4 ms·
Does the video explain what the slow money movement/beetcoin is? Because none of the text seems to.
by pavel_lishin 5y ago
Does the video explain what the slow money movement/beetcoin is? Because none of the text seems to.
- mooreds 5y agoThis is probably the best short explanation: https://slowmoney.org/about/principles https://slowmoney.org/about/principles There's a couple of books as well: https://slowmoney.org/publications https://slowmoney.org/publications
- tedunangst 5y agoThis explains nothing. It's meaningless drivel.
- mooreds 5y ago"What would the world be like if we invested 50% of our assets within 50 miles of where we live? What if there were a new generation of companies that gave away 50% of their profits? What if there were 50% more organic matter in our soil 50 years from now?" The goal is to relocalize economies (particularly food) through local investment.
- elil17 5y agoI think I have answers to all of these questions. 1. Worse. Geographic areas that already have a lot of wealth would receive a ton of investment, and poorer areas would struggle to access funds. 2. That'd be cool. Not sure how anything on the website addresses/encourages/works towards that. 3. We would need to use less commercial fertilizer, right? (This is meant somewhat sarcastically - I guess I just don't understand what these questions are actually meant to drive at, because taken at face value they seem sort of meaningless to me.)
- marmakoide 5y agoTL;DR your comment for 1. applies to 3. All organic matters are not all made equal. I have potassium in mind : mined potassium is essential to the high yields of industrial agriculture. You don't strictly need it and you can rely on locally sourced organic matters, but it'll never beat mining fertilizer and spraying it. Besides that, if your soil is poor to start with, you'll need to concentrate organic matter from a large area into a small spot that will become arable. For example, my ancestors were living in a swampy marsh, aka Aquitaine coast 150 years ago. They were raising large herds of sheeps feeding on low nutrients shrubbery. Then all those sheep's would rest on one specific plot, where they would eventually poop. On that plot, barley would be grown, as thanks to the sheeps poop, the ground was fertile enough. Compare that to area where the soil is very fertile (say, Ukraine or Moldavia)
- nine_k 5y ago1. Rich places would remain rich, poor places would remain poor, many far-away riches would stay untapped. Many dirty manufacturing plants would be closer to densely populated areas. Investing in geographically large things would become harder, with agriculture, forestry, and mining affected most severely. 2. Most companies would show very minimal or negative profits, as they already often do now. It's basically 50% tax on profits, only administered not by state but by the companies themselves. Some funds would be allocated better, some would be "given away" to various schemes funnelling the money back. 3. Maybe soils would be more fertile. Maybe the other way around: a bog is full of organic matter (drowned plants), but does not particularly teem with life. What saddens me is that these arguments are poetic, not rational, but are positioned as a down-to-earth program. Such things are a recipe for disaster as often as unbridled greed is.
- Supermancho 5y ago> This explains nothing. It's meaningless drivel. I second this. Leveraging the crypto trend with the term "Beetcoin". The whole site feels like a hippie inspired marketing scam. > This is probably the best short explanation: https://slowmoney.org/about/principles https://slowmoney.org/about/principles This is marketspeak. > There's a couple of books as well: https://slowmoney.org/publications https://slowmoney.org/publications Pointing to long-form high level abstracts is not an explanation. https://beetcoin.org/how-it-works https://beetcoin.org/how-it-works is a nightmarishly poor breakdown. Beetcoin (some organization) takes donations. The Slow Money Institute (some other organization) then makes grants to local 0% loan groups (some other groups, and local to who?) which matches Beetcoin-donations with donations from other individuals (more donations from where?) to match (or what, it doesn't get loaned out?). What capital is this double-donation loan against?
- mooreds 5y agohttps://beetcoin.org/movement https://beetcoin.org/movement (the original link, actually) has a list of the groups (you have to scroll down; the UX is, well, to say problematic is a bit generous). It's crowdfunding for local food producers with 0% loans. Another comment mentioned Kiva. It's similar.
- tata71 5y agoSo, kinda like FLOKI, but without: - centralized - liquidity - star power
- zz865 5y agoSeems like Kiva to give 0% loans but for US organic farmers.
- edibleEnergy 5y agohttps://beetcoin.org/how-it-works https://beetcoin.org/how-it-works
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoNot sure why this isn't upvoted higher. I thought the infographic on that page explained it pretty clearly, step-by-step.