3 ms·
If the land registrar's venality can be exploited, what difference does blockchain make? Laws are enforced by people, not code.
by rchaud 5y ago
If the land registrar's venality can be exploited, what difference does blockchain make? Laws are enforced by people, not code.
- DennisP 5y agoThe difference is that it can't be done in secret. And it's possible that the highest level of government would like to fix the problem, but has trouble with corruption at lower levels. Making corrupt transfers obvious would make them much easier to clean up. In other words, you might as well ask "what difference do notarized documents make?" Anything we can do to establish reliable documentation helps the enforcers of property rights do their job. Blockchains provide reliable records even when you can't trust a critical mass of low-level human record keepers. (And I'm not making this stuff up, see the links I posted in a cousin comment.)
- dmitriid 5y ago> The difference is that it can't be done in secret. Who cares? The record is entered by a government official. That's it. The land bow belongs to whoever is written the record. Blockchain doesn't help here at all. There are also multiple other cases around land ownership that blockchain proponents don't consider because blockchain proponents en masse have no idea how reality works.
- DennisP 5y ago> it's possible that the highest level of government would like to fix the problem, but has trouble with corruption at lower levels
- dmitriid 5y agoAh yes. As always with blockchains, everything depends on some nebulous "possibly someone somewhere will perhaps do something, and the only reason they are not already doing it now is because they don't have blockchain"
- DennisP 5y agoIt's actually not uncommon for high-level government officials to attempt to crack down on corruption at lower levels, and to have great difficulty succeeding. Blockchains are a reliable record-keeping tool that can help, much like double-entry bookkeeping helps authorities prevent other types of shenanigans. Unlike the skeptics here, I've provided reference supporting these claims. But I suppose when double-entry bookkeeping was first introduced, it faced a lot of dismissive snark as well.
- Daishiman 5y agoNo, the snark is that you're talking about things as is good recordkeeping is some marvelous solution to problems. Where I live the tax agency has no problem having transparent records of everything that happens. And yet tax evasion is an enormous problem. Recordkeeping is not the reason why people evade taxes and why they won't stop. Same thing with a violent police force or corrupt border police.
- dmitriid 5y ago> Blockchains are a reliable record-keeping tool that can help It's a computer system where you enter records. That's it. These poor high-level government officials that can't do anything could already have implemented/procured such a system without blockchain. They haven't. But sure, they are only lacking blockchain to make this magically happen. Edit: > Unlike the skeptics here, I've provided reference supporting these claims. If you refer to pilot projects using blockchain in some countries, these are nothing but scams looking for easy grant money, don't solve the actual problems (especially not in countries with bad record keeping), and can be implemented faster and more efficiently with any other tech. As an example, this mini-thread on land registries in Afghanistan: https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1386994745218584580?s=20 https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1386994745218584580?s=20 Also this discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27212564 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27212564 And this lower down: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27217681 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27217681 How's that for references?
- 5y ago
- lowkey 5y agoSunlight is the best cure for corruption. By putting registry data on the blockchain and allowing anyone to independently verify state of an immutable distributed database makes it much harder to get away with the corruption.
- Daishiman 5y agoThis isn't how things work in corrupt countries.
- DennisP 5y agoPeople here keep saying I don't understand "how things work" but so far nobody has provided references, while I've provided three links in support of my claims. Could you do the same?
- Daishiman 5y agoIn corrupt countries the laws don't matter two shits. What matters is what gets enforced. What matters is that the right cases go to the right courts. What matters is that people who press on these things get calls told to drop it, and if they don't drop it, they find themselves in accidents that no journalist is willing to touch with a ten-foot pole. You're not going to find experiments quantifying this corruption; you'll find lived experiences and anecdotes coming from the same countries with the similar MOs. Blockchains don't solve the problem of a police captain knocking at your door telling you that if don't go through with a shitty deal your son isn't coming back from school the next day.
- DennisP 5y agoStill no references then. I didn't ask for experiments; any decent journalism would suffice. You're assuming the government is a monolithic entity, either corrupt or not. The truth is that often corruption is widespread but there are people at the top trying to fix it. That's not an easy task, and it's where keeping good, unforgeable records can help. That's why several governments are in fact running pilot blockchain programs.