4 ms·
I appreciate the honesty of the post. For myself, I don’t think having “swagger” is particularly constructive. Ego is a mind-killer. It is selling smoke. I’m
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
I appreciate the honesty of the post.
For myself, I don’t think having “swagger” is particularly constructive. Ego is a mind-killer. It is selling smoke.
I’m quite good at what I do. In some things, I am very good; but at many, many other things, I still have a lot to learn, and in other areas, it’s best I stay out of the kitchen, entirely.
In the areas in which I excel, I often exude great confidence, which is sometimes mistaken for arrogance.
The key difference, though, is that I’m quite aware that I have yet to reach the summit. False confidence is a lie, but so is false humility. I’m good at what I do. I want people to feel assured. Confidence is a trait that helps to add to a team environment. Arrogance is corrosive. It damages a team.
Regardless of how good I get, I’ve learned that kindness, respect, and empathy never go out of style. I can always listen to others, and treat them well. And, even more important; I always have something to learn.
If I am working for others; either as an employee, or under contract, they are the boss. They may make rash, uninformed decisions, give terrible orders, and treat me (or worse, my work) like crap. I have to tuck in my bib, pick up a spoon, and engage in coprophagy. It sucks, but that’s life. I had to deal with it for a long, long time, and am grateful that I am finally free of it.
I was a manager for a long time. I was a very good one, but I hated that job. I did a lot of open-source work during that time, as it kept me sane. Being humble was not a problem. I wasn’t that high on the food chain, and my bib was quite stained.
During a long career, filled with bad decisions and mistakes, I have learned that there’s really no substitute for the kind of self-confidence (and humility) that is wrought by experience.
“Good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgment.”
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atoav 5y ago> “Good judgment comes from experience. Experience comes from bad judgment.” And if you are clever you also get your experience from bad judgment others make.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoYup. Another favorite aphorism: "A fool never learns. A smart man learns from his mistakes. A wise man learns from the mistakes of others." One problem that I have with people being given huge responsibility, before getting much experience, is that we haven’t had time to see others make mistakes. One key reason that I was a good manager, was that I had many bad managers, and learned what not to do.
- atoav 5y agoI think a lot of that has to do with the ability or experience to actually observe when something presents itself. Not sure where this comes from, but I realized at some point that not everybody makes use of this ability.
- mattcwilson 5y agoThe unegotistical, realistic, quiet, but firm self-confidence you’re describing seems to me to be exactly what the author’s labelling “swagger.” Is this maybe just a terminology quibble? > What is swagger? For me, it's knowing what you're good at and acting accordingly — earned confidence. But it's not arrogance. Your behavior and ability are in lock step. > Be assertive and opinionated even when you aren't as sure. Go back to having strong beliefs. Know your beliefs. Hold onto them. > Don’t be an asshole about it, but push for what you need and don’t give in to every request. Separately, and speaking as a current manager: the last thing I want is for the people on my team to just blithely go along, “just following orders,” if (when, and probably frequently) I’m asking for something shortsighted, ill-considered, or just plain stupid. I crave feedback from the talented experts on my team because it helps make sure we’re not suffering from blind spots, silos, or echo chambers. Like you’re saying: experience has taught me that I always have something to learn.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoYou are correct. I just don't like the term "swagger." Like I said, I really appreciated the article, and its tone. It's just that words matter. In my experience, many folks run with the first dictionary listing, and ignore any nuances. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/swagger https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/swagger I prefer "confidence." https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/confidence https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/confidence And, to your second point, one of the reasons that I was a good manager, was because I actively solicited and valued pushback from my employees. This was seldom a luxury that I was given, by my superiors. And, as a "gentleman of a certain age," I'll lay odds that a big reason for ageism in tech, is because most tech managers don't want to hire people that may have the ability, backbone, and judgment to push back on badly-formed strategies. I managed a "tiger team" of experienced C++ engineers. I had to pay attention to them, and treat them with respect.
- simonbarker87 5y agoThis is something that military officer training (at least in the UK) teaches very well. You may have a degree and have gone to Sandhurst but woe betide any junior office who doesn’t listen to their experienced NCOs.
- SavantIdiot 5y ago> Ego is a mind-killer. It is selling smoke. I think you might be misunderstanding ego. That's like saying, "The engine in your car is bad." It's not good or bad, it's a part of your car. Ego is part of the triad of the Freudian model of the human mind. When people use ego the way you are using it, they are usually referring to a narcissistic personality disorder. Instead, cognitive behavioral therapists will refer to "ego strength". Which is important for healthy functioning. "Ego strength" is what the author is referring to. It is how we act assertively, instead of aggressively (bad) or passive-aggressively (also bad). This is a widespread confusion on HN, people think being assertive is the same as being aggressive, or being a narcissist. A person with low ego strength will act in a passive-aggressive way rather than be forthcoming, they will allow their boundaries to be ignored. Ego strength is how we hang on to ourselves. Ego strength is critical for a mental well-being. That is what this article is about.
- hinkley 5y agoAs I read this I kept finding my mind pulled toward metallurgical concepts. A rigid ego gets people into lots of trouble. They lead people down dark alleyways. They break instead of bend, leaving sharp edges everywhere that hurt everyone around them. Flexible people can either be door stops or assertive, and which they are has to do with how much they think of their own opinions and abilities. Strength doesn't have to mean rigid, and there are multiple neuroses depending on which mix you're discussing. 'Ego-strength' suggests one dimension which IMO simply muddies the waters.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoThe difference is "ego strength" is a real term used by real mental health professionals, and your analogy to metallurgical concepts is something you invented. Ironic, that in a discussion about ego and narcissism you would dismiss medical terms as "muddying the waters" and try to replace them with your own beliefs to benefit your opinion.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> I don't think you understand what ego is. Be kind. I thought we weren't supposed to do this stuff, 'round these parts; but I'm often wrong. Actually, I know about the Freud stuff, and the scientific meaning of "ego." Basically, the meaning that almost no one actually ever attributes to the word. Words tend to adapt to the meaning that is most often applied to them. Dictionary be damned. It's how people actually use the word, that defines it. For example, look up the etymology of "nice." (It made me change "be nice," to "be kind"). > This is a widespread confusion on HN, people think being assertive is the same as being aggressive, or being a narcissist. My take on "the Modern Societal Zeitgeist," so to speak, is that aggressiveness, narcissism, avarice, arrogance, and just plain ol' bein' cruel, are traits to be admired, and emulated; especially amongst the types of people that run businesses. Those of us that speak to being kind, empathetic, or generous, are often attacked, and mocked as being "weak."
- jimbokun 5y ago> In the areas in which I excel, I often exude great confidence, which is sometimes mistaken for arrogance. Isn't that how the article defines swagger?
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoYup. I just don't like the word "swagger," but I dug the tone of the article.