4 ms·
What do you mean "except"? Within the moon share ecosystem, moon shares have the exact same kind of authority. Value's always worth what someone will pay, sur
by Dylan16807 5y ago
What do you mean "except"?
Within the moon share ecosystem, moon shares have the exact same kind of authority.
Value's always worth what someone will pay, sure. But blockchain authority isn't more special than any other database. It has some fancy properties, but they don't affect the authority.
- capableweb 5y agoAuthority on the blockchain is validated by a bunch of different actors, none who trust each other but reaches consensus anyways. Authority within the moon share ecosystem is validated only by the people who own the company.
- Dylan16807 5y agoThat might matter in a niche case where the ownership of my moon share database entry is in dispute. (And each system has positives and negatives, blockchains aren't a strict upgrade.) But the potential authority over the actual moon is the same under both systems.
- imgabe 5y agoOwnership only ever matters when there's a dispute. If you go build a house on a piece of land, and nobody ever comes along and disputes whether you own that land, does it matter whether you do or not? I mean, we even built into our laws that if you do that and nobody disputes it for long enough, then you get to officially own the land.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Ownership only ever matters when there's a dispute. Right. And a blockchain only solves a tiny percentage of ownership issues. It solves those issues with powerful mathematical certainty, and if you could live inside a blockchain your problems would be solved*, but don't confuse that sliver with the full set of real-world ownership issues that exist with or without a blockchain being involved. * if there are no bugs or hacks
- imgabe 5y agoWhat does it mean to own something? It what sense does a Moon share give you any ownership over any part of the moon? If someone else goes up to the Moon and builds a lunar base on "your" piece of the Moon, does your Moon share give you any way to stop them? Can you sue them in any court? Does it prevent anyone in any way from doing whatever they want with that piece of the Moon? No, it doesn't. Contrast with a token in your wallet on the blockchain. As long as your private keys are secure, nobody else but you can transfer that token anywhere else. Nobody else can convincingly represent that they are the owner of it. The blockchain proves irrefutably that you own it. The blockchain, as represented by the consensus of thousands of nodes, is the ultimate authority of who owns what on that blockchain.
- efdee 5y agoThe blockchain equates to the Moon Shares company. Outside of the company/blockchain, the ownership means nothing.
- imgabe 5y agoOutside of the blockchain, a token on the blockchain means nothing. Outside of the Moon company, a piece of the moon is still a real thing that means something. You can only "own" a physical object if you either have sufficient physical force to assert your ownership of it or the government recognizes your ownership and will exert force on your behalf to assert it. Neither of those are necessary for the blockchain because nobody can assert ownership of the blockchain tokens without the private keys to your wallet.
- UncleMeat 5y agoAnd my moon certificate proves that I own that part of the moon. Control over transfer is not the same as control over other uses.
- imgabe 5y agoIt doesn't prove that you own part of the moon at all. The moon is a physical object. To own it, you need to be able to prevent other people from using it, or have an authority that can do so recognize your ownership and do that on your behalf. The Moon shares don't do that. The NFT on the blockchain does prevent other people from using that NFT without your authorization.