4 ms·
It is where it will end up, and that's phoning home, online verification, and more. And intel already has parallel software running on intel systems, includin
by b112 5y ago
It is where it will end up, and that's phoning home, online verification, and more.
And intel already has parallel software running on intel systems, including access to the nic, which is impossible to shut off at the OS layer, so yeah.. they can do that.
(but outrageous, you say! and people will complain. naw. IME has been around forever, no one cares, it has had zero days, you cannot deactivate it, so a little phoning home and license authorization won't matter. This also means your cpu can expire because intel says so.... )
- qeternity 5y agoFine, I would agree with you on much of this. But those are different issues. And I don’t think a slippery slope argument applies as you note Intel has been pushing this stuff for a while. So from a purely price discrimination perspective, I think this is a good thing, even if Intel are doing a lot of other shady things in parallel.
- southerntofu 5y ago> So from a purely price discrimination perspective, I think this is a good thing This kind of setup never benefits users. It only allows corporations producing a product for <100$ to sell variations of it up to thousands of dollars. See also Canon cameras or nvidia graphics cards doing precisely that: locking/reducing features via software cuffs (and of course you can find cracked firmware to go around those, just makes it harder). Greed is a bad way to organize society: it has failed us as a species and threatens to destroy millions of other species along with it. We need to build a needs-based economy that is not dictated by private corporations.
- qeternity 5y ago> This kind of setup never benefits users. You’ll be hard pressed to find an economist that agrees with you. If Canon sold one camera, they would have to find the profit maximizing price and quantity. By definition this means that single product will have too many features and too expensive for some people, and have too few features for other people who would be willing to pay more. So instead they make multiple products with different functionality so that people can decide. I’m surprised to have to be defending greater consumer choice in HN?!?
- throwaway2048 5y agothis sort of "choice" is essentially entirely meaningless, if camera features were software unlock based they could sell all cameras with all features for the lowest price and still make money, the only one benefiting here is canon extracting maximum value.
- qeternity 5y agoMaking money is not binary. Companies will target the profit maximizing price. Price discrimination allows this to be solved for numerous segments. Let's say there are 10,000 people who want to buy cameras, a lot will pay $100 for bare bones, less will pay $200 for a few more features, and a few will pay $1,000 for all the features. If Canon makes one single camera, and let's say they charge the middle price of $200, then the largest market of low-end consumers are priced out the market, while the handful of high end buyers get a great deal. You might say "oh well just charge the $100 to everyone!". But Canon might actually make more money by charging more and selling to fewer people. They would be dumb not to do this. Price discrimination let's them target all these different price points.
- throwaway2048 5y agothat still has nothing to do with consumer choice, and is entirely about revenue maximization for canon. It is not somehow magically enabling a greater degree of choice.
- qeternity 5y ago> It is not somehow magically enabling a greater degree of choice. What are you talking about? There are 3 camera choices instead of 1.
- southerntofu 5y agoWould you consider it's more choice if a company started selling fruits where all vitamins have been removed? It used to be the same fruit, but the company altered it to make more profit: it's not benefiting the users in any way.
- gruez 5y ago>We need to build a needs-based economy that is not dictated by private corporations. what does that even mean? As bad as a "Greed" based economy might be, it does provide clear incentives for everyone to follow. How would a "needs-based" economy work?