4 ms·
This article talks about their new electric sedan and future SUV. And here I am still waiting on electric minivan. I regularly have to carry six people around
by jedberg 5y ago
This article talks about their new electric sedan and future SUV.
And here I am still waiting on electric minivan. I regularly have to carry six people around, two of which are children and two of which are elderly, so I can't use anything that requires climbing to get into the seats (like every six seat SUV).
Am I really that small of a market that no one wants to make an electric minivan, or is it a technologically difficult problem?
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoI'm with you there. I tried all the currently available vans (Mercedes V Class, eVito, Opel Zafira Life (and related models)) and nothing so far I enjoy. Hoping the ID.Buzz is going to be a reasonable replacement for our current Diesel Minivan.
- dangoor 5y agoNot fully electric, but there is a plugin hybrid minivan: https://www.chrysler.com/pacifica/hybrid.html https://www.chrysler.com/pacifica/hybrid.html
- jedberg 5y agoI actually almost bought that instead of my current minivan, but the build quality on it wasn't very good and more importantly it's all electric range was tiny (like 30 miles).
- dangoor 5y agoDefinitely depends on your driving patterns. I had a Prius Prime with a similar range and did the vast majority of my driving on electric (and quite appreciated the gas engine with 50mpg when I was driving longer distances).
- slaw 5y agoDid you actually drove one? Or you just read somewhere about build quality?
- jedberg 5y agoI actually drove one for an extended test drive. Even the brand new car had stuff that wasn't on straight and already coming apart.
- QuarterReptile 5y agoThat's a shame to hear; I thought the pacifica hybrid seemed like a good option for my own upcoming purchase, especially since I would've been able to do the vast majority of my non-travel miles on the battery. I'm guessing you went with a Honda?
- jedberg 5y agoI went with the Honda, yes. They had just launched the new model and it checked all the boxes. But you should still check out the Pacifica. It might be a lot better now, four years later.
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoIn Europe you can buy the current gen VW Multivan as hybrid now since the Pacifica is not sold here.
- MBCook 5y agoUnfortunately I think it’s just a smaller market. SUVs are easy to make and REALLY popular. The only thing that might be a problem is that there’s a thickness to the battery. Because SUVs are higher up it’s sort of easy to “hide“. But since minivans are much lower there may not be much space between the battery and the bottom of the car to put one. But more than anything I would guess it’s a demand thing.
- Rygian 5y agoSounds like a Tesla model X fits your needs thanks to the falcon wings.
- jedberg 5y agoWe tried one of those. It’s a spaceship for the driver and a Corolla for the passengers. Super uncomfortable for everyone but the driver. My MIL who never gets carsick got carsick in it.
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoThe doors are also a completely bonkers and impractical design. I'm not sure they couldn't just install sliding doors instead.
- ComputerGuru 5y agoIt was a successful marketing stunt.
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoSuccessful would be if the car would sell. It doesn't.
- Tagbert 5y agoBut then it would be... <gasp>... a minivan!
- dharmab 5y agoIt's a market issue- SUVs have a larger addressable market.
- dghughes 5y agoThe Canoo seven seat electric vehicle is supposed to be released soon. https://www.canoo.com/ https://www.canoo.com/ edit: It was originally supposed to go on sale "late 2021" now I see it's "late 2022".
- jedberg 5y agoInteresting concept, never heard of it. Will keep my eye on it, thanks!
- Epa095 5y agoWhat about the Nissan e-nv200? It can come in different configurations, including a 7 seat one. A friend has it to log his family around. It does not have the greatest range, but decent enough.
- jedberg 5y agoLooks like it's only available in the UK and mostly commercial. But at least it means it's possible!
- Epa095 5y agoThey are certainly available outside the UK, there are plenty of them here in Norway. But I googled it now and surprisingly they don't seem too be available in the US at all.
- newaccount74 5y agoSpeaking from a European perspective, I think classic minivans are dead. There are just a handful of minivans left on the market, and I doubt any of them will be electrified. People who used to buy minivans now have 3 options: - if you don't need to transport more than 5 people, you can get an SUV. There are lots of electric options. - if you want to transport 5-7 people and want a lot of cargo space, you can get what wikipedia calls a "leisure activity vehicle" (VW Caddy, Renault Kangoo, Mercedes Citan). A new electric Kangoo with longer range is coming, and there's the Mercedes EQT concept based on it which is as close to an electric minivan as you'll get. - If you want an even bigger car that can transport up to 8 people there's the EQV from Mercedes.
- the_mitsuhiko 5y agoEuropean minivans never really existed in the US. The European vans (V-Class, Staria, T6.1/T7, Vito, PSA van etc.) are size wise almost on the same level as the classical US minivans (Pacifica, Carnival, Odyssey). Sure, small minivans are dying out but at the same time there are a lot of new van designs many of which are already electrified but don't have good range yet. VW is positioning the new T7 as replacement for Touran/Sharan/Alhambra and the ID.Buzz for instance is supposed to be a replacement as well when it's available.
- jedberg 5y agoI actually looked at gray market importing of European vans (we don't have any of those in the US) but it was cost prohibitive or straight up impossible depending on the model.
- hinkley 5y agoVW has been teasing one but the front blind spots on that thing are heinous.
- spockz 5y agoMy biggest gripe with SUVs is that even the biggest ones like X5 and XC90 comfortably fit 3 passengers in the rear. There appears to by an Audi Q7/8 that could do it but it isn’t hybrid/electric. Then If you want more, you have to get a 7-seater. But actually using it as such eliminates any cargo space from the boot. And this while the outer rear seats are hugely wide and there is a ton of space between theseat and the door. My Passat gte has 20cm on each side where the sitting part of the bench extends further than the back of the bench. That could also have been used to make a comfortable seat in the middle.
- BlueDingo 5y agoI searched a few weeks ago and find there should be a number of EV minivans for model year 2022. For those saying that SUVs can fit this use case...the SUVs are almost entirely small crossovers. They have the shape but you can't fit more people than a car.