5 ms·
"copious leisure is right around the corner, if we can just muster the political will! But it doesn't work out like that. We still work a lot." This is worth t
by Animats 5y ago
"copious leisure is right around the corner, if we can just muster the political will! But it doesn't work out like that. We still work a lot."
This is worth thinking about. What do people actually do?
Well, this is what.[1]
- Farming is tiny. Under 1% of the labor force. In 1900, it was around 40%. (That's typical of most developed countries. Since the US is a net food exporter, that's not due to imports. Food preparation is 10x the size of farming. (Farmers complain that they capture only a small fraction of the value of food as eaten, but they're not doing more than a small fraction of the labor involved.)
- US manufacturing is around 5% of the labor force. Some of that is due to imports.
In Kropotkin's day, those two categories covered most of the workforce.
- Health care, broadly defined, consumes a sizable fraction of the labor force.
An interesting question to ask is how much other employment is not really necessary. How much is zero-sum activity?
- If advertising was no longer a tax-deductible business expense, there would be a lot less of it.
- If insurance was standardized (as it is for Medicare), the insurance industry could be far smaller.
- If finance faced a tax on financial transactions and was restricted to the product set of 1980, finance would be far smaller.
This would look a lot like China's policies today, or US policies of the 1950s.
[1] https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/emp-by-major-occupational-group.htm https://www.bls.gov/emp/tables/emp-by-major-occupational-gro...
- Scoundreller 5y ago> Farmers complain that they capture only a small fraction of the value of food as eaten They’re still not wrong. The difference between what they get paid for a potato and what I pay for a bag is quite extreme. I think it’s quite a bit different than say, gasoline vs barrel of oil, or iPhone at Bestbuy vs what Apple gets paid, or lower-end clothing. I get that potato is low value/lb, but I’m thinking the same applies as you go up the value/lb for raw things.
- nine_k 5y agoProduction is cheap because it's massive and economies of scale apply, but distribution is not because it works with every customer inevitably. Every customer in a supermarket needs to interact with a cashier. Also, transporting, washing, sorting, storing are all scalable but not free, and these are important parts of the easy availability for the end customer. Then, storage is not preserving 100% of produce, some of it inevitably withers or spoils, and handling this is also not free. Potatoes are only dirt cheap if you buy them in bulk on the farm, then store in your basement, and sort and handle yourself. This is a lot of work and time spent, I've seen such an approach firsthand.
- jessaustin 5y agoThe operations you cite aren't free, but they aren't the reason that costs of food for consumers dwarf payments made to farmers. Distribution is not a free market. Farmers sell to monopsony, and consumers buy from monopoly. Firms like Tyson, JBS, Cargill, etc. are not the immense size they are in order to create efficiency but rather to extract rents from abusive market positions.
- Retric 5y agoMany companies buy directly from farmers or actually own farms. This however isn’t a major cost savings. Those distributors are actually doing a lot of work relative to the effort needed to produce it at a farm. Consider even just someone driving a semi truck from Idaho to NYC takes over 30 hours of labor one way and roughly transports one acre worth of potatoes. That’s excluding loading, packaging, unloading, etc or any effort needed to actually sell to each customer.
- beaconstudios 5y agoOf course, none of this would be necessary without the idea that produce grown anywhere should be available everywhere. You don't need all that infrastructure if the potatoes you buy are from a farmer's market and were grown a few miles outside town.
- brokenkebab 5y agoIn 90s in my country it was a norm to buy potatoes directly from farmers. Many would find it funny that in richer places people pay more buying it washed, and sorted. However, as economical circumstances enhanced majority of urban dwellers started to pay more for washed, and sorted (and often imported, because you can't guarantee high quality of yield in any given year, at any given place) potatoes. You still can buy directly if you like, but nowadays it's mostly for students, and unsupported seniors. I don't know, maybe there's some sort of cartel conspiracy in US food trade, but consumers paying more for intermediary services is universal phenomenon. Likely after reaching some economical threshold, it becomes easier to spend for a bit of free time, and comfort.
- Jedd 5y ago> The difference between what they get paid for a potato and what I pay for a bag is quite extreme. Not only extreme, but also obscene. I recall in the late 90's someone described the poor profitability of potato growing in large tracts of the USA, and it sounded impossibly low - in the order of hundreds of dollars per acre. Sad but true -- while revenue per acre may be ~$2500, costs are ~$2000 [0] There's probably an on-topic observation to be made here about the past century or so spent driving subsistence farmers off arable land, monoculture, soil destruction, leading to an objectively unsustainable potato farming industry (in the sense of throwing more Joules into the working of the land, than you are getting out of it). [0] https://www.farmprogress.com/story-potatoes-profitable-risky-venture-9-149581 https://www.farmprogress.com/story-potatoes-profitable-risky...