5 ms·
Haiku would be an OS I would enjoy running every day if there were drivers for modern hardware and it ran the software I need. I stil hope it will get to that p
by DeathArrow 5y ago
Haiku would be an OS I would enjoy running every day if there were drivers for modern hardware and it ran the software I need. I stil hope it will get to that point one day. :)
- morganvachon 5y agoAgreed, I was a huge BeOS evangelist back when Be, Inc. was still around and a while after they were bought out. I ran it as my main OS for several years and to this day I prefer its interface, multimedia back-end, and file system to anything modern. Haiku would scratch that itch if only, as you said, it supported modern hardware and current necessary software. This announcement is one step closer to the former becoming a reality, and I'm so there for it! I feel like once it's stable enough for use as a daily driver hardware-wise, the software porting side will begin to catch up.
- mdp2021 5y ago> drivers for modern hardware How well does Haiku work on bare iron nowadays? Any tested laptops - better, any repository of tested brand/models, or of tested hardware in general?
- cardanome 5y agoAnecdotally, when I tested it on an old ThinkPad last year, it worked fine. I was really impressed.
- mrweasel 5y agoI tested R1/beta3 on an old NUC. I can't remember if BlueTooth worked, but everything else was supported, including the wireless NIC. Note that the wireless only works if you do an install, the live-cd won't be able to use the wireless driver for some reason.
- morganvachon 5y agoI've had the best luck with older "office PCs" like HP EliteDesk/ProDesk series and Dell Optiplex machines. They tend to standardize around the most common denominator components like Intel or Realtek Ethernet NICs and Intel iGPUs and nothing too esoteric. Laptop support has gotten better recently, with many Thinkpad models from the past decade working more or less 100% out of the box in my experience. My biggest issue running Haiku bare metal has persisted across hardware and form factors though: Stability. I can't seem to keep a machine running for more than a few days without a kernel panic or a frozen GUI. I haven't tried the latest snapshot on my "newest" acquisition, a Haswell era HP EliteDesk castoff from work, it's my project for this coming weekend and I'm looking forward to seeing how long I can keep it running.
- waddlesplash 5y agoIf you can so consistently reproduce kernel panics, it would be good to open a ticket. However, that has been less and less of a problem in recent years, and a lot more panics were squashed in the past few months, especially USB related ones. So you might try a nightly build and see if things are improved; if not, please do open a ticket.
- morganvachon 5y agoIt was indeed on older official releases on those older machines, I never got into the nightly builds that much. I will try both the latest release and latest build this weekend when I work on the new hardware, and I'll report any showstopping bugs. Now that I think about it, it definitely could be USB related on those other machines too. I've used the same cheap USB KVM for years and it has polling issues in Windows 10, I didn't even consider that might be the source of my issues elsewhere. I'll try it without the KVM and see what happens. Thanks!
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoI ran it briefly on a laptop (thinkpad) and it worked remarkably well; the only real issue was that Haiku really needs mouse and that model's inputs were kind of awful
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoYeah, I think I would too. At the very least I would love to tell Windows to shove it and have an option that wasn't as horrifically terrible as Linux Desktop. The latter issue (software) would be mitigated significantly in my case if it had a good hypervisor and a WINE port, but the former issue seems nigh-insurmountable given the amount of hardware around today. It's really sad because it's a big reason that we don't have more experimentation in the Desktop OS space.
- nyanpasu64 5y agoHaiku has less of a software problem than I expected, since Qt has been ported to it, and it has some (not the majority of) Qt apps, as well as the Qt Creator IDE. I'm not sure if Qt apps are as light and responsive as native Haiku apps though. Unfortunately I never did find supported hardware and clear out enough hard drive space to install it (despite shuffling my disks around and losing my last copy of important files). Perhaps I could try running it in a VM, but why not use the outside OS at that point?
- smallstepforman 5y agoTalking about supported hardware, I always select hardware that will run the software I want, not the other way around. When I build my desktop PC last year, it was all AMD hardware. Haiku works great on it, and with X512’s vulkan driver, I’ll even have 3D acceleration. I’m buying a laptop in 2 months, again, it will be all AMD hardware. And Haiku will run great on it. As will Linux.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoAs usual it's a matter of what you're trying to do and how closely it matches the things the devs are trying to do. My only real attempt to use it lately was on an old eeePC I only really wanted to use for remoting into my home Windows PC and I ran into a bunch of issues with the only working RDP client (commandline-run FreeRDP). Waddlesplash even had to pick up on a post of mine here on HN and take it upon themselves to update FreeRDP to get to that point. It functions, but is seemingly unable to resize or even go fullscreen despite specifying the relevant commandline arguments, which on the tiny monitor is a problem because it leaves me forcing it to run in a less-than-fullscreen resolution that accommodates the title tab and moving it to the top-left corner. Personally, I am not a fan of the reliance on ported-from-unix packages. Especially considering that there is currently no autoremove for the mountains of dependencies that they bring with them. If Haiku had containerization this could be more easily mitigated, but as far as I'm aware it doesn't. > Perhaps I could try running it in a VM, but why not use the outside OS at that point? My feeling as well.
- hyperman1 5y agoCould it be possible to shove the linux kernel under the Haiku userland? This would give access to all drivers available in linux. You could sacrifice compatibility with the linux or POSIX userland. A bit the same thing as WSL1, but from Linux tu Haiku.
- MisterTea 5y agoThere is a defunct project which did exactly that called BlueEyedOS. http://blueeyedos.com/ http://blueeyedos.com/
- AshamedCaptain 5y agoThis is why I dislike Linux. Some of the policies regarding drivers may make sense, but the net result is that rather than having a lively ecosystem of free operating systems with all of them sharing decent hardware support, we have a Linux monoculture with it being the only operating system with any type of hardware support and the rest being terrible compared to it (even Windows is bad). In part I guess it's because there is no Linus-enforced requirement to have sane specifications, rather than only code. In fact, they seem to encourage having Linux-specific drivers to the detriment of other OSes. Having non-upstream "generic" drivers is not only heavily frowned upon but also rather hard due to the constant breaking API changes. And for upstreamed drivers, you basically have to make your kernel code all but Linux-specific in order to have any chance; generic code or code that doesn't use all the specific Linux infrastructure is basically forbidden everywhere except staging/. The lack of stable API/ABI should in theory prevent "write-once-and-forget" drivers, as well as discourage proprietary ones, but in practice we have both of these. I would really like to see how the world would look like if there was one stable, open, popular API for drivers.
- kitsunesoba 5y agoI think that perhaps pushing for drivers in userspace wherever possible would improve this situation significantly. Userspace drivers for Linux would still be built with various Linuxisms, but at least you get all the kernel specific bits disentangled which improves portability a lot and makes writing compatibility layers for other operating systems more feasible.
- dusted 5y agoIn that case you better start lobbying your software vendors for Haiku supports.
- snvzz 5y agoI have to wonder how supporting RISC-V and amdgpu does not count as modern hardware.
- rvz 5y agoThe goalposts of ‘modern hardware’ and ‘modern web browser’ will be moved forever with HaikuOS on HN, even when it can apparently run on real RISC-V hardware with a GUI, has a Chromium-derived Web-browser and now is about to get 3D HW acceleration via amdgpu. When compared with other certain unified hobby OSes out there written in C++ or Rust, they don’t even come anywhere close to being useable. Not even a complex browser or office app running. They are still stuck in a VM and yet celebrated here even when this OS is able to run all of that on real hardware after installation. If RISC-V is not modern hardware, then I don’t know what is.
- themodelplumber 5y agoSo you'd be OK with no login password on your daily driver? Personally that gave me a little bit of pause when trying it out. Still haven't decided what I think about it.
- nix23 5y agoIt's a single user system...just like dos.
- themodelplumber 5y agoSo I guess just like I did with DOS, I should design my own "FBI" faux login screen in Lazarus, or some other RAD equivalent of QuickBasic? :-)
- bitigchi 5y agoYou could help integrating full disk encryption, and a login screen. :)
- themodelplumber 5y agoI'm curious, is a native login screen desired by project developers? I was under the impression that it wasn't, so much.
- bitigchi 5y agoIt's just that no one got around to that yet, also a login screen without disk encryption does not mean much. For reference, there's a drive encryption[1] implementation on alpha status, but it needs to be merged and reworked into the system. [1] https://github.com/axeld/driveencryption https://github.com/axeld/driveencryption
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoYou can want a lock screen (optionally paired with data encryption) even on a single user machine for privacy reasons.
- oweiler 5y agoBeOS is older than Win 95 so I have my doubts.
- somewhatbetter 5y agoWhich is relevant because?
- rvz 5y agoMinix is even older than Windows 95. Does that mean Linux does not run on modern hardware? So Linux is Minix then?Where does it say that Haiku is BeOS?