5 ms·
That is by now more than frustrating. Yes, everyone from WHO down to the CDC and there counter-parts in other countries screwed up the mask recommendation. At f
by hef19898 5y ago
That is by now more than frustrating. Yes, everyone from WHO down to the CDC and there counter-parts in other countries screwed up the mask recommendation. At first, under very difficult circumstances. They corrected that, so, rather quickly. We would all do ourselves a favor and stop bringing this up every single time we talk masks.
- Ensorceled 5y agoYou should really read the rest of the comments in this thread. People are still asserting masks do "zero" to stop the spread. Dr. Tam, who is responsible for both gross incompetence AND intentionally misleading the public WRT COVID19, mistakes that literally killed people and, is probably still killing people, remains in her position as Chief Public Health Officer of Canada. This is why I can't let it go.
- FredPret 5y agoFiring her during the pandemic would be very unwise politically
- timr 5y ago...and then someone actually did a cluster RCT for masks and Covid, and found that cloth masks don't have any effect, and surgical masks have a truly minor effect on transmission: https://vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/do-masks-reduce-risk-of-covid19-by https://vinayprasadmdmph.substack.com/p/do-masks-reduce-risk... We really need to stop repeating the talking point that "everyone screwed up". The original evidence base was that masks don't do much to stop respiratory illness. "The science" changed in the span of a week in early 2020, based on little more than propaganda. No actual science was ever performed, and once we did some, we found out that the early evidence was pretty much correct.
- skinnymuch 5y ago[flagged]
- christophilus 5y agoNot gonna defend him, but I was once an atheist and am now Catholic. People do change, and it’s always weird when people pull the “no true Scotsman” card on you. I have plenty of liberal friends who were once conservative.
- jquery 5y agoI don’t think it’s “no true scotsman” when someone is saying they aren’t scot and that they’ve never been within 1000 miles of Scotland.
- skinnymuch 5y agoThe sibling comment echoed what I was trying to say. It’s not a no true Scotsman. It’s what the sibling comment said. That’s what I have a problem with. It’s a more and more common occurrence among obviously conservative/right wing people continuously saying they were recently liberal/progressive or are still centrist. At no point in any blog post did I see the blogger refer to themselves as conservative. Only cheering conservatives on a lot and blaming the left for a bunch of stuff (the only group the blogger said he has identified or belonged to)
- timr 5y agoHe's not a conservative. You're engaged in tribalism: defining people as members of the other team because they disagree with you on one issue. I am on the left, and agree with Prasad that the institutional left has done generational damage with its response to Covid, abandoned reason and equity and respect for science. If the "right" happens to agree with me, then that's fine.
- zpeti 5y agoI'm not sure what makes you right wing about being worried about school closures. We have studies showing worsening eyesight for children because of lockdowns: https://www.aao.org/eye-health/tips-prevention/covid19-pandemic-myopia-children-eyes https://www.aao.org/eye-health/tips-prevention/covid19-pande... (that might have an effect for 100 years?) A 7 year old child is extremely malleable, and especially socially needs an incredible amount of input to develop as a person. What you do today to a 7 year old for (currently) 2 years has a massive effect later. Not to mention, how do you think a 7 year olds parents are affected by lockdowns who they are locked up with? Alcoholism? Up. Drug abuse? Up. Domestic abuse? Up. So again, where is the guy wrong?
- chrischattin 5y agoI find it disturbing that everytime someone points out the actual science of masks (ineffective for stopping viral transmission) they are immediately downvoted or shouted down online.
- AnthonBerg 5y agoIt's absolutely crucial to distinguish between the different understanding people have of the word masks – cloth masks, gaping-at-the-sides "surgical masks", N95/FFP2 masks, N100/FFP3 masks. Each random person's picture of masks will be very different from what the next person is thinking. And it's also very important to distinguish between the different meanings of viral transmission – of what virus, and according to what scientific results it's being talked about. A lot of the friction comes from this. In SARS-CoV-2 transmission specifically, I speak about it as airborne or aerosolized, based on all the papers that are out that confirm that now, and I when I say "masks" I tend to think of gaping surgical masks or better, and no, those don't work well enough. However in the sense of the word masks as N95/FFP2 masks or better—often called respirators—then those masks are almost unreasonably effective at stopping transmission. Here's the data I base my perspective on, in the nutshell form of some tweets from scientists, tweets linking to scientific papers. (Some are peer-reviewed, some at the preprint stage.) https://twitter.com/JenniferKShea/status/1449748053548752903 https://twitter.com/JenniferKShea/status/1449748053548752903 — We've summarized the literature supporting airborne transmission of COVID-19 & several other respiratory pathogens. Guess what? #COVIDisAirborne https://twitter.com/mjb302/status/1409628852867850240 https://twitter.com/mjb302/status/1409628852867850240 — Important new research examining the real world impact better PPE has on workplace acquired infections of SARS-CoV2. — TL:DR - FFP3 respirators provide 100% protection to healthcare workers looking after patients infected with SARS-CoV2. 1/25 https://twitter.com/andymoz78/status/1441355141051936772 https://twitter.com/andymoz78/status/1441355141051936772 — A thread on our recent pre-print “The removal of airborne SARS-CoV-2 and other microbial bioaerosols by air filtration on COVID-19 surge units” (*Pre-print -not peer reviewed*) — TL:DR Hospital air is dirty, we can clean it https://twitter.com/DFisman/status/1454776521818886145 https://twitter.com/DFisman/status/1454776521818886145 — Remarkable new work from Korea shows the extraordinary impact of masks on SARS-2 transmission on public transit. — Parameterized based on *aerosol* simulator. (Because SARS-2 is airborne). Distancing helps, but less important (b/c SARS-2 = airborne). https://twitter.com/caruzycki/status/1360635674324463616 https://twitter.com/caruzycki/status/1360635674324463616 — 2/ If this disease were only spread by droplets that fell to the ground within 2 metres, [plexiglass barriers] would be a perfectly fine solution to limit transmission. Unfortunately, we unequivocally know that aerosols are important with this disease.
- bmn__ 5y ago> We would all do ourselves a favor and stop bringing this up No, I won't. Explain why those responsible at NHC and WHO for allowing the CCP virus to spread should escape public scrutiny for having blood on their hands.
- fl0wenol 5y ago"CCP virus" -- Kind of makes it hard to take you seriously.
- bmn__ 5y agoIt works well as a name to make people laugh. If they wouldn't laugh, they would cry. This is a good coping mechanism in the face of overwhelming tragedy and suffering. I works well as a name to remind people that all this was caused by the neglect of the CCP that was instrumental in allowing the virus to spread.
- hef19898 5y agoSo we are back at blaming China? For what, a couple of weeks delay in locking down Wuhan, a decision by local authorities? China locked down harder and faster than any other country. Heck, they even locked down Wuhan harder when it was still seen as local thing than Germany is locking down, and taking measure against the 4th wave, now. Blaming China, and one wrong recommendation about masks for the mess parts of the developed world finds itself in is just disingenuous. After Italy was a couple to days to slow in 2020, we know what to do. And we fail doing it. And that failing has nothing whatsoever to do with China or our experts, but rather large swaths of the population, and politicians, refusing to accept measures and guidance.
- bmn__ 5y agoI see that you brazenly conflate the country with the party in an attempt befuddle HN readers, but that does not work. They are not tricked that easily. No, we are back to where we started, placing blame where it belongs, on the CCP: first for suppressing the information about a new SARS outbreak and claiming it was not human transmissable, then second for a laughably ineffective Wuhan lockdown. It was ineffective, allowing asymptomatic infected people to escape, for two reasons: • Some people who did not fancy being put under lockdown left the region by car and found holes in the secure perimeter or simply bribed the patrols, those who were successful doing so shared the routes and bragged about it on Wechat. • The party secretariat ordered the airport to stop domestic flights, but the international flights continued as usual. Tracing revealed the virus was subsequently carried off abroad, initially to Thailand.
- MrPatan 5y agoSo the next time they're about to mess up nobody remembers how incompetent they are?
- hef19898 5y agoNo, of course not. Because we also continue to listen to people that only were "right" once due to sheer luck that parts of the utter BS they spread turned out to be not completely wrong in a single instance. On a serious note, how often did they really mess up? In a sense of having consequences that are close to impossible to fix? Not once, if you ask me.
- ekianjo 5y agoThey were supposed to be the experts. In practice your dog was a better expert than they were.
- hef19898 5y agoBeing once wrong disqualifies then? What I really hate is that some parties have to be right all the time, while others only once. An expert is not the one who is never wrong, but the one who knows why he was wrong and changes his opinion once data and information changes.
- ekianjo 5y agoThere was sufficient data available from China before even COVID19 hit the US. You had to be either incompetent or malicious not to recommend masks.
- CamperBob2 5y agoOr you had to take one look at the toilet-paper shelf at your local grocery store, leading to the realization that if the same thing were to happen with PPE, it would be apocalyptic. Not all lies are malicious. Some are necessary. "Masks aren't helpful" was one of those. Everyone with a three-digit IQ should have understood what was really going on, and everyone else was better off believing the lie.
- throwaway2077 5y agoI love how mask-off this comment is.
- CamperBob2 5y ago(Shrug) Realpolitik is real.