6 ms·
> At a high level, the story of Zillow Offers is a story of our industry at its best. Not in my book. All I see is the price of real estate being driven up by
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
> At a high level, the story of Zillow Offers is a story of our industry at its best.
Not in my book. All I see is the price of real estate being driven up by corporate greed and the individual home-buyer being shut out of the market.
Is it wrong of me to hate "flippers" (be they corporate or private)? Pure capitalists will tell me that every property sold went to the highest bidder — in the case of a flipper winning they were willing (able) to risk the capital to hopefully turn a profit on the flip.
I suspect if you dig deeper you might find sales going to flippers because they had 100% cash offers, because they are better at "the game". I see no reason to punish prospective first-time home owners in this sort of market.
But I don't know what the answer is either.
- chii 5y agoflippers make the real estate market more liquid, in the same way high-frequency trading does for stocks. Flippers take the risk of the market falling while they're flipping - that's the price they pay for their profits.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoYou'll have to educate me then: is more liquid better for the buyers or sellers?
- loeg 5y agoLiquidity is good for both buyers and sellers.
- javert 5y agoBoth. In an illiquid market, it takes a long time to find buyers or sellers. You are incentivized to overprice (if selling) or underprice (if buying) and wait a long time to see if someone will match you. A liquid housing market means people can buy or sell the house at the "right" price without waiting many months or years. As a seller, would you rather wait a year to make a bit more money? That wouldn't be good. That would be crappy.
- rswail 5y agoSure, but the more important point is that the market represents housing. Having housing empty is pointless, so market speculation is that is not about the rent from the asset but only its capital growth leads to that exact outcome, empty housing has lower expenses and depreciation in reality, which helps maintain the asset's value better than if someone was living in it.
- javert 5y agoI haven't heard of housing sitting empty. Even if there is a flipper in the chain of possession, houses end up getting acquired by long-term investors who rent them out or people who actually live in them. As far as I'm aware.
- encoderer 5y agoHere’s a thought experiment: if I told you the market was going to be less liquid and you may not be able to easily sell the house you’re about to buy, wouldn’t that change your behavior? I think you’ve bought into the tik tok narrative that somehow it’s zillows fault that houses are expensive.
- rswail 5y agoI'm buying housing for myself. It would be a potential relevant thing to take into account between choices, but I still need a house. I'm buying a long term asset, so the liquidity of the housing market is not relevant to me, unless I'm actually buying for a specific short term, like a planned work period. Liquidity of the housing market is only important to the agents and the loan originators because they make money on the flow.
- eropple 5y ago> if I told you the market was going to be less liquid and you may not be able to easily sell the house you’re about to buy, wouldn’t that change your behavior? No. Like a normal person, I bought my house to live in and to improve and to stay in for a long period of time. It isn't a speculative investment vehicle.
- encoderer 5y agoIt seems like you’re presenting a straw man. Being able to sell your house and not be tied to one home for life is a reasonable desire that has nothing to do with speculative investment.
- eropple 5y agoNo, it's that if I need to sell it I've structured my finances and my life to be able to take time to do it--because I've intentionally made decisions with the remodeling in my home to be suboptimal for selling anyway. I'd have to put up a wall and reroute a bunch of plumbing for my laundry room off my master bedroom so I could turn it back into a bedroom because that's what the dollar-signs-for-eyes crew values, so why would I be worried about selling it in 48 hours? This is an industry I actually know a teensy bit about. Normal people don't need to sell a house in two weeks. That is an abnormal condition brought on by stupid, disinterested money flooding the market and the idea that everyone must be hyper-mobile all the time is one brought on by the more deranged, "humans exclusively acting as work producing automatons" part of a market economy. Solidity and permanence are valuable. I'd go so far as to say that when you take into account the benefits of long-term residence and ownership--and they are benefits you will not see in your ML model, such as a cohesive neighborhood where you actually know and maybe even interact with the people who live around you--that it might even be a positive to discourage market thrash. You know. For humans, and not investors.
- perpetualpatzer 5y agoArguably, it's good for both. Buyers have more quality inventory to choose from and can purchase a home with lower risk of getting trapped in it permanently. Sellers get faster sales with a higher floor on prices.
- loeg 5y agoWhat's even arguable about it? Liquidity is good for market participants, period.
- _xnmw 5y agoLiquidity is NOT good in a dire-necessity supply-constrained market like housing, because it invites capital which could've been spent elsewhere to lock up unnecessary housing units (houses are empty while being flipped), further constraining supply of a critical resource. Imagine if drinking water was treated as a speculative asset, with large percentages of a countries water supply being stored in tanks and sold back-and-forth on paper between capital-rich investors instead of actually being pumped to where it was needed through pipes.
- chii 5y ago> Imagine if drinking water was treated as a speculative asset, with large percentages of a countries water supply being stored in tanks then you'd see people not waste any water at all, and fix any pipe leakage, and conserve water, and use water efficient agriculture methods etc. The price of a commodity determines how much and how easily it is available. The fact that water is so liquid (both in terms of the price, as well as being an actual liquid) is because of the high amount of investments made into obtaining it over the past centuries. Liquidity of any asset (or commodity) is a good feature to have imho.
- _xnmw 5y agoYou'd also have people die of thirst, just like the homelessness problem in expensive cities in the US right now.
- _xnmw 5y agoFlippers also reduce the supply of housing units for the time they are unoccupied, which could be months or years, especially when sold to other flippers. More liquidity is not necessarily a good thing for the housing market, as it tends to increase the number of speculators on the market, contributing to a vicious cycle where more homes are being flipped between speculators than actually occupied by people who need them. It pains me to watch people apply simplistic theoretical laws of supply and demand to something as complicated as housing. The map is not the territory. There are massive costs to increasing supply, as well as psychological/community costs to moving homes, which are not cleanly captured in any Economics 101 textbook.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mberning 5y agoPeople would probably suggest regulation or taxes to “fix” the problem but I think the root of the issue is artificially low interest rates, freewheeling lenders (again), and the fact that there are few other places to deploy your money and get some yield. There is also the tax benefits of owning income properties which should probably be looked at.
- pontifier 5y agoThe answer is to reduce regulation. The process of building new structures is filled with so much regulatory friction that it is impossible for the average person to even consider building their own home.
- skohan 5y agoWhich regulations would you relax? Surely there is some unnecessary red tape, but it's not as if building regulations have been developed for fun, it's largely in response to safety issues and so on.
- loeg 5y agoQuite a lot of regulations have nothing to do with safety. Minimum set-backs, minimum parking requirements, maximum building heights, etc. All of these add cost and reduce density. Single-family zoning is another local government policy that is absolutely intended to constrain development, not improve safety.
- skohan 5y agoWell as someone who lives in a fairly regulated housing market (Berlin) I'm happy about all the regulations you've mentioned as they prevent negative externalities which would benefit real-estate developers at the cost of everyone else. Imo targeting a specific population density is within the mandate of local government, as too-high density causes all sorts of issues from traffic to health and everything in between. If you want to unchain developers on density, I invite you to take a 10km drive in Delhi or Bangkok and tell me if the cost generated on a daily basis in terms of time and stress is worth it. I am in favor of finding ways to encourage more housing, but what you're calling for is essentially to invite favela housing in the developed world.
- hogFeast 5y agoSeriously? Berlin's tower blocks are the favelas of the developed world. Also, the reason why Berlin hasn't had the same pressure is because it is one of the few cities in the developed world that has actually shrunk over a multi-decade period. It is very easy to limit population density when there is no pressure on housing. And, ofc, the historical division of the city meant that it had to develop more than one centre. These factors aside, afaik, the development of Berlin hasn't been exceptional...they built suburbs when there was pressure on housing in the early 20th century, built public transport, those suburbs eventually integrated into the city...very few cities have grown through greater intensity in the centre because cost is prohibitive, regardless of regulations. Nothing to do with regulations, everything to do with historical circumstance (also, the guy you replying to is quite correct...if you actually look at housing regulations in the US, they have been a tool for racial/economic segregation...being real, that is why the limit on multi-family housing exists, the US has very low population density, saying they will become Delhi if they reduce regulations is hysterical).
- throwhauser 5y agoThe answer is to build houses and print money to buy them with. If houses were a (much) smaller bet for the buyer, there would be more flexibility to build houses where demand exists and a faster, lower-drama exit for people who don't like the changing nature of their in-demand neighborhood. The inertia created when people have their life savings tied up in their house perpetuates the problem of affordability, by making the areas that have the most mismatched supply vs demand the least likely to deal with the problem.
- javert 5y agoYes, you are wrong to hate flippers. You are wrong to hate anyone who is working hard to make an honest living. Yes, flipping is hard work. All successful work probably displaces someone else in some way. If you're good at your job, you're "denying" that job to someone less skilled. If you work in software, you're automating things that would require more labor if done manually. Fortunately, humans can pivot. Either hate everyone, or hate no-one. You can't just hate flippers.
- loeg 5y agoI think there are ways to make money that are socially negative value -- e.g., theft is a pretty obvious one, or bitcoin mining. House flipping isn't a social negative. They're doing a productive activity and producing value. They aren't long-term speculators removing housing stock from the market. It's essentially home renovation, done by a 3rd party owner.
- javert 5y agoBitcoin people believe it is a moral good (myself included), and have extremely strong arguments in favor of that view, which are rooted in morality and economics. Thus, when you make a snide anti-bitcoin remark without actual content, you come across as trying to invalidate bitcoin through mere peer pressure, which we all know is juvenile. It's like Trump voters who criticize "libtards." We all know it's not a valid way to discuss something. In fact, the expansion of the fiat money supply enriches the wealthy through the Cantillon effect. Then, because the value of money is going down, they pile into assets like housing. For instance, the US is becoming a nation of renters due to this effect. The stock market is similarly distorted. We need bitcoin because we need an objective form of money. That would allow stocks and houses to stop being stores of wealth and reflect their true economic value, which would be a huge boon to everybody. I'm guessing the energy thing is what you think your anti-bitcoin argument would be. Bitcoin mining is also such an efficient market that in the long run, only the most efficient forms of energy--such as nuclear and geothermal--will be viable for it. Bitcoin is already helping to advance "green" energy. This is abundantly clear to people involved in the mining industry.
- 5y ago
- nova22033 5y agoAll I see is the price of real estate being driven up Who is doing the selling? "Wall St Fat cat Co" or the average Joe who saw his house value go up by a LOT?
- evan_ 5y agoWhen Conglomocorp sells one of their houses, they just get the cash and can realize profits. When average homeowner Joe sells their house they still have to live somewhere. They must immediately use that money for another house, which is also inflated. The higher sale price doesn’t matter. Average non-homeowner Joe trying to buy a first house is SOL.