16 ms·
Intel Software Defined Silicon: additional CPU features after license activation
- castratikron 5y agoIntel Upgrade Service? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Upgrade_Service https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Upgrade_Service
- zinekeller 5y agoThis was what I've thought, until I've realised that SDS is for enterprise (aka Xeon) processors.
- johndoe0815 5y agoCalling this "Software Defined Silicon" instead of what it is - rent-seeking - is audacious...
- toast0 5y agoIt's hard to have this discussion until we know what the features are. If it's hardware that implements a (non intel) patent and you have to pay to use it, but not everyone would want the feature, seems reasonable to let those who want it pay for it. Like MPEG-2 support on (early?) raspberry pis. If it's something frivalous, it's frivalous.
- mlyle 5y agoA main use is probably core count. AKA sell parts for a lower cost with a low core count, and when people need more performance, let them turn the additional cores on. IBM has had this model on the mainframe for quite some time. Intel gets the benefits of fewer valuable physical SKUs to manage inventory of at distributors... and of very high margin revenue later.
- fomine3 5y agoIIRC Intel did almost same thing at around 2011.
- toast0 5y agoI mean... that feels scummy, but on the other hand, when they've got a mask that has N cores and the yield is good, they fuse off working cores to get the lower core SKUs the market wants. There may be many customers that the IBM model works for. It used to be you could do some fiddling around and get disabled cores undisabled to see if they were disabled for good reasons or not...
- thayne 5y agoPrice discrimination would also be an apt description.
- kristjansson 5y agoIntel can make parts to fit a SKU by (a) sorting them based on what elements are working when they come off the proverbial press, (b) physically disabling working elements, or (c) disabling working elements in software with the option to re-enable them. I totally understand the argument that (c) is more objectionable since the chip you buy is prevented from using all the elements it left the factory with. However I think it really shouldn't feel different than (b)? The only difference between getting 8 core part with 8 more cores burned out on its way out the door and an 8 core part with 8 more cores disabled in microcode is that you can double the core count of the latter in place for a price that's presumably proportional to the price difference between the 8c and 16c SKU? Of course there's a slippery slope to a hardware-as-a-service pay-us-x-per-unit-time-or-we-turn-off-your-CPU, but with competition from AMD on x86 and in-house ARM chips from Apple and hyper-scalers, one would think Intel wouldn't want to make their product even _less_ attractive.
- tehjoker 5y agoI think the issue is that the economy is supposed to in theory serve people, which most people would think means that if there is no material difference in effort to produce a part, the best most useful technology should be produced and in consumers hands. The theory of market competition says that moves like this should be impossible because it would open Intel up to being undercut by a competitor nearly instantly. However, we can see that monopoly capitalism does not function the way the legitimizing theory does. In fact, it is populated with rent seekers that manipulate the public using market segmentation strategies to profit.
- vlovich123 5y agoPrice discrimination happens all the time even when there's no material difference in providing the good/service (e.g. Uber surge pricing).
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoAt least surge pricing makes sense - when there are more fares than drivers, the fares have to pay more to be picked up first. With CPUs, it's less intuitive - The people with DRM-hamstrung CPUs are supposed to be getting a cheaper price subsidized by the people buying the product at full price. The cheaper models otherwise would have to be sold at the full price. That's not to say that Intel's prices are necessarily fair at any tier...
- milderworkacc 5y agoAs a sibling comment notes, Intel can (and has a history) of doing this physically. Where a manufacturer price discriminates by offering two products, a normal one and an inferior one, it may be the case that the cheapest way to do that is by simply making twice as many “good” ones and intentionally disabling half of them. There is a very famous economics paper by Deneckere and McAfee that outlines exactly this behaviour from Intel in the 386 (…?) days, and how it may even lead to Pareto improvement - and increased consumer welfare. I can’t find it at the moment on mobile, but it should be relatively easily surfaced. Edit: found it, “Damaged Goods” - https://www2.econ.iastate.edu/faculty/langinier/teaching2005/615-fall2005/paper-hom2/damagegoods.pdf https://www2.econ.iastate.edu/faculty/langinier/teaching2005...
- akira2501 5y agoI thought the normal and inferior products lines are usually the result of binning, not of intentional production. In which case, it's a way to make good on products that would not normally sell under your brand and would otherwise be disposed of. If your manufacturing efficiency has advanced to the point that you no longer have low quality parts coming out of your binning process, then I think customers are right to wonder why that savings and efficiency aren't being passed on or being used to further advance the product line. In any case, if the purpose of passing the inferior products off under an alternative label is to avoid brand damage, then this seems to be the opposite of that.
- milderworkacc 5y agoIn many cases yes, it is the result of binning, but the 486 SX (my first comment incorrectly said 386) was an intentionally disabled 486 DX. From memory, you could then purchase a 487, which was actually just a full-fat 486 DX to slot into your co-processor slot as an 'upgrade'!
- toast0 5y agoMy understanding is that binning is typical at the beginning of the product line, but usually process tweaks increase the yield as the product continues. At which point things become complex. If you no longer have N core chips because all of them test good at more cores, but don't want to sell the N+1 core chips at the old N core price, you've raised prices with all that entails.
- oceanghost 5y agoIt's actually, "functional pricing."
- systemvoltage 5y agoWait until you realize that the entire SaaS industry and the subscription model is based on that same concept you're alluding to. I can understand service (say a barber) that needs to have a subscription model. But, most products today such as Adobe Photoshop should just be a one-time fee. Yet, we have come to accept that everything is $/month. You own nothing. The most eggregious of these is browser-based apps. You have zero control over upgrades and whether you want features or not. With a desktop app, atleast you can ignore updates.
- wayoutthere 5y agoIn practice Adobe Photoshop was effectively a subscription long before the pivot to SaaS. If you used it professionally, the old versions couldn’t open files from the new versions, so if you were part of a creative pipeline that you didn’t fully control, you got pushed into upgrading within a few months every time a new version came out. The switch to SaaS didn’t really end up costing it’s pro users much more since they were spending $600 every 2-3 years on it anyway. But I suspect it did convert at least some of the people who pirated a copy from work into paying customers.
- systemvoltage 5y agoYeah, SolidWorks also does this. If you get a file from a later version from a customer, you cannot open it on the older system even if it is just a year old. Entire machine shops get sucked into this - they already run on thin margins and it is probably one of the most expensive aspects of running a shop.
- kristjansson 5y agoThis is where the JetBrains pricing model is exactly right. If they sold licenses, people would upgrade every few years, after some needling^W marketing. Instead, they sell as a subscription with the option to cancel and keep only the features available as of your last renewal. So someone that would upgrade every release pays about the same average cost and gets a more continuous flow of new features, someone that would buy once can just buy once, and everyone gets the optionality to stop paying and 'keep' what they've already paid for.
- gumby 5y agoIBM was famously past master at this: they’d increase your clock rate temporarily, at a price.
- kristjansson 5y agoThey still offer stuff like this in the mainframe machines, right? I recall that their z machines have full duplicate processor drawers idle and locked out so that if one dies, IBM can remotely activate the idle one to maintain service?
- mschuster91 5y agoWhy? It's the exact same thing as binning, only that now the binning is done in software.
- baq 5y agofree market at work
- qeternity 5y agoHow exactly is this rent seeking?
- hkt 5y agoI for one will have no compunction about: a) abandoning CPU vendors that do this, forever if needs be b) pirating features in my CPU
- baq 5y agosorry to break the news for you, but...
- magicalhippo 5y agoOur customers all get the same executable file. Yet if they've paid for it, they get more features as the license will unlock modules. The code is all there for everyone, compiled and ready in case the customer decides to upgrade their license. Is what we're doing "rent-seeking" as well? Of course we could make differentiated builds, just add in a bunch of ifdefs and provide a new executable to the user when they upgrade their license. Would that be any different? The result would be the same, the user would still pay more to get access to the additional functionality.
- microtonal 5y agoThe cost of copying your executable is near-zero. The cost of producing a CPU die is non-zero. Suppose that ECC support takes a certain die area, then either everyone is already paying for it while buying the CPU or everyone who licenses the feature is paying for the silicon for everyone who doesn't enable it. So, if you are licensing a CPU feature, you may be paying twice for it. Of course, whether you actually do so, depends on the relative cost of producing that area of the die vs. the development cost of that functionality. Another issue is that this probably would not happen in a healthy, competitive market. In fact, the opposite would happen, CPU vendors would try to provide more features at a price point in order to compete (which is probably why AMD does support ECC on many Ryzen SKUs, as an underdog AMD still has to compete). However, if you need a x86_64 machine, you only have two options. Or if you are unlucky and required to purchase from a large vendor like Dell, you may only have one option.
- magicalhippo 5y ago> The cost of producing a CPU die is non-zero. While strictly true, the actual die is a relatively tiny cost when producing a CPU. The majority of the cost is the upfront cost of designing the masks. Once you have those, using this or that mask doesn't make a huge difference. > Suppose that ECC support takes a certain die area, then either everyone is already paying for it while buying the CPU or everyone who licenses the feature is paying for the silicon for everyone who doesn't enable it. As mentioned the majority of the cost of the ECC support is in the R&D, not the physical manufacturing. As such, moving this to a software level can be a win-win for both parties. By selling ECC support to more customers, they can afford to price the bare CPU cheaper. That's exactly what happens with our software. There's no way we could sell to single-person companies at the price we do without having features behind "license walls". > Another issue is that this probably would not happen in a healthy, competitive market. In fact, the opposite would happen [...] One of the reasons people love cloud computing these days is that the cost scales with activity. Get more customers generating more activity? No problem, just add some extra capacity from your cloud provider. Need some additional functionality to service a new market? No need to pay for years for something you don't use until you need it.
- wayoutthere 5y agoI would have much more of a problem with this if Intel was still the only game in town. I get the feeling Intel is effectively ceding parts of the CPU market to ARM and focusing on their high-margin products.
- 1970-01-01 5y agoIntel: I'm altering our deal. Pray I don't alter it further.
- userbinator 5y agoI think the big question on everyone's minds after they get over the anger of selling something artifically crippled is, "how long until this gets cracked?"
- wmf 5y agoHow long until Intel microcode gets cracked? (Yes, one Atom processor got cracked so far.)
- sabas123 5y agoAnd that Atom processor has way inferior security than current day processors (also less attack vectors so who knows). Although what's in the OP doesn't seem to worry me that much, if it were as disastrous as others commenters suggest, this situation would just be resolved by market forces hopefully.
- waste_monk 5y agoThe splitting of the atom has changed everything except for how we think.
- atlgator 5y agoGelsinger ran VMWare into the ground. These kind of moves don't bode any better for Intel.
- ksec 5y ago>Gelsinger ran VMWare into the ground. He nearly tripled VMware revenue since be became CEO.
- throwaway2048 5y agoIntel similarly recorded record smashing profits while destroying its R&D and tons of its future potential, and AMD and ARM are now a very serious problem for them. Its entirely possible to post a few years of crazy profits while tanking the company.
- TomVDB 5y agoYour claim about running Vmare into the ground deserves a bit more explanation.
- mschuster91 5y agoThey probably are referring to VMware being displaced by the major three cloud providers.
- atlgator 5y agoThis is my point. Gelsinger milked all the profit out of VMWare when it was a cash cow, but sacrificed VMWare's future. They were #1 in virtualization, setup to dominate the cloud. Not only did they let it go, their partnerships made it EASIER to migrate to competitor CSPs.
- butterisgood 5y agoI fear you'll have to back that up with something else. VMWare thrived under Gelsinger.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- timemachine 5y agoThe real WTF: restructured text.
- nicce 5y agoIt is widely used and offers more features than Markdown. It is much better for techinical documentation in many cases.
- qilo 5y agoYeah. Didn't know GitHub can render reStructuredText.
- crazysim 5y agoIt can render mediawiki, textile, pod, org-mode, and a bunch of other text formats as well.
- usr1106 5y agoWhat's wrong about that? Not that I would have made a deep analysis, but the Linux kernel developers did not that many years ago and chose rst.
- kolbusa 5y agoAm I completely misreading this? Theoretically this is not only rent seeking but also ability for cloud provides to be able to configure the same piece of silicon with different features based on demand / etc.
- nicce 5y agoInstead of having everything by default, they would need to start buying licenses for different settings? How is this an upgrade?
- kolbusa 5y agoI had in mind a scenario in which a cloud provider would have access to everything but would be disabling things and selling those nodes cheaper (or, rather, sell nodes with extra features for more), while maintaining a uniform fleet of nodes.
- michaelt 5y agoIf a cloud provider has a 16-core processor and customers who want 8-core processors, they simply put two customer VMs per processor, each only able to see 8 of the cores. Why disable half the cores and leave them unsold, when selling both halves makes you twice as much money?
- qeternity 5y agoWhen has Intel ever sold processors that were all homogenous? They have always created many tiers of products that appeal to different customer segments and price sensitivities. This allows for upgrades without having to replace the hardware. Consider you buy consumer gear at consumer prices without ECC functionality. Then you decide you'd like to run ZFS or something where ECC is encouraged. Instead of having to replace the processor, you just upgrade the microcode.
- otherotherchris 5y agoHyperscale and large corporate buyers aren't dumb enough to fall for this. Gimme everything enabled or I'll buy a neoverse or AMD thanks. And I'd reckon at retail that sub-brand and product confusion leads to most customers buying the least costly and lowest spec version and tossing the machine in the bin if it's unsuitable. Any undifferentiated "intel core i" processor is just the same as any other undifferentiated "intel core i" processor to the layman. Most laptops at retail aren't even labeled with the cpu model number. If the cpu is slow it's just because Intel products are crap.
- userbinator 5y agoI believe this practice actually started out with the enterprise stuff, i.e. the "large corporate buyers", and if anything, they are more likely to not care or embrace it.
- monocasa 5y agoHyperscalers have already been bought in for years. There's custom Amazon, Google, etc. silicon in Xeons that either gets fused off in the general case or needs a secret MSR knock to turn on, or what have you.
- kmeisthax 5y agoIs there any public documentation as to what these features would be, and has anyone discovered ways to turn them on? I remember hearing a few years back about Intel rolling a special weird Xeon SKU with VNNI/bfloat16 tacked onto a different core architecture that got cancelled, specifically because Facebook backed out of the project. However, I think that was intended to be a publicly-available SKU that just didn't make monetary sense to produce in volume. There's also the occasional off-roadmap SKUs that eventually wind up on eBay or wherever... but my impression was that these were just ways for Intel to obfuscate whatever special volume deals they were giving certain hyperscalars.
- vsrinivas 5y agoIntel Cooper Lake - it's a 14 nm server part that fit a particular niche (4S support, VNNI/bfloat16). It was partly due to FB, but also partly to provide a platform that was larger than ICX server could / can.
- dboreham 5y agoThe modern version of the story about the mainframe where the memory upgrade consisted of a tech coming on site to pull out a jumper...
- detaro 5y agoNot much of a "story", it's a feature e.g. IBM openly advertises for their machines, not just in mainframes. E.g. you can get the big POWER servers with spare CPUs you can then buy or rent later. Or at least you could last I had the "pleasure" of IBM sales presentations.
- baq 5y agoit's like having a cloud on prem. what's not to like?
- sokoloff 5y agoFor a while, Jeep Wranglers had a 15 gallon fuel tank, with an optional upgrade to a 19 gallon tank. The tank itself was the same; the “upgrade” consisted of shortening the metal fill hose to allow the 19 gallon tank to be completely filled.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoUS versions of the BMW i3 hybrid has a "software defined fuel tank" that is smaller than the actualy physical fuel tank, from https://tomasz.korwel.net/2015/01/16/favorite-i3-coding-change-9-l-2-4-us-gal-fuel-tank/ https://tomasz.korwel.net/2015/01/16/favorite-i3-coding-chan... : > It is suspected (although nobody confirmed ) that to fully comply with CARBs requirements BMW needed to make sure that the car’s gasoline range is lower than it’s range when it’s powered by electricity alone. To accomplish that they lowered tank’s capacity (from 2.4 US gal to 1.9 US gal). We, software engineers, hate when accountants win.
- hyperman1 5y agoCan they stop you from doing this yourself? In software, the trick is it is licensed not sold, so you are not allowed even if you can do something. But a car is sold. So if you want to cut of a piece of the car, what's going to stop you?
- scottcodie 5y agoSilicon is highly competitive so I doubt this will be much of an issue. Currently, processors are shipped with features turned off with no ability to turn them on later.
- gumby 5y agoI was hoping this was a way to write my own microcode. I miss those days.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sebow 5y agoLmao, and the funny thing is that this is not intel's first time doing this.
- PedroBatista 5y agoA Tesla inspired feature of an old playbook?
- DeathArrow 5y agoWhat's next? You don't own anymore the CPU, you just rent it, the same way the software today is using subscriptions?
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoConsidering CPUs already have a hidden OS that runs on standby power and can update over the Internet, I'd say we're already there. Intel can brick your computer remotely just as easily as Apple can. The only reason they have not done so, is because the US government haven't told them to. Same applies to Chinese telecom equipment of course, and the Internet itself. In fact, it's a feature of weapons sold as well. US supplied fighter jets will conveniently not allow firing on sources of secret US codes transmitted. Most people have no clue that even their SIM card runs its own operating system, that communicates and is powered remotely. Not from great distance but still.
- southerntofu 5y ago> powered remotely. Not from great distance but still. What do you mean with this? Do you have a link explaining in more detail?
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoOh sorry my brain skipped from SIM cards to other cards with NFC chips. I don't actually know if SIM cards do NFC. In short, computers powered wirelessly over short distances. A larger, fixed device with ample power ("card reader") produces a radio field; The NFC chip is an antenna with a computer that gains enough power from the radio field itself to do computation on the signal and transmit a response. Since the NFC chip is obviously very low power, it has to be close enough to be heard. But anyone with the right kind of portable card reader can attempt to communicate with your NFC cards in your wallet simply by passing you on the street. Phones, of course, already communicate over long distances, so NFC would be somewhat pointless on a SIM card specifically :P
- 5y ago
- qeternity 5y agoI'm not really sure I understand the outrage here. Just because the marginal cost of something is low/zero doesn't mean companies shouldn't charge for it. Should an indie software developer using a freemium model be crucified because the binary they ship already contains the code for full functionality? Of course not. The cost is in developing the binary, not in manufacturing it. Same goes for silicon. Also, "rent seeking" does not mean what most people in this thread seem to think it does. Economic rents are a very specific phenomenon and it simply does not mean charging for something that is perceived as being low/no effort.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThe problem is that this can be arbitrary if the market doesn't supply enough competitors. I don't think Intel is in a position to enforce this, but the competitors that would prohibit them from implementing such restrictions are fairly weak in numbers. AMD alone isn't enough regardless of whether they ship superior products or not. It also tells me about the focus of Intel and who is in charge of the company. They have many flawed products lately and they seem to not want to compete on a technological level anymore. That said, proprietary DSP aren't unusual. It would still a shame if they find their way into general computing too a larger degree. Can make sense for the line of XEON CPU perhaps. I just wouldn't buy them really.
- qeternity 5y ago> The problem is that this can be arbitrary if the market doesn't supply enough competitors. What is this referring to? What is the problem? And why is this problem arbitrary? > It also tells me about the focus of Intel and who is in charge of the company. They have many flawed products lately and they seem to not want to compete on a technological level anymore. Ok, that's one take and you're certainly entitled to it. As someone who personally had to replace some hardware so I could use ecc ram in a zfs nas for my media server, I would have loved to just pay a few bucks to get a microcode update instead of a full hardware upgrade. Now, you can complain that ecc should be standard, etc but that's a different discussion. But it's classic economic theory: if Intel can charge some people more for ecc, and charge other people less who don't want it, that is an optimal pricing strategy.
- kristianpaul 5y agoDoes this comes with free security updates?
- foxhop 5y agoNobody wants shit on their hardware. Imagine DRM on after market CPUs. It's already a disaster at the daughter board level. For example, look at this nonsense I had to reverse engineer: https://russell.ballestrini.net/how-to-reset-hp-ilo-lights-out-user-and-password-settings-with-ipmitools/ https://russell.ballestrini.net/how-to-reset-hp-ilo-lights-o...
- voakbasda 5y agoIndeed. This kind of anti-consumer shenanigan has pushed me firmly and permanently in the AMD camp. Maybe it is time to reevaluate x86 entirely. Is ARM ready to take over the world?
- pabs3 5y agoIf I had the money I'd go with OpenPOWER for now, even the firmware is open source (at least for POWER9, POWER10 is another matter).
- systemvoltage 5y agoCan we reel software into this philosophy? I want no shit on my software either. To me, software and hardware at some abstraction layer become the same. They're just products and services. If I purchase a movie, I want no DRM just as if I purchased a CPU.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoBut Revokatio Payola disapproves!
- omegalulw 5y ago> Nobody wants shit on their hardware. It's so annoying. On a similar note, DHCP implementations are messed up for one reason or another and I now can't watch 4K premium content from most providers except Netflix. They would force me to buy a 4K TV.
- rsynnott 5y agoI feel like Intel tries this about once every five years, everyone is unhappy, and it's abandoned for a bit. I'm pretty sure there were certain desktop chips for which virtualization instructions were an in-chip-purchase, for instance.
- vaylian 5y agoIf we can toggle features on and off for money, then I would like to get a refund for the Intel Management Engine because I don't want that nonsense on my private computer.
- charcircuit 5y agoYour computer will not work without the IME. It's a necessary part of the system.
- anthk 5y agoFalse, you can deactivate it, the Libreboot/Coreboot guys have done that.
- monocasa 5y agoIf you look at their work closely, you'll find that it's still on. They simply removed a lot of the processes that run on it on earlier revs. ME is required to bringup the main CPU chip afyer pkwer on.
- baq 5y agoHN: deploy to cloud, pay as you go only for what you're using also HN: I will never buy anything from a company that does sells me a product with an upgrade option same thing, different wording, opposite ends of the reaction spectrum.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoBack in 2004, Joel Spolsky wrote about market segmentation and pricing of technology. > And God help you if an A-list blogger finds out that your premium printer is identical to the cheap printer, with the speed inhibitor turned off. [1] I don't think he could have imagined that consumers would be forced to tolerate the subscriptions and rentals we see today. [1] https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-duckies/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-...
- gareiner 5y agoNo, please don't do this one. It's killing the hardware and its features. It feels like you don't own the hardware as it needs to be fully unlocked at the expense of a license activation
- Qem 5y agoMore appropriate term would be Ransom-Aware Silicon (RAS or RASi), instead of the euphemism Software Defined Silicon (SDS).