5 ms·
An Entrepreneurial Fix for the U.S. Economy
- timr 15y agoAh, yes...the usual conservative shopping list: de-regulation (eliminate Sarbanes-Oxley! Sunset regulations!), tax cuts for the rich (Who likes capital gains taxes? Certainly not the hard-scrabble "entrepreneur" managers of "small-company" hedge funds!), privatize shared knowledge (Make it easier for rich people to get patents, and commercialize academic research!). But somewhat unsurprisingly, the WSJ omitted an extremely important bullet: * single-payer health care. It's a huge problem. Gigantic. How many people in the US are putting off their entrepreneurial dreams because they're afraid of being waylaid by the costs of unexpected health problems? I'm not that old, and it worries me. It has to be terrifying to people with families. Dear WSJ: if you want me to take your opinions about "entrepreneurship" seriously, you have to stop proposing things that benefit the old economic guard (I've yet to meet an entrepreneur who would start a business but for the capital gains tax), and start proposing things that benefit actual entrepreneurs. (And by "entrepreneur", of course, I mean "someone starting a business" -- not "someone managing a hedge fund".) But, of course...I'm being willfully naïve. The WSJ doesn't really want to benefit entrepreneurs. They want to help the rich people who read the WSJ, and dress it up to look like they're helping entrepreneurs. Big difference.
- jacoblyles 15y agoI'll ignore your partisan bile and address your salient point (Yes, regulations do have costs. Sorry.). My friend's startup was offering health insurance within 6 months after it was initially incorporated. Most of the founders had some sort of individual plan or COBRA before then. Are you telling me that there are many people out there resourceful enough to be successful entrepreneurs but not resourceful enough to cover that gap? Count me among the skeptical of the idea that government health care will unlock a torrent of entrepreneurial energy. If government support is necessary for entrepreneurs, why isn't Silicon Valley located in old Europe? I have to admit that the idea that government provided health care is necessary for entrepreneurship has been a successful meme. I see it repeated everywhere even though I haven't heard a convincing case for it. You gotta admire the persistence and message discipline if nothing else.
- sologoub 15y agoI agree with your sentiment about resourcefulness, but I'd probably also say that the spirit of the article is that government should do all it can to lower the barrier to entry and thereby promote more competition. One other item I found annoying is the bit about premium paid for expedited patent applications - this will simply not work because the current tech giants will simply flood the system with expedited patents and the government will be able to collect more revenue, while those who cannot afford the expedited fees will be stuck waiting even longer.
- ap22213 15y agopartisan bile? Sounds more like the poster is an independent who's tired of Big-C vs. Big-L politics and really wants pragmatic change, not partisan line-toeing. Look, I don't know what age you are, but health care at upper-30s is no easy street, and from what I hear, it gets much, much worse. Just in the past year, I dropped 10K on health care expenses, and that is _with_ fantastic insurance. Edit: and, seriously - I'm no slouch. I'm an extremely healthy upper-30s guy who runs, weight-trains, eats like godliness. I'm guessing the audience of HN is probably lower-middle 20s. Well, trust me, health problems still creep up (on some of us), even with uber lifestyle.
- anamax 15y ago> Look, I don't know what age you are, but health care at upper-30s is no easy street, and from what I hear, it gets much, much worse. I'm "low 50s" and a fairly premium plan didn't cost me much. > Just in the past year, I dropped 10K on health care expenses, and that is _with_ fantastic insurance. Wowswers. However, if that's expected costs, that's an argument for not subsidizing you. And, if it's unexpected costs, that's an argument for catastrophic health insurance, not ordinary health insurance, which is little more than pre-paid expenses.
- ap22213 15y agoYes - I see your point. Ok - A sizable portion of the 10K happened between jobs. Another large chunk was dental. So, I'm packing a lot into that number that I probably shouldn't. And, I apologize for that. I guess I'm just bitter about it. Healthcare has personally burned me, and I find it a personal distraction and barrier. But, I need to recuse myself from healthcare discussions.
- sologoub 15y agoI'm guessing what they mean by exemption for capital gains is not a broad one, but one geared at promoting more seed and angel funding. It's actually not a terrible idea - tax the traditional investment vehicles the same way they are today, but provide an incentive to go into much riskier forms of investment that also serve more of a public good. I'm not sure it would really work, but it lowers the returns levels you would need to break even, compared to other investment options.
- anamax 15y ago> but provide an incentive to go into much riskier forms of investment that also serve more of a public good. Special incentives is how GE pays $0. Any proposal that ignores effects like regulatory capture is either deceptive or ignorant.
- bfe 15y agoSomehow I doubt startup founders have been desperately waiting for a new government bureaucracy that will finally give them a way of finding out good locations to start a new company.
- sologoub 15y agoYeah, this part of the article is a waste of space...
- anigbrowl 15y agoThis is superficially interesting, but the article is too short to explore the ramifications of the proposed changes. I'm looking at the Kauffman foundation report now (http://www.kauffman.org/research-and-policy/startup-act.aspx http://www.kauffman.org/research-and-policy/startup-act.aspx), but my seat-of-the-pants reaction to the proposals goes like this: Letting in immigrant entrepreneurs who hire American workers. Sure...but why not just open up the labor market and have done with it, rather than trying to predict in advance which immigrants will adjust the demand side? I think this is a necessity given the US's demographic problem (ie making sure there are enough workers to fund social security in the coming years), but it won't lead to endless expansion since both demographics and regional wage competition are projected to even out during the 2030s. Reducing the cost of capital through capital gains tax relief for early stage investments. I'd like to see numbers on this. The startup world appears to be awash in cheap capital already and that taxes are on capital gains rather than capital investments - in other words, you're not paying that tax unless your investment make a profit. Capital gains tax is already fairly low compared to income taxes, and many would argue that the problem is not early stage access to seed capital but mid-stage access to revolving capital during a period of slack demand. ISTM that demand is going to remain slack until the housing market is more predictable and the consumer debt overhang is gone. Reducing barriers to IPOs by allowing shareholders to opt out of Sarbanes-Oxley. This seems sensible, since the cost of compliance for SarbOx is high. But if large firms already have that priced in, how does one avoid a two-tier system whereby opted-out companies are unable to get an 'investment grade' rating for their commercial paper? Again, it would help to have some numbers quantifying the cost of compliance, and some kind of strategy for dealing with the corner cases where bad faith or incompetence result in serious losses. Charging higher fees for patent applicants who want quick decisions to remove the backlog of applications at the Patent Office. Wouldn't it be better for Congress to just let the patent office keep its own fees? Selling access just raises the barrier to entry and effectively cedes control of the patent landscape to big players like IV or various large corporations that already devote $$$ to patent litigation. If anything, this change would reduce the negotiating power of entrepreneurs with patentable ideas during pre-IPO funding rounds. Giving licensing freedom to academic entrepreneurs at universities to accelerate the commercialization of their ideas. That one went over my head - I thought this was already allowed under the Bayh-Dole act, and with relatively low transaction costs. Having the government provide data to permit rankings of startup friendliness of states and localities. Surely this is better provided by someone like Gartner group or some other entity. Assigning bureaucrats to the task of measuring bureaucracy seems perverse. Information about incorporation fees, median wait times, and tax regimes is already available on state websites, and evaluating it is exactly the sort of thing one pays lawyers and accountants for. That falls under 'due diligence' from an investment standpoint. Regular sunsets for regulations and a consistent policy of putting new ones in place only if their benefits exceed their costs. I'm for sunsets, legislative performance targets, and empirical microeconomics in general. But again, more specificity is needed here: what sort of regulations do the authors consider wasteful? There are pointless regulations like excess credentialism, but many regulations exist to address real problems. I was sort of happy to see the FDA requiring the recall of turkey meat a week or two back, since I'd rather not consume e. coli-tainted food. EDIT: the pdf on the startup bill (at the link above) addresses quite a few of my objections, is well-argued in many respects, and is moderate rather than partisan. Still, I stand by my basic contention that much of the problem stems from economic uncertainty on the demand side, rather than a paralyzing excess of red tape on producers. To take the HN community as an example, when did you last see people complaining about the inability to procure a business license or the complexity of buying worker's comp insurance? Has anyone actually thrown up their hands and moved their firm across state lines to reduce their fixed or marginal cost of doing business, or shut a firm down and handed the money back because the administrative costs didn't make economic sense?