8 ms·
Plunge in lithium-ion battery costs
- 1cvmask 5y agoAlso let's not forget Wright's law: https://twitter.com/skorusARK/status/1309225390494420996 https://twitter.com/skorusARK/status/1309225390494420996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24606382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24606382
- newyankee 5y agoI am personally a firm believer that a sub 100$/kwh retail price LFP battery with 10k cycle life will be a reality in < 10 years and change our relationship with energy. I wish there could be modular energy blocks that we can move around portably and charge/ discharge for different loads (not just EV)
- shiftpgdn 5y agoAllegedly Tesla is already at $130/kwh which part of the reason their margin is so high.
- jacquesm 5y agoI think so too but I also think that the groundbreaking research that will underpin that change is not going to be trumpeted in the press ahead of time but instead will quietly show up as incremental improvements to the current processes and materials. The venue for announcement will likely be the WIPO.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoI think this is less about ground breaking research and more about simply ramping up volume production to the point where the market isn't supply constrained anymore. With the EV industry basically growing as fast as batteries can be produced, that might take a while. But as that happens, cost will continue to improve for manufacturers and that should start reflecting out in unit prices. The important thing to realize is that production cost and product price are two things. In a supply constrained industry full of EV manufacturers desperate to buy any batteries at all, the profit margins are going to be insane for battery manufacturers for quite some time to come. So, we might not see lower prices until production volumes start meeting demand. That demand is for existing batteries at their existing prices. A better battery at a higher price would likely do equally well. However, new and improved batteries should drive the prices of the older ones down. So, we might end up with some commodity good enough batteries produced in very high volumes that will actually become affordable at some point.
- jacquesm 5y agoLet's hope that there will be a major effort to make batteries not only cheaper but cheaper to recycle. Right now we are treating ground up batteries as high grade ore rather than to be able to retrieve their component parts in relatively pure state from the battery itself. There are probably very good reasons for this but it strikes me that we may be going from one environmental problem into another. A few hundred kilos of chemical waste per vehicle is not a great prospect to look forward to.
- adrianN 5y agoHow much waste is left after the "high grade ore" is processed? I thought we were pretty good at extracting metals from stuff.
- jacquesm 5y agoAnywhere from 5 to 75% depending on who you believe. https://cen.acs.org/materials/energy-storage/time-serious-recycling-lithium/97/i28 https://cen.acs.org/materials/energy-storage/time-serious-re... Note that this is in flux, more recent articles may give different (hopefully higher) numbers.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoThere is plenty of investment going into recycling. Basically recycling lithium from spent batteries is vastly easier compared to refining it from naturally occurring deposit that only have tiny trace amounts of it when measured in parts per million. That's why lithium is so expensive. There's no shortage of it but refining it from naturally occurring deposits is a very energy intensive process due to the low concentrations of it even in some of the richer deposits. Recovering it from a batteries that actually contain many kilos of it is going to be not a hard cost equation for a wannabe recycler. In the unlikely case that somebody were to actually dump EV batteries in a landfill that would just create a nice business opportunity for other companies. Much better to sell batteries directly to such companies. But if you are genuinely worried about environmental impact, you should of course be very angry about anything ICE vehicle related where we convert fossil fuels into planet destroying quantities of CO2 without regard to how the oil is mined, how badly it destroys the environment or how many babies the exhaust fumes kill. Exaggerating a little here but just making the point here that there is a bit of double standards here. When it comes to ICE vehicles, nobody gives a shit where their oil comes, how many children were involved mining the Cobalt involved in removing the sulfur from their diesel/petrol (yes, that's a thing). But as soon as we talk EVs people suddenly get hyper critical about how resources are mined and used and where stuff comes from. It's more than a little hypocritical. Yes there are some challenges (and business opportunities) but it pales in comparison to the absolute dumpster fire that is the ICE vehicle industry and its apologists.
- beembeem 5y agoInteresting metric. I recently came across this team [1] in Seattle that is building what you mention. Disclaimer: after coming across the team I decided to invest in their equity crowdfunding effort. [1] https://joulecase.com/ https://joulecase.com/
- KaiserPro 5y agoI can see the charm, but they are more expensive per kwh than a powerwall. However the form factor is a definite winner, along with the stacking. I;m not sure about the integration into solar. But for what it is, a portable power block, its very nice. On a side note, I would love to see some weather proof alternative to a tesla powerwall. I dislike Tesla as a company, and it pains me to see that they only decent product out there being owned by them
- boringg 5y agoFascinating company. Not sure I see value proposition though for festival rentals replacing generating power as they aren't completely interchangeable products. Wish them luck though greening up the festival space.
- hinkley 5y agoAnker's isn't modular but they do have power devices that overlap with the lower end of their product line.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoTen years is long. I'm pretty sure that Tesla is already buying them below that price right now for their China operation. Retail prices are of course a different matter. This market is supply constrained so unless you are negotiating hard for large volume orders, it's pretty hard to buy battery cells directly. That indeed might take ten years to get fixed. Anyway, you can buy some Tesla power wall for your home at quite steep prices right now. Considering the difference in price for that and their actual cost, margins on those might be very lucrative for Tesla right now. They charge as much as 8500$ for a 13.5 KW powerwall. If they source the batteries for 100$ per kwh, that's a nice markup.
- rootusrootus 5y agoAt this point the cool kids on the DIY forums have worked out exactly how to build your own powerwall equivalent using LFP cells bought directly from China. It's enough of a savings to make it a worthwhile project.
- paulhart 5y agodo you have links for that?
- rootusrootus 5y agoMy personal favorite is DIY Solar Forum. I'm more into LFP batteries and solar for my RV than for my house, but here is a direct link to their DIY Powerwall subforum: https://diysolarforum.com/forums/diy-powerwalls.25/ https://diysolarforum.com/forums/diy-powerwalls.25/
- Baeocystin 5y agoAs cool as that sounds in a certain sense, I would be shocked (no pun intended) if doing so wouldn't void one's homeowner's insurance. There's no way in hell I would put so much concentrated energy in an amateur pack anywhere near a home.
- 5y ago
- hinkley 5y agoIt may be a while until the KWH/kg are high enough to make a removable auxiliary battery that is light enough for the average person to pick up. Right now it looks like Teslas are going about a 4.5 lbs per mile, which is quite heavy. A 30lb battery would barely be worth pulling off the highway to swap. A pair of them wouldn’t get you 15 miles and add a bunch of complexity to your design. In ten years when density has doubled we might be in a very different place. As the batteries get lighter the cars go farther on the same charge, so maybe we will hit an inflection point sooner than that.
- spfzero 5y agoFor cars, you would want to automate the swap anyway, so you'd presumably have handling equipment to swap and move batteries between the remove-recharge-store-install steps. I don't think you'd want to use humans in that application.
- cduzz 5y agoUntil the value of the battery is a tiny fraction of the vehicle, battery swapping will always be a risky proposition. I as the battery swap station will try to keep the good batteries and swap into someone else's vehicle the terrible batteries. Even if most stations are good actors, it won't take many to destroy the ecosystem by pushing marginal (or worse) batteries into customer vehicles. Nobody's going to blindly trust a swapping system where the swapped commodity is anywhere between very valuable and toxic waste.
- hinkley 5y agoI didn't spell it out in my top post but this is part of my concern as well. My primary battery is going to have to stay mine due to the market for lemons. A swappable spare battery feels like something I don't need to own. And my hunch is it should be more tactile versus automated, for that reason and because humans are good at manipulating non-standard objects, machines are not. Probably require less weather proofing too. But now you're limited by how much an average human can carry for fifteen, thirty feet. Propane tanks are 37 lbs new, and those are hard for many people to wrangle until they've burned off a few pounds of propane. 30 lbs, or maybe 15kg feels like a more workable number. But that's < 9 miles per 'cylinder'. I don't know what the threshold is for 'compelling' but I'm pretty damned sure it's a lot more than 8 miles. 25 miles for a pair might get someone's attention, but that's a few years out. Or an automated replacement process, which still has other issues we haven't addressed in this thread.
- turtlebits 5y agoPrice is already there. I bought ~89$/kwh LFP batteries last year (shipping brought them over ~$100/kwh though). Some LFP batteries already have a 5000+ cycle count, I'd expect way less than a 10 year outlook.
- newyankee 5y agoI read about such prices in articles about EVs but have never seen them in practice in a completely assembled pack.
- topspin 5y ago> LFP I'm so thankful to see that acronym supplanting LifePO4.
- intrasight 5y agoI too believe that modular energy blocks are key to price and technology competition. But tech vendors really don't like competition, so I doubt that this will be a reality unless forced by regulators. Regular batteries began to be standardized in 1928 by American Standards Association (predecessor to ANSI) - according to Wikipedia. We can buy standard batteries in a variety of sizes. I envision a "modular energy block" as something much bigger than these "C" and "D" batteries. But small enough to still be picked up. Perhaps 40 lbs.
- aldonius 5y agoSo... normal car battery size?
- intrasight 5y agoUsing Lithium-Ion and adding electronics to make it "modular" - I think it would closer to a cubic foot.
- Animats 5y agosub 100$/kwh retail price LFP battery with 10k cycle life will be a reality in < 10 years Look on Alibaba. You can buy that right now.
- SECProto 5y agoI would note that they were specifically talking about "retail price". Alibaba, where (based on experience) you have little recourse with refunds and accountability if the product isn't as described, is not a retail outlet.
- belval 5y agoYou might already know this but anything labelled as grade A cells on Alibaba is a scam pure and simple (especially at 100$/kwh). You will get a grade B (used) cell with a somewhat diminished capacity that won't hold for 10k cycles. To be clear those are usually still great value, but it's worth nothing because people are generally unaware and don't understand that discrepancy between Alibaba prices and what you'd get from a supplier in the US.
- gataca 5y agolink to the primary article: https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2021/ee/d1ee01313k https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2021/ee/d1ee0...
- everybodyknows 5y agoProfound work. Sad to see the MIT PR hacks polluting it with a chartjunk headline image -- spurious shadow of the data line, no tick marks on scales, Y-axis values begging for a log scale but not getting it, superimposed photo of a metal box labeled "Battery". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartjunk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chartjunk
- gowld 5y agoIt's an illustrative decoration that communicates the key idea. None of the "chartjunk" (of which there is very little) matters as much as the likelihood that it's fake data.
- jacobolus 5y agoMight be better to link directly to the paper (which this press release does not bother to do): https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlehtml/2021/ee/d0ee02681f https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlehtml/2021/ee/d0ee0268... Here is their better chart: https://pubs.rsc.org/image/article/2021/EE/d0ee02681f/d0ee02681f-f1_hi-res.gif https://pubs.rsc.org/image/article/2021/EE/d0ee02681f/d0ee02... Looks to me like price decreases are substantially slowing on a log scale.
- spfzero 5y agoThank you for this. Reading the OP article, I kept wondering when they would get to the numbers. Then it ended.
- kurthr 5y agoYes, their forecasts for $75 & $20/kWh (e.g. 2027) seem highly optimistic. The rate of decrease for small cells have declined precipitously. Based on the last 10 years of improvement, I'd expect something like $100/kWh in 2030. However, this doesn't include LiFePO where a lot of manufacturing focus has turned in the last few years. Car maker and fixed battery install are driving demand and lower costs. Looking at $100/kWh next year. and $50 in 2030. https://climatebiz.com/lifepo4-battery/ https://climatebiz.com/lifepo4-battery/
- 5y ago
- mjh2539 5y agoHow much of this reduction in cost is due to improvements in the underlying technology (as opposed to a reduction in cost due to increasing the scale of production)?
- SubiculumCode 5y agoits a good question, although I wonder whether the original tfa covered it already. In any case I suspect that cost reductions due to scaled production may be easier to model than technological advancements, so its probably the latter which caused projections to be exceeded.
- tiahura 5y agoAnyone who’s followed the price of a 12v 100ah battery on Amazon has seen the plunge over the last year. $900 -> $400.
- MayeulC 5y agoI wonder if some of this is due to covid-driven inflation, possibly in china or other countries?
- missedthecue 5y agoCovid driven inflation reduced the cost of a battery by $500?
- MayeulC 5y ago> by $500 First, that would be $300, or a 33% reduction. Let me explain the reasoning. If batteries are manufactured abroad and that foreign currency experiences sudden inflation, exchange rates for the local currency would make them quite a bit cheaper, especially in a volatile market if sellers are "desperate" to get some (perceived) more stable currency. I wonder what kind of items that effect would be visible on first, and if that can be used as a tool to look at the market. Now, this would be combined with regular year-on-year advances in battery tech and price reduction. But if the yearly price drop was higher than usual, I was offering a possible explanation.
- rootusrootus 5y agoPrices would have dropped faster without covid. Shipping is really problematic on LFP cells direct from China right now. Combined with the surge in RV purchases, prices are not going to drop much further this year. But in a couple more years when things have smoothed back out, it's going to be great.
- MayeulC 5y agoThank you, I can picture current shipping difficulties. Although, wouldn't that mostly affect big orders and/or guaranteed delivery? Customers on the average Chinese export marketplace are used to long delays (shipping > 1-2 months).
- shoto_io 5y agoSide note: this is from March 2021.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoOne of the interesting things about battery production cost is that it is very much tied to the price of energy and the cost of the raw materials. Both battery production and sourcing of the raw materials are energy intensive processes. E.g. refining lithium from either ore or brine, basically involves a long process of evaporating water, concentrating usable quantities, pumping stuff around, etc. So, you could simplify the statement above to the whole process being essentially about energy cost. It also uses water in large quantities and producing and cleaning that boils down to yet more energy intensive processes. So, as energy gets cheaper, the whole production process gets cheaper. A lot of automotive companies are announcing plans to move their production processes to be carbon neutral. That includes using clean energy for battery production. For many manufacturers that means sourcing their own energy and turning that into a fixed cost rather than a variable cost. As it is such a big component of their overall cost, you can bet they'll work hard to lower that. And as they do, everything energy intensive they do, benefits. Of course another way batteries can get cheaper is by improving the production process to e.g. require less rare earth materials (e.g. Kobalt), using less water, etc. That too is going to happen. But bringing energy cost down is already big deal. Long term alternative battery chemistry, improved production processes, cheaper energy, all work together to bring cost down further. The question is not if but when. The key metrics here are simply $/kwh. That used to be quite high; it's now around 100$. What happens when it hits 50$ or 25$? How long will it take to get there? These are interesting questions considering that the battery is by far the most expensive component in an electrical car. Also interesting for ICE car manufacturers still hoping to keep on producing ICE cars for another decade or so. Having a lot of cheap EVs to compete with is not going to be good for them.
- shiftpgdn 5y agoA correction for you: The element is cobalt, Kobalt is a brand of tools they sell at Lowes home improvement stores. Also I believe most modern lithium battery chemistries omit cobalt due to cost and supply chain issues.
- leecb 5y ago> The element is cobalt, Kobalt is a brand of tools Kobalt is the name of the element in German; @jillesvangurp's profile says he is based in Berlin, perhaps he also speaks German. (German also capitalizes nouns.)
- mmazing 5y agoI remember a few years ago reading an article about a breakthrough in Lithium Metal batteries, as opposed to Lithium Ion. Supposedly have 2x the power density at half the size, and don't burst into flames when punctured. Anyone else remember that? I want those batteries. Apparently the main issue is that they don't last as long as Li-Ion.
- rootusrootus 5y agoThe big competitors to lithium ion right now are LFP (lithium iron phosphate) and LTO (lithium titanate oxide). Neither have quite the power density of current lithium ion cells, but they're not that far off. LFP is quite popular right now for home storage and RVs. It is not nearly as prone to fire as lithium ion. LTO is even safer yet, it usually doesn't even pop the case if you abuse it to the point of destruction. LFP is improving density so it may be viable soon for EVs (in the US; in China they already use LFP), which manufacturers would love. Making the news for fires is really undesirable.
- Baeocystin 5y agoLFP have been popular as drop-in replacements for 12V batteries in motorcycles for years now, too, FWIW. Their cell voltage and resistance to charging damage make them excellent replacements. Their only real deficit is in the cold.
- mmazing 5y agoI might be wrong but it looks like neither of those are classified as a Lithium Metal Battery and are still a form of Lithium Ion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_metal_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_metal_battery vs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_iron_phosphate_battery and here's an article about using pure lithium metal as the anode https://arstechnica.com/cars/2021/11/lithium-metal-hybrid-battery-promises-lighter-longer-range-evs-by-2025/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2021/11/lithium-metal-hybrid-ba... You seem to be well informed, is this just hype?
- RandomWorker 5y agoReal numbers are lacking in this article. It’s way more interesting to talk about real dollar numbers. We are looking at $100/kWh. While most projections by NREL said it would be bottoming out around 200 in 2021. Having a 50% drop compared to projects is insane. At $100/kWh battery connected solar panel power plants become very lucrative.
- cwkoss 5y agoAre lithium batteries becoming cheaper than lead batteries? I was under the impression that lead was the leader for fixed installations (like solar) because weight isn't much of an issue if it doesn't have to move. Is there a different reason why lithium is preferable to lead for these sorts of applications?
- magicalhippo 5y ago> Is there a different reason why lithium is preferable to lead for these sorts of applications? AFAIK lead-acid batteries have a number of downsides compared to LiFePO4. They're heavy, they require a ventilated area due to hydrogen gas production, they don't last nearly as long (fewer charge/discharge cycles) and they have significantly lower effective capacity at higher discharge rates. At this point the main benefit seems to be upfront cost. https://www.victronenergy.com/blog/2015/03/30/batteries-lithium-ion-vs-agm/ https://www.victronenergy.com/blog/2015/03/30/batteries-lith... https://relionbattery.com/blog/agm-vs-lithium-batteries-which-are-better-for-solar-rv-and-camper-van-battery-banks https://relionbattery.com/blog/agm-vs-lithium-batteries-whic...
- belval 5y agoLead for fixed installation was a general rule a few years back but it's not really advantageous anymore. There were several concerns with lithium (especially price, availability and safety) that are now addressed making it much more interesting. For example a powerwall built with LiFePO4 cells will be good for at least 10000 cycles (+15 years) and afterwards the degradation curve is much nicer than lead-acid so you can easily get 25 years if you can cope with some reduction in capacity. It also has no risk of thermal runoff (so it won't start a fire is a cell has a catastrophic failure) which is much better than traditional cobalt or manganese batteries. You can get grade A cells for about ~400$/kWh today when buying only one and obviously bulk discounts are widely available if you are getting something bigger. It still burns if your house catches fire though so that's still a concern.
- throwaway81523 5y agoFYI: This is from March 2021 (old news) and is about the large multi-decade decline that anyone following the topic is already well aware of. There are no recent (i.e. this year) developments reported in the article.
- powera 5y agoWhat would it take to start a factory in the United States making lithium-ion batteries to sell to consumers (for a PowerWall-like usage)?
- jokoon 5y agoSorry but anything related to energy that has a climate impact should not be measured in dollars, but in co2 equivalent. Good luck doing a CO2 summary of lithium batteries from start to finish when you look at the whole chain and lifetime. Not to mention lithium mines are those weird big artificial blue lakes which I really don't understand how they really work. Pretty weird there are no documentary on them. Even mining Uranium does have a CO2 cost you can hardly avoid.
- belval 5y agoIt's not directly covered in the article but LiFePO4 which are the new popular cells for most things don't require manganese or cobalt so they are much cleaner than older lithium cells. So I can't directly answer your question, but there is no doubt that CO2 production for lithium cell manufacturing is much lower now than it was in 1990 and it should keep dropping as car manufacturer flip to LiFePO4.
- rossdavidh 5y ago"anything related to energy that has a climate impact should not be measured in dollars, but in co2 equivalent..." It depends on what you're trying to do with the data. If you're trying to estimate the economic competitiveness, then $ is absolutely the metric more likely to in fact be a predictor of that. For example, will renewables continue to get market share, or is that in danger of being held back by battery cost? If battery cost is falling exponentially, we're in good shape. If battery cost is _not_ falling exponentially, then it could be that we need to explore alternative ways to store the energy. Whether or not $ _should_ be the driving factor, the reality is that it _is_ the better predictor of market uptake.
- jokoon 5y agoso if coal is cheaper than renewables, does it matter? why are you not measuring the co2 emissions of coal? makes no sense at all.
- peter303 5y agoEV trucks are just coming on the market this year. They require at least 100 kwh to exceed 200 mile range. The leading models have 135 kwh. At $300 a kwh an EV truck was too expensive, but not $100 kwh.
- devy 5y agoNot trying to be snarky here, but wasn't this Elon Musk's entire thesis on Tesla's success by bringing the massive produced EV (aka Model 3) affordable and all-around better than conventional ICEs? https://futurism.com/analyst-questions-elon-musks-10-year-ev-prediction-is-it-achievable https://futurism.com/analyst-questions-elon-musks-10-year-ev... This article was dated in 2017 but I am pretty sure Musk mentioned "economy of scale" will bring down the cost of lithium batteries which in turn make the massively produced EVs like Model 3 more affordable. https://www.tesla.com/blog/secret-tesla-motors-master-plan-just-between-you-and-me https://www.tesla.com/blog/secret-tesla-motors-master-plan-j... Dated 2006 (not directly mentioning of cost of Lithium batteries though).