4 ms·
> Biometric recognition in public spaces ... are to be prohibited by European law. That's ok but an exception for law enforcement and national security would b
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
> Biometric recognition in public spaces ... are to be prohibited by European law.
That's ok but an exception for law enforcement and national security would be useful.
This technology is a tool, like all technologies, and as such it may be used positively or negatively.
For instance, here in the UK we have automatic plate recognition cameras that are used to track uninsured or wanted cars. In the same spirit it might be useful to have similar cameras operated by the police to match people with a database of wanted or missing people (with only matches stored and reported for further investigation). Now this may not not work very well yet, there may be caveats and procedures to develop, etc but IMHO this means we should work on it and see if it can become useful rather than killing it off completely so early by having a blanket ban.
In any case, individual member states can draw their own laws on this.
On a side note, the wording in English might give the impression that the German government decides EU law...
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think the prevalence of CCTV in the UK warrants skepticism about its effectiveness as the UK doesn't necessarily have better crime numbers than comparable countries. I know video surveillance is mostly available in hot spots, but for me it is certainly uncomfortable to be under scrutiny constantly and it isn't something I would want to get used to as it does not provide significant benefits.
- gmueckl 5y agoExceptions for law enforcement have proven to be a very slippery slope in the past. Police is constantly trying to erode restrictions around tools that are only available for serious crimes and unfortunately also has a record of successfully circumventing any access checks for surveillance tools that have been put in place by lawmakers. There is constant and incessant lobbying from these circles to get more surveillance in place. But, when pressed, no one can point to cases where this actually helped. The only realistic way to counter this is to say no to surveillance technology from the start.
- raxxorrax 5y agoAdditionally we als have a dark security IT that makes good cash with dubious security solutions. Getting rid of that again will be difficult.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoI think that if the people see the government and especially the police as the enemy then society has a bigger problem than surveillance technology. Of course, there should be checks, controls, limitations placed upon those institutions, and transparency in their workings. But the police is here to protect and serve the community, at least it should be, not to oppress it. I've noticed that this is a difference in the way the police is often seen in Europe vs. in the UK for instance.
- mschuster91 5y ago> But the police is here to protect and serve the community, at least it should be, not to oppress it. The key question when the phrase "protect and serve the community" comes up is "which community?" and the answer is: it primarily serves the interest of the rich and powerful. If you are poor, not in the majority ethnic or in any other way not "mainstream", you have shit times ahead of you. No matter the country, the only difference between a cop in the US and a cop in the UK is better training and less reliance on guns. Homeless, being a person of color, being LGBT, protesting the government (especially from the left wing) - all common risk factors for adverse interactions with police. If you never have had a negative interaction with police, ask yourself why and prepare for an answer you likely would not have liked to hear.
- trasz 5y ago>the only difference between a cop in the US and a cop in the UK is better training and less reliance on guns Ah, so that’s why American cops routinely murder random people and go unpunished - it’s just the lack of training! (The reality is that there’s a fundamental difference in that in Europe police is just another government branch that’s helping people, like firefighters and doctors; normal people don’t need to fear them and avoid any unnecessary interactions, which seems to be the case in the US.)
- mschuster91 5y ago> That's ok but an exception for law enforcement and national security would be useful. Jesus hell no. Law enforcement already has too many permissions, and you can bet that there are more than enough people who would like the police to put iris scanners, gait monitors and other crap on each train station and public square. Minority Report and Little Brother should be warning enough, I feel no desire to see science fiction becoming reality. > but IMHO this means we should work on it and see if it can become useful rather than killing it off completely so early by having a blanket ban. We need a blanket ban because when you grant the government a single digit of your hand, tomorrow it has your whole arm in a vice. "War on terror!" "War on drugs!", "war on prostitution!", "protect our children from kidnapping!!!" - the list of stuff that people will bring up once the technology is in place is endless, and there are enough voters convinceable with fear mongering that the authoritarians will get what they want. > In any case, individual member states can draw their own laws on this. Blanket bans and mandatory requirements cannot be overridden, which is part of why many politicians from all EU countries choose the "Brussels backdoor" to pass shit they would get kicked out of office for at home, and when local voters rightfully complain, they just say "complain in Brussel, not my fault, we are just doing the whims of the EU". (Side note: this despicable behavior and complicit/ignorant media are a major reason for public trust in the EU eroding!) > On a side note, the wording in English might give the impression that the German government decides EU law... Let's be real: Germany, France, Italy and Spain are the dominant powers in the European Union. As long as only the Commission has the right to initiate the passing of laws, most initiatives will come out of these "big four" countries, and there will not be any initiatives where it isn't clear from the beginning that they have a high likelihood of passing.
- simiones 5y agoI would say that, on the contrary, police and secret services are the institutions it's most important to keep this out of the hands of. While private companies are using this data in ways that cause harm quite indirectly (influence, consumerism - societal evils to be sure, but no immediate threat to your life), police and the SS are most likely to cause very active harm with such technologies.
- shlurpy 5y agoA technology that is especially easy to use very negatively and relies on a constant maintenence of good moral virtue in government or law enforcement is a dangerously unstable risk. Its like how actively cooled nuclear reactors are just a technology, but its a far better idea to build them such that if power is lost even for a moment you don't experience a dangerous meltdown.
- raxxorrax 5y agoEspecially considering that you also have to look at the benefits. There still is no evidence that mass surveillance helped even in the most trivial cases. Crime numbers? Completely unaffected. I have no illusion that it is a mechanism to empower executive forces of course, but these invasive mechanism have to justify their existence. They have not done that to any degree at all.
- CRConrad 5y ago> On a side note, the wording in English might give the impression that the German government decides EU law... First, the text „lehnen wir ab“ can be read as “we won't accept”, in the sense that these legislators are against it. But legislators all over the world say stuff like that all the time, and in the end they often get overruled or outvoted anyway. Second, I think in a (negative) sense the German government does decide EU law — just like any other national government within the EU does: IIRC, in at least one of the (confusingly) many entities that decide on EU-wide legislation (Council? Commission? Ah, fuck knows...), all the national governments are represented with one vote each, and unanimity is required, i.e. they each have a veto.