6 ms·
Not really. Rail works great where it exists but there is still a pretty huge last mile problem so it generally gets transhipped onto trucks at some point.
by TylerE 5y ago
Not really. Rail works great where it exists but there is still a pretty huge last mile problem so it generally gets transhipped onto trucks at some point.
- WalterBright 5y agoLong haul trucking is grossly inefficient compared to rail. As for the last mile: 1. train rolls into freight yard 2. crane lifts container off of rail car 3. crane puts container onto last mile truck 4. truck drives last mile
- WalterBright 5y agoIt can be even simpler: 1. truck drives onto flat car 2. train goes long haul 3. truck drives off flat car 4. truck drives last mile
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThat ties up the truck for several days while it's being shipped across the country, though. That's a very unproductive use of the truck. It's overall more efficient to do it the way you said the first time.
- WalterBright 5y agoI know that. But it's a way to get started without needing expensive cranes and crane operators. It also works for intermediate low traffic dropoffs of freight. All you need is a platform level with the flatcar.
- PeterisP 5y ago> All you need is a platform level with the flatcar. Do you? You can't drive a truck sideways (from the side of a parked train); you can't drive a truck across multiple rail platforms (from the end of a parked train); and you can't efficiently split up the train in individual cars, bring them to a rail-end where they can be driven to/from and reconnect them, that would be much more expensive in terms of machinery (locomotive) and operator use than a crane; train cars can be reshuffled but it adds significant time and effort compared to just lifting a container from a truck onto a train, which is how it's usually done. You would also need specialty (longer) flatcars to fit not only the length of the container but the truck as well.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThere used to be TOFC (trailer on flat car) cars that had little flaps that you could lower so that you could drive between cars. They don't have those any more, for the most part. They found they could make them less heavy with a "spine" kind of design, which you can't drive across.
- TylerE 5y agoAlso most intermodals these days use well cars which allow containers to be double stacked. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e5/DTTX_724681_20050529_IL_Rochelle.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e5/DTTX_724...
- WalterBright 5y agoThink of it like parallel parking. Not much room is needed, and the flatcar + the gap between cars can be longer than the truck by just enough to make it work.
- rascul 5y ago> you can't drive a truck across multiple rail platforms (from the end of a parked train) This is how we loaded our vehicles onto train when I was in the US Army. Everything from small vehicles to large trucks. There were removable pieces connecting the cars so they could be driven over.
- burntwater 5y agoBeyond wasting the truck and wasting energy (fuel) transporting the weight of the truck, the height of the truck and trailer on top of the train car would likely exceed bridge and tunnel heights.
- bell-cot 5y ago1a. semi-skilled labor individually secures each and every truck to its flat car for safety. Figure 8+ hand-tightened heavy chains or freight straps per truck. 2a. if any mistakes were made during step 1a, then this train, flat car, and truck may enjoy 15 minutes of fame on the evening news. 2b. semi-skilled labor individually removes the heavy chains or freight straps from 1a, and stows them away. America's railroads looked very seriously at doing this, back in the day. The economics really didn't work out. There is a sorta-similar concept that's still used - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadrailer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadrailer
- smnrchrds 5y agoIf it's grossly inefficient compared to rail, does it mean it is grossly more expensive than rail + last mile truck? If yes, why does anyone still use it? If no, in what sense is it inefficient?
- WalterBright 5y agoTrucks drive on roads paid for by taxpayers and gas taxes paid by car drivers. Rail is paid for by the rail traffic. Hence the gross distortion of financial incentives. As for why it is inefficient: 1. one truck driver per load vs one train driver per 50 (or whatever) loads 2. one engine per load vs one engine per 50 loads 3. steel wheels are far more efficient than tires 4. no rubber dust pollution from steel wheels 5. truck damage to freeways is enormous, but is not paid by trucks. rail is built to handle heavy loads, and is much easier/cheaper to maintain 6. trains are far more fuel efficient per load than trucks
- dariusj18 5y agoTrucks pay "Heavy Vehicle Use Tax" or HVUT
- sudosysgen 5y agoThat's 100-550$. Peanuts compared to the actual cost.
- MertsA 5y agoTo elaborate on why this doesn't bridge the gap between heavy trucking road wear and all other traffic, road wear primarily comes down to environmental causes and impact loading. Wear from impact loading scales with IIRC roughly the 4th power of axle weight. The ruts you see in asphalt aren't from wearing through the surface, it's from slowly deforming it due to cyclic loading slowly shifting the subsurface and road surface on top. That basically doesn't happen with any vehicle that doesn't require a CDL. As a counterpoint the environmental wear is basically inevitable and in colder climates that's going to dominate the road work schedule anyways so it doesn't matter as much. Even with freeze thaw wrecking the road heavy loads still shorten the life of the road surface. Any way you slice it though, the current taxes and fees that heavy trucks pay do not come close to covering the share of maintenance work they're responsible for. Gas taxes effectively subsidize the trucking industry.
- 8note 5y agoLast mile from the port should all have destinations for the containers, so I'm not convinced that's the issue?