27 ms·
I have had similar conversations with elementary school teachers and principals in Texas. All family members. I think it's the same story everywhere now. No on
by bob1029 5y ago
I have had similar conversations with elementary school teachers and principals in Texas. All family members.
I think it's the same story everywhere now. No one knows what to do to resolve it. Teachers no longer have sufficient means to provide an effective education to our children.
The school boards and layers of governance have all but stripped the actual educators of any autonomy that may have existed. Using decades of experience to deal with nuanced situations is not a thing that is allowed anymore. There is some strict procedure for everything, and if you deviate the administration will make your life hell.
The solution is probably a blend of: pay teachers more, give them more autonomy, banish smartphones in the classroom, more accountability for abjectly-shitty parenting and a reduction of our total obsession over standardization of outcomes.
If we could only fix one thing - Every teacher I talked to would rate the smartphone as the #1 reason for lack of engagement in the classroom. Even if they arent using it at school, being on tik tok with your friends at home until 3am every day has the same effective blast radius.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y ago<<banish smartphones in the classroom This, I think, is the most impossible thing listed. For the record, I agree with you, but I honestly can already see someone crying that they need to be able to reach their child 24/7.
- speedcoder 5y agoI taught H.S. for a year and setup banks of USB universal phone chargers at the back of the classroom. Students could charge their phone if they put on silent but could not get out of their seats without permission. It actually did help foster involvement in our lessons.
- mathattack 5y agoMy local schools have a no phone policy. It’s not that hard to implement.
- zdragnar 5y agoI was in school when mobile phones were just becoming accessible, and our school had a blanket ban on them. If they were out of your backpack or locker anywhere other than the lunchroom, it got taken away and you could pick it up at the end of the day from the principals office. It blows my mind that anyone could try to teach a room full of young kids without such a policy... what a daunting task.
- killtimeatwork 5y agoThey can get a dumb phone for the child then.
- syshum 5y ago>>No one knows what to do to resolve it. That is actually very easy, but hard politically Backpack funding of school choice. End the monopoly of government school districts determining how the money is spent. Let the market, and capitalism work its magic I am sure however most will disagree with this position
- mathattack 5y agoI am a big fan of charter schools, however it’s not quite this simple. Conceptually this is the right thing. (Parents tend to know which schools are best) There are lots of thorny implementation details. Moving to a system where schools can open and close quickly with kids not getting lost in the process is actually very difficult. As we see in Higher Ed, there can be a lot of abuse when the government acts solely as the payer or guarantor. I still agree with your central premise though.
- syshum 5y agoThe problems are not directly transferable though, Higher Ed there is no pricing controls at all since it is debt funded backed by government with almost unlimited amounts of funding, this is what has cases the explosion in costs You will not, and can not see that with local schools because the majority of them comes directly from local taxation which can not simply print more money to fund their largess like the federal government does. Local tax programs MUST be revenue neutral for the most part, baring limited issue bonds for specific things like building a new building This will limit the amount of backpack funding that would travel with the student. Personally I would not only want to open the backpack funding to charter schools but also allow parents to use that money for Home Schooling curriculum, programs, or creating School "Pods" like we saw during the schools closures where parents pool resources to hire tutors for their kids I think we need massive innovation in schooling, including things like Homeschooling, schooling pods, MOOC's, and charter schools
- bsder 5y ago> Backpack funding of school choice. End the monopoly of government school districts determining how the money is spent. Let the market, and capitalism work its magic The problem is that you need to define a minimum standard--look at the mess left behind by the coding bootcamps that weren't up to scratch. At which point you are back to the original issue. In addition, everybody magically thinks that their child won't be the one that charter schools will exclude. The vast majority of parents will be in for a very rude awakening. If your child causes any trouble, they will be punted from the school very quickly and good luck getting into the next one. A friend of mine put it best: "Having to manage just my own daughter's education through the lockdown was a nightmare. I can't imagine managing 30 students and their parents on a daily basis."
- bsder 5y ago> The solution is probably a blend of: pay teachers more, give them more autonomy, banish smartphones in the classroom, more accountability for abjectly-shitty parenting and a reduction of our total obsession over standardization of outcomes. We are where parents chose to be with respect to education. Nothing more, nothing less. Parents wanted accountability--so we have standardization of outcomes. Parents say they want autonomy and discipline--until you apply it to their child and then they sue you. Parents complain about taxes going to education--while teachers have to buy their own supplies (this particularly frosts me). We are where decades of parents chose to be through their collective actions. The fact that they don't like the consequences of their actions is simply typical of modern society.
- ErikVandeWater 5y agoParents aren't allowed school choice in most situations. This is on legislators banning students from getting an education outside their district, and banning or significantly hampering private education.
- bsder 5y agoPrivate schools and academies exist right now. The rich have no problem exiting the public school system no matter where they are. So, why is it that all parents aren't taking advantage of this? Oh, right, they can't pay for it. Parents magically think that something they already are unwilling to pay for will magically get cheaper the moment you bring the "free market" into the discussion. And, to be fair, that will be true for some students. If your child is abnormally big or abnormally smart, charter schools will accommodate them. If, however, your child has any behavioral issues--don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out. ADHD accommodation--bye, bye. Threaten to commit suicide or cutting behaviors--you're gone. Depressed and failing because your parents are divorcing--see ya. Got into a catfight over a boyfriend--yeah, that's on social media--you're out of here. If your child isn't perfect, they will get punted. And generally those parents screaming the loudest, funnily enough, have the children who cause the most issues. Everybody assumes their child won't be the one on the short end of the stick. Everybody will be in for a rude awakening.