6 ms·
Since POWER9 and OpenSPARC are open architectures with open ISAs, I don't see why companies like Facebook, Amazon, Alibaba aren't using them and trying instead
by DeathArrow 5y ago
Since POWER9 and OpenSPARC are open architectures with open ISAs, I don't see why companies like Facebook, Amazon, Alibaba aren't using them and trying instead to build CPUs based on ARM. Is there a much better performance/power ration which can be achieved by ARM and not by POWER or SPARC?
- PedroBatista 5y agoWith ARM you have a World of resources, with POWER or SPARC you have 2 abandoned platforms. There’s a reason they are “open” now and nobody wants to hold that bag.
- broodbucket 5y agoPOWER definitely isn't abandoned lol, POWER10 shipped last month.
- PedroBatista 5y agoThen SPARC isn't abandoned either, but I think you know what I meant compared to ARM.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoEr, when did SPARC last have a new version?
- PedroBatista 5y ago2017 or 2018 I think, but Fujitsu was going to release a new version this year.
- hulitu 5y agoWith ARM you have a world of blobs.
- fomine3 5y agoWe can't buy Cortex/Neoverse equivalent modern core design on POWER/SPARC
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- spullara 5y agoYes. Otherwise people would be using them.
- ggrrhh_ta 5y agoAre you saying that you get better performance vs. power with ARMs than with POWERs?
- rbanffy 5y agoI would be sure you would for any off-the-shelf open designs. POWER9 and POWER10 are power-hungry (no pun intended) but are very powerful (I will neither confirm nor deny wether a pun was intended here), more than any ARM server option.
- volta83 5y agoHow many smartphones using POWERs do you know? Or IoT devices? Or... Or...
- donatzsky 5y agoWould it even be possible to fit a POWER CPU in a smartphone?
- classichasclass 5y agoFor "big POWER" like POWER8/9/10, they are clearly not positioned at that market. However, there are small Power ISA chips for embedded systems and companies like NXP still make them (the Amiga community even tries to shoehorn these into desktop systems, to their detriment, IMHO), and IBM has done "little POWER" versions of big POWER chips (the G5 being a scaled-down POWER4 with AltiVec, for example).
- MisterTea 5y ago> (the Amiga community even tries to shoehorn these into desktop systems, to their detriment, IMHO) What detriment would that be?
- pjc50 5y agoThe instruction set is not as critical as you might think, and ARM has the huge advantage of a lot of working implementations which you can already buy. Semiconductor design teams don't exactly grow on trees, either. It was over a decade from Apple buying PA Semi whole (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P.A._Semi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P.A._Semi ) to announcing the M1. And of course if you're going to do that you already need the rest of the vertically integrated pipeline to build motherboards to put your chips on, peripheral IP to do all the other things other than processing, etc.
- Someone 5y agoARM also has lots of sometimes hand-optimized software that may not be available or as good as for those other platforms. I haven’t checked, but I don’t expect Power to have good USB support, for example. I also think Power targets a different performance range than ARM. Reading https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenSPARC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenSPARC and https://www.oracle.com/servers/technologies/opensparc-overview.html https://www.oracle.com/servers/technologies/opensparc-overvi..., both of which mention no news after 2008, OpenSPARC looks on its deathbed to me.
- pjc50 5y agoQuite. I can't think of any reason other than retrocomputing that someone would want an OpenSPARC. I think people forget that the economies are different with hardware vs software; because you cannot eradicate the per-unit cost of hardware, paying a small part of that in license fees is not a big deal, especially since it comes with integration support that saves you a lot of non-recurring R&D expense. Whereas in software, being free makes it zero-friction and this has a huge impact on adoption.
- classichasclass 5y agoI would think USB would be more of a OS issue, though. If a USB driver came as a blob, my Talos II obviously couldn't run it, but otherwise pretty much all USB stuff just works if I have source code for it (Fedora). Page size can ruin your day for some devices -- I have to hack FireWire, for example, because it assumes a 4K page size and Fedora uses 64K pages -- but so far no issues with USB or AMD GPUs. Optimization is a bigger issue, though autovectorization in compilers is making it less of a problem than it used to be, as well as us nerd pioneers getting things upstreamed.
- rakoo 5y agoI know they design their parts, but do they actually assemble them ? If not, how many fabs can build ARM boards compared to POWER or SPARC boards ? Is the performance/power ratio so important compared to the price of being tied to fewer companies ?
- stjohnswarts 5y agoDo you mean boards or chips? "Fabs" as typically referenced in the industry refers to wafer fabs.
- volta83 5y agoAn ISA is like a platform. It is valuable only if it has many users, e.g., application code, optimized for the ISA. HW's job is to then run that code with good perf/cost. OpenPOWER has little software. ARM has a lot of software. So from that POV, ARM is already many orders of magnitude more valuable than OpenPOWER. But it doesn't end there. Do you need some software to be extremely optimized for ARM? ARM can do this for you at resonable price, no need to hire. Also, for OpenPOWER, you need to hire 50-100 Facebook engineers, at 400k$/year, and it'll take them >3 years to produce a chip design, which then needs to be verified, etc. and then needs to be built, so you'll need a fab, specialized on OpenPOWER, or not. A fab churns 40k chips/month, so how many chips / month do these companies need ? With ARM, you pick one of the many ARM farms, and there is little for you to do. And you get 5 engineers, and they just customize an ARM design to your needs. And they ship in 1 year instead of 3. And next year ARM gives you a way to update your chip to the next generation. And if next year you need some other feature, ARM gives it to you. And if you need software, like C library, profilers, math, all that is supplied by Arm. And they take royalties on chips you built, and.... and.... So ARM is many orders of magnitude cheaper in perf / $ than OpenPower. Not only is the hardware better, but it is better, cheaper, has more software, and tools, and teams of experts ready to help your team, etc.
- api 5y agoIs ISA lock-in really an issue today? Porting most software to ARM64, Power, or RISC-V involves typing some variation of "make." Only a small percentage of software written in C/C++ or ASM is problematic. Anything in a higher level language like Go or a newer language like Rust is generally 100% portable. Switching from X86_64 to ARM64 (M1) for my desktop dev system was trivial. Endian-ness used to bite, but today virtually everything is little-endian above embedded. Power and some ARM support both modes but almost always run in little-endian mode (e.g. ppc64le).
- enedil 5y agoEndianess is not the only problem. You can have issues with different cache coherency model, different alignment requirements, different syscalls (which are partially arch-dependent, at least on Linux). The fact that the switch from x86 to arm was trivial just proves the point that arm has matured really well.
- donatzsky 5y agoAs others have already said, ARM has the economy of scale which POWER doesn't have. And SPARC seems to be dead. Also, ARM has always (?) been about getting the most out of limited resources, whereas POWER is about performance at any cost. With modern ARM designs, the performance is getting close to, and even exceeding, that of traditional desktop and server CPUs, while still being frugal with resources. POWER is still, well, power-hungry.
- Twirrim 5y agoAgreed. Power frugality is absolutely crucial, especially at larger, enterprise scale. Unless you're in HPC, you're looking for a good balance of peak performance-per-watt and the lowest idle consumption, with a very good scaling down story. ARM has long done a better job of this than x86. It's one of the main reasons the chipset has been absolutely dominant in the smartphone market. The biggest single cost for AWS etc. is per-rack running costs, encompassing power, cooling etc. It's hard to overemphasise just how much this dwarfs all other costs. To optimise those costs you've got to cut down the power consumption and associated heat production.
- ksec 5y agoOne could also ask why people are using / pushing Rust and RISC-V over Ada and OpenPOWER. The latter are simply not cool, gets nothing on their Resume Driven Development. And no companies wants to bet on it because without other company sharing some cost of ecosystem no one can sustain it by themselves. ( That is why we need marketing ) And finally, what benefits does POWER and SPARC brings to the table? The licensing cost from ARM is tiny in the grand scheme of things. I like open ISAs like POWER and OpenSPARC, but from a business POV it just doesn't make any sense.
- gnufx 5y ago> what benefits does POWER and SPARC brings to the table Radiation hardened implementations, e.g. spacecraft, is one niche, though I don't know whether that has anything particular to do with the ISA.
- ksec 5y agoRadiation hardening are mostly done with mature old node with less error rate and packaging. There are additional compute to check if results are correct ( I remember it was n+2 ? ). So nothing to do with ISA itself ( at least as far as I know ).