6 ms·
> I wouldn't buy a new daily driver that doesn't have blind spot monitoring, collision avoidance, lane keep assist, etc. Once you have these features and you ar
by HWR_14 5y ago
> I wouldn't buy a new daily driver that doesn't have blind spot monitoring, collision avoidance, lane keep assist, etc. Once you have these features and you are accustomed to how they work, you can't go back.
And I don't like them. But only one of us has the government taking away our choice by making them mandatory.
I wouldn't mind them if it wasn't for the fact that they universally seem to be points of failure that shorten the lifespan of the car.
- alphabettsy 5y agoHow does a defeat-able non-essential feature shorten a vehicle’s lifespan?
- HWR_14 5y agoIf it's a feature required by the government to be road legal, it's likely not run and/or pass emissions testing if it's not working. And it's a point of failure written by people who are bad at software. Alternatively, computer control of real world systems (e.g. acceleration and braking) can lead to actual accidents, totaling the vehicle. There was that lady who claims her Tesla's software caused a crash, and, without commenting on if that is true, it's plausible.
- stefan_ 5y agoHere is a thing that happens: many countries have more or less comprehensive regular vehicle inspections. If your car is showing a warning light or reports an error on the standardized interface, that can cause you to fail the inspection. What a warning light is shown for is at the discretion of the manufacturer though. One example is Anti-lock braking (ABS), which they made mandatory in 2004. If you bought a car without it in 2003 and have it inspected in 2013, no problem. If you bought a car with ABS in 2004 and the controller for it breaks in 2008, you will fail the inspection - even though your braking is no worse than the 2003 car (ABS was wisely designed to fail safe..).
- aunty_helen 5y agoThe point of abs isn’t to improve your braking system. It’s to stop you from panicking in an accident situation, locking up the front wheels and losing the ability to steer. Abs actually very slightly reduces the stopping potential of your brake system. But being able to steer and control your car is a bigger benefit under these circumstances.
- stefan_ 5y agoNow think it through. What happens if a wheel locks up? Right, it loses all stopping power. I certainly agree that you want ABS, it's just to illustrate the pitfalls it creates when you have these additional systems. You can tell much the same story around emissions controls; newer cars pass stricter emissions standards and require extra parts and technology to achieve them.
- mnemnc 5y ago> Now think it through. What happens if a wheel locks up? Right, it loses all stopping power. That‘s not true. Going in a straight line, blocking wheels will stop you in less distance than with active ABS. However ABS allows you to brake and go around an obstacle without losing control of your vehicle.
- throwaway525142 5y agoI think the friction of wheels is lower when the wheels lock up vs when they go with the speed of the road. From Wikipedia[1]: > Kinetic friction, also known as dynamic friction or sliding friction, occurs when two objects are moving relative to each other and rub together (like a sled on the ground). The coefficient of kinetic friction is typically denoted as μk, and is usually less than the coefficient of static friction for the same materials.[40][41] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Friction&oldid=1054585720#Kinetic_friction https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Friction&oldid=10...
- jjav 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- willis936 5y agoThey're not there for you to like them. They're there so you don't kill someone and someone else doesn't kill you. Society collectively fails to give a single ass of a rat about how people feel about their ubiquitous 2-ton death machine.
- necovek 5y agoAs I explained in my another comment on this thread, sometimes they can behave unpredictably — eg. car brakes without a need — causing someone else to crash into you (these are most common crashes I see in the city streets). Perhaps they are not useful for me because I am a very attentive driver (eg. I prefer not to talk on the phone even with the BT hands-free system while driving because it takes my attention away from the road), but they are far away from being all positives. And how many more cars are going to be produced and bought because of "planned obsolescence" when electronic systems in modern cars start to give up (eg. electric cars and their engines should be able to last for a really long time)? Are they going to keep getting security updates for 20, 30 years? Or will we start seeing people doing something to fool their sensors so they crash? While I like all the technology, it's short-sighted to think that the alternative is desired simply because people don't care about potentially hurting someone with their cars. Like everything else in life, this issue is multifaceted too.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I am a very attentive driver Everyone thinks they're a great driver.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> And I don't like them. They're not there for you to like - they're there for the people you might kill with your car. > the government taking away our choice... ...to plough into people with your car.
- HWR_14 5y agoI don't think those devices reduce the number of accidents, so I disagree with your premise. I think they serve to help slowly roll out self-driving capabilities.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I don't think those devices reduce the number of accidents Good for you. But society disagrees and requires them.
- HWR_14 5y agoPeople in society are disagreeing about the accuracy of the devices and arguing about it. Kinda circular logic to insist that "this law is about the be passed, therefore it's the will of society, and therefore is correct."
- anakaine 5y agoThere was also a time where people suggested that vehicles replacing horses was unsafe. They were, of course, correct in a sense, but tended to ignore the decrease in horse related accidents. There was also a time where quite a number of people believed that the human body couldn't cope with speeds over some arbitrary number. They also were proven to be incorrect - mainly because technology enabled people to travel faster and then subsequently made that travel safer.
- marcellus23 5y ago> I don't think those devices reduce the number of accidents Do you have a source for this?
- e-clinton 5y agoThey made seatbelts mandatory too. Yuck! JK! These system do save lives though. Driving is a privilege, not a right. So I’m fine with these mandates as they don’t really get in my way.
- jeegsy 5y ago> Driving is a privilege, not a right Why is that?
- marcellus23 5y agoBecause it’s an incredibly dangerous activity and you can easily kill people. That’s why you need to pass a test and get a license to drive a car.
- patrick451 5y agoThe only person at risk when I decided to not wear a seatbelt is me. Laws compelling me to wear one are the epitome of government overreach.
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 5y agoThat's patently not true. - in some situations you can lose control of the vehicle, e.g.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCObYDxa3Do https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCObYDxa3Do - if you crash, your body will be flying freely in the car, creating danger for other occupants of the car