3 ms·

It's fine to refuse the return. It's not fine to steal the refused return.

• dylan604 5y ago
  What are the logisitcs for majorCorp? Eat the cost of shipping the item they didn't authorize to send to them in the first place? It's not their fault user did wrong thing. To them, they are still out 2 items. According to the terms of the return, if you don't follow the terms, you eat the cost of both items. The terms were not followed to the point that it will cost seller even more money to return the unqualified item. Maybe a bit rambly mambly, but hopefully you can at least see the situation from a neutral point of view.
  • Dylan16807 5y ago
    It's logistically annoying if you're sent something by mistake and now need to deal with it in some manner. But if they don't accept the return then it's not their property. Throwing it away is theft.
    • dylan604 5y ago
      Um, it was given willingly if perhaps mistakenly. Amazon did not sneak into their home and grab the wrong thing without the owner knowing. There were no weapons brandished, no threats made, nor any other menacing to provoke the taking of something unwanted to be given. I think your definition of theft is in need of adjustment. You might have something against Amazon, and might even be justified in that feeling, but it is misguiding your judgement in this case.
      • Dylan16807 5y ago
        If you send the wrong item, or send an item to the wrong address, it's not a gift. Amazon taking possession isn't theft. Destroying something they don't own is theft. Specifically, it's conversion.
  • tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago
    At most, they could charge reasonable shipping costs for shipping it back.