lending to small businesses. So you get a lopsided recovery at the top income spectrum where the rich are highly credit worthy and get their shoes kissed by the banks, meanwhile the average person still gets up to 10% interest for a small $10k loan.
- throwaway248329 5y ago>People sell stuff for currency and this creates a chain of transactions. If someone saves money beyond what they intend to spend, it's like damming a river. There are less transactions on the other side, in extreme cases no transactions may happen Please explain how does me not spending money stops others from spending theirs?
- MrMan 5y agoif everyone doesn't spend any money, and incentives encourage hoarding treasure instead of productive work, this is a bad outcome in the aggregate
- throwaway248329 5y agoNot hoarding, it's called saving. And people would still spend money because everyone has their own time preference and we're all going to die someday anyways. On the positive side, economy with a large number of savers would be less vulnerable to crisis. Governments won't be afraid to let zombie-companies die, because they know that people are not going to starve when this happens.