3 ms·
"partisan bile? Sounds more like the poster is an independent who's tired of Big-C vs. Big-L politics and really wants pragmatic change, not partisan line-toein
by timr 15y ago
"partisan bile? Sounds more like the poster is an independent who's tired of Big-C vs. Big-L politics and really wants pragmatic change, not partisan line-toeing."
I think I'm an independent, but it's probably objectively possible to look at my position here, and claim that I'm siding with the Democrats. So be it: if the Democrats want single-payer health care, then I'm on their side, and I guess it makes me "partisan" in the eyes of people who disagree.
There's nothing inherently wrong with being partisan -- the problem comes when people are partisan without reasons beyond party affiliation. Demonizing "partisanship" is a rhetorical trick that dresses up ad hominem attacks as legitimate debate.
- jacoblyles 15y ago"Partisan bile" refers to your snarky dismissal of the case for deregulation. There are real problems with regulation, including Sarbox. The law has encouraged cartelization of the economy by pushing firms towards acquisitions instead of IPOs. Most regulation punishes startups and protects incumbents. Sometimes the benefits are worth it but often they are not.
- timr 15y agoI said that degregulation was part of the usual conservative shopping list (which it is). That particular remark was no more or less snarky than the rest. But if your primary objection is that I'm snarky...well, that's great. My argument remains. In any case, I'm the first person to admit that there are problems with Sarbanes Oxley. I think that parts of the law were a total over-reaction to the situation, solving nothing. But I'd rather see ammendments to the law than a wholesale retraction. And that's where I differ from most conservatives.