5 ms·
There are many places in the US where a skilled blue collar worker can buy a house and look after a family. But HN users tend to have a distorted perspective si
by nradov 5y ago
There are many places in the US where a skilled blue collar worker can buy a house and look after a family. But HN users tend to have a distorted perspective since most of them live in the SF Bay Area and other expensive areas.
- YesThatTom2 5y agoWhere? Where in the US can someone live on blue collar salary and afford a mortgage?
- b9a2cab5 5y agoPlenty of places in the Midwest/South if you're a tradesman. Obviously a McDonald's worker or Starbucks barista is probably not going to be able to afford a mortgage.
- stefan_ 5y agoThis is obvious because? We certainly have the wealth for it.
- derbOac 5y agoI agree with you, speaking from experience with family. But I also see the spillover from the coasts as threatening this. The "wealthy refugees from the west coast" has become a real thing. Maybe it's all about [over]population and age distributions.
- butMyside 5y agoThen spend all their retirement on medical care for their broken body. We treat each other like animals no matter the job. Moral relativism has never gone anywhere. It was black people, and women, now it’s just poor people. Still flogging Anglo gibberish law when it’s clear it’s all just biological need being held hostage by political corruption empowering cliques like a fucking high school
- samsolomon 5y agoMost small and mid-sized cities? I lived in Mobile, Alabama for a couple years. I rented an awesome 1,400 sq ft place with power, gas and water included for about $600/mo. Looking at that same street on Zillow it looks like there are a few 3br 2ba homes for around $200,000.
- throwaway803453 5y agoOne of the properties I own is in Reno which is a 4hr drive from SF. It's a 2br 1ba condo which Zillow estimates $207k. It's nice, fully remodeled. That would be $900 mortgage + $180 hoa + $50 taxes (?) = ~$1200/mo ? Make $20/hour like most folks in this working class neighborhood do and you are all set. Get a roommate or a spouse that works part time if you can't earn $20/hr.
- jkaptur 5y agoEnviably close to Tahoe, too.
- afpx 5y agoMost of the US, I'm guessing. There are 53 million people living out in rural areas. The vast majority aren't college educated. People just live on a lower standard of living and get by with less. For example, my sister just bought a $28,000 3 bedroom house. It's a boring old company home, in a boring and uneducated area of the country. But, she has lived there all her life and enjoys the people and culture.
- abernard1 5y ago> Where? Where in the US can someone live on blue collar salary and afford a mortgage? Most places that aren't deep blue cities. That seems like hyperbole but is true. Picking just a few cities, the median house prices/sq footages are: - Houston, TX: $238K, 2031 sq ft - Indianapolis, Indiana: $196K, 1853 sq ft - Oklahoma City, OK: $152K, 1455 sq ft - Atlanta, GA: $399K, 1586 sq ft Each one of these places has a cost of living (excluding real estate) less than 50% that of CA as a whole. All >1M size metros. The most expensive, Atlanta, has a combined monthly payment inc taxes of $1700 a month on a 30-yr. That's $20,400 a year. Median plumber salary in Atlanta is $63K a year, so this would be 1/3rd their income. Once again, that's median salary and salaries rise sharply at mid-career, and median home price.
- throw0101a 5y agoGenerally speaking, the US population is quite concentrated. 66% of people live with-in 100mi (160km) of a border: * https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone https://www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-border-zone A sizeable portion live on the coast: > As of 2014, nearly 40% of the population lived in counties on the coast. * https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/population.html https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/facts/population.html So presumably there's a decent amount of space 'in the middle'.
- eru 5y agoYes, there are many places like that. Alas, there's almost no overlap between those places and the most productive parts of the country. GDP would be enormously increased, if eg more people could move to New York City or Silicon Valley. See also https://www.mercatus.org/publications/monetary-policy/shut-out https://www.mercatus.org/publications/monetary-policy/shut-o...
- biomcgary 5y agoOr would GDP be increased more (and more evenly distributed, both geographically and demographically) if the jobs in NYC or SV were all required to be remote? Imagine if every small town in the country had HN types bringing money into the local economy instead of taking it out.
- eru 5y agoNo. Increase in GDP means that someone is making more money. And you seldom have to _require_ anything to get people to make more money. Companies and workers already have the option to negotiate remote working arrangements. And had for a long time. > Imagine if every small town in the country had HN types bringing money into the local economy instead of taking it out. They'd just take it out to another 'local' economy. What makes some random spot more deserving than some other random spot? And in any case, on a macro scale there's basically as much money in the national economy as the Fed wants there to be. If there's some process that makes money magically vanish (eg perhaps those wacky foreigners selling you goods but then just burying the cash you pay them, instead of spending it), then the Fed will just issue more money to make up for the shortfall. Similarly, if those foreigners dig the money back up, the Fed will just sell a few items off their balance sheet to soak up the extra money.
- Nevermark 5y agoYou are responding to arguments about GDP with arguments about money supply. Inflation adjusted GDP is a completely independent measure/concept/entity/quantity from money supply.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]