13 ms·
ConstitutionDAO
- Imnimo 5y ago>ConstitutionDAO is seeking an esteemed partner to publicly display the Constitution. The eventual home must have the expertise to properly house, store, and maintain the artifact. Additionally, the community has expressed strong preferences for institutions that are free to the public and willing to cover the costs associated with housing the document. Really putting the cart before the horse on this, aren't we?
- cdot2 5y agoTo be fair I can imagine that a number of museums would jump at the chance to be essentially donated an original copy of the constitution
- Imnimo 5y agoIf they wanted to "essentially donate" it, they could just donate it. And if museums are jumping at the chance, they could have arranged it ahead of time.
- rndmind 5y agothis whole project is organized by a bunch of kids for fun, chill out and relax your butt cheeks dude
- jimkleiber 5y agoI can't speak for other Americans, but as much as I try to see this as "organized by a bunch of kids for fun," I also feel a strong emotional attachment to the Constitution and an original copy of it. So I try to balance that "cool experiment" with "wait, what are they doing with a sacred document?" I say it genuinely, I feel torn by the excitement at the experiment and frustrated/angry at what seems to almost be a parody of the Constitution itself.
- rndmind 5y agoI think of it as a homage to the U.S. constitution actually. I respect your sentiment as it seems we are both coming from the same perspective. I, however, look at this not as a parody, but an incredible tribute and homage o the U.S. constitution.... If it brings attention to the constitution and bill of rights, so much the better. Besides, they will feature it in a public museum ( presumably ) so they will honor it and preserve it.
- jimkleiber 5y agoI guess for me, homage to the document would be people hunkering down to debate philosophies on how to structure governance to balance powers between a lower and higher level. I could see maybe how it was showing more respect for the document, I guess I just wish it went a lot deeper.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoHow does ridiculous bullshit like this get 30mm while other promising projects fail because people don‘t want to pay USD 0,99? Has the entire world succumbed to simply whoever has the better marketing!
- sorethescore 5y agoYes
- wallacoloo 5y ago> Has the entire world succumbed to simply whoever has the better marketing! meme magic. you’re not just advertising. you’re creating culture. the marketing is the product.
- holonomically 5y agoI don't think these people realize the futility of their effort. The US Constitution isn't something to be bought and sold. Assigning a dollar value to it is the literal anti-thesis of everything that is outlined in the document itself.
- KoftaBob 5y ago"For the first time in thirty-three years, one of thirteen surviving copies of the Official Edition from the Constitutional Convention will be publicly auctioned by Sotheby's. It is one of the two copies that are still owned by private collectors. The proceeds from the auction will be given to a charity that has been established by the current owner. ConstitutionDAO is a DAO that is pooling together money to win this auction. We intend to put The Constitution in the hands of The People. " It's a copy of the original.
- holonomically 5y agoI understand what they're doing. The Constitution already belongs to the people, no copies need to be bought or sold for this to be the case. That's what I mean by futility of their effort. Their project betrays a profound misunderstanding of the US Constitution.
- KoftaBob 5y agoYeah in terms of that, it seems like it's hyperbolic metaphor that the crypto community loves to throw around.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- UncleEntity 5y ago> It's a copy of the original. In the same way a Gutenberg Bible is "a copy of the original" I suppose...
- casi18 5y ago
- NickNaraghi 5y agowagmi :)
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoI'm very pro-crypto, and also very pro exploring DAOs as an organizing structure. But this one feels so rushed that I won't be surprised if scandals and controversies follow. A lot has to be done properly here, and there's a lot of places things can go wrong. If the aftermath has problems that are too spectacular, it could cause trouble for more carefully planned efforts.
- cdot2 5y agoI would be surprised if scandals and controversies didnt follow
- nrmitchi 5y agoSo let me get this straight. There is an auction for a priceless (well, very expensive) item. A group is trying to raise funds to buy this item, but is not guaranteed to win the auction anyways. Participating in an auction while having a publicly known funding cap feels like a poor position to be in. Further, let's suppose the group wins the auction, and is now the proud owner of a copy of the Constitution. This entire end goal of this project seems dependent on finding a partner that is willing to cover all the costs associated with storage, display, security, etc of this high value item. This feels like a whole lot of "ifs" for a project trying to collection $20M.
- robodobo 5y ago*for a project that did collect $20M.
- AutumnCurtain 5y ago>Additionally, the community has expressed strong preferences for institutions that are free to the public and willing to cover the costs associated with housing the document. Had to laugh at this. I'd have a strong preference for others subsidizing my questionable decisions too.
- nrmitchi 5y agoI think it's more than that; "preference" aside, if you can't find a partner willing to cover the costs, how will the upkeep costs be paid for? I see 3 options: 1. They are required to raise additional funding for maintenance. I'm not sure I'd bet on them having the same interest in this project in a couple of months 2. The DAO neglects the item, and it gets irrecoverably damaged/destroyed. The ConstituationDAO has now effectively destroyed a copy of the constitution 3. They find themselves in the position of having to firesale the item in a couple of months when they're unable to cover the associated costs. I'll also add that it would be _possible_ for the DAO to have enough funding after purchasing the item to generate income/returns that can cover the associated costs. Given that their funding is public, and will be participating in an auction, I'm not sure I would bet on having a whole of of funds left over.
- barney54 5y agoSo what’s the point? There is a copy of the Constitution that is owned by the American people. It’s on display in the National Archives in Washington, DC. So what’s the point of this DAO?
- laluser 5y agoTo me, it's more about the idea than the actual action on display here. Decentralizing a process than is normally very opaque and centralized is what's being attempted and it's a cool idea. Whether this is executed well or not, that's a different story.
- jimkleiber 5y agoI wonder if one of the main reasons it hasn't been decentralized is because it has been illegal to do so—selling shares/securities to the general public without disclosure of risks and other rules set forth by the SEC. I remember being in the Bay Area back in 2014-16 and people talking about wanting to use Kickstarter and other crowdfunding platforms for not just buying products but owning the company, but kept getting stuck at the accredited investor requirements for private companies. So, I guess I'm curious about this as a referendum on why we have securities laws and accredited investor laws and whether those should change or stay, I just don't think it's necessarily as brand new of an idea as it seems. EDIT: The concept I was talking about is called equity crowdfunding [0] and the SEC opened it up to more people in 2012 [1]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_crowdfunding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_crowdfunding [1]: https://www.sec.gov/divisions/marketreg/tmjobsact-crowdfundingintermediariesfaq.htm https://www.sec.gov/divisions/marketreg/tmjobsact-crowdfundi...
- laluser 5y agoI think these types of decentralized entities will collide with a long list of legal issues in the future. The technology is just moving too quickly for any elected official to understand. Just imagine that instead of buying this copy of the constitution, the resources were anonymously being used in some malicious way and there is no accountability along the way.
- outside1234 5y agoMore Distributed Woo Hoo: https://www.stephendiehl.com/blog/decentralized-woo.html https://www.stephendiehl.com/blog/decentralized-woo.html
- casi18 5y agoshow me how this would have happened without crypto. in less than a week going from being a joke in a group chat to a registered organisation with $25m funding and a clear mission statement to take something from private ownership into public display. people can keep dismissing how strong a coordination and communication tool crypto, is or we can start taking it seriously.
- ains 5y agohttps://www.gofundme.com/ https://www.gofundme.com/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- int_19h 5y agoI don't see how any feature specific to crypto contributed here? The only coordination required is to get the requisite number of people to contribute - and that's a social problem, not a technical one.
- maybenotafart 5y agoI dont get this. Is the constitution an NFT?!?!?! owning the constitution does not need to be a financial transaction, this seems like a scam. we need less money in politics, not more.
- cdot2 5y agoRead the whole thing
- papa-whisky 5y agoIgnoring the questionable end-goal here, the 'crypto' aspect of this is apparently completely orthogonal to the fund-raising effort[1]. What's the point? [1]https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/11/16/constitutiondao-a-20-million-stupid-ethereum-trick/ https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/11/16/constitution...
- pkukkapalli 5y agoThe crypto aspect serves a very important feature, hype. Anything tangential to crypto gets the attention of all of crypto twitter. This would not have nearly as much money in it if not for that hype. One thing I do wonder though: at some point all this ethereum gets converted to dollars in order to buy the constitution. What does this DAO do with any "extra" dollars from the increasing value of ethereum?
- casi18 5y agofrom his blog: >No, the crypto bit absolutely doesn’t do anything useful None of this would have happened without 'the crypto bit'. People are just annoyed that crypto is happening and theyve been betting against it. they were so focused on the 'currency' aspect they missed that groups of people can coordinate, they missed that a reddit group can become a political force, they missed that people are buying land together, the missed that coordination is the killer app. HN and the cynics have been telling us for years that none of this would work, and when we get examples of it working we hear "you could do this without x". yes, in theory you could have a mysql database and a company registered in deleware, and stripe processing payments, and also companies in other countries to handle international payments, and blah blah..... this is faster, easier, and more fun.
- eropple 5y agoWhen you have to ascribe things to "the haters" or "the cynics" to make sense of the world, it's worth taking a step or two back.
- enragedcacti 5y ago> HN and the cynics have been telling us for years that none of this would work, and when we get examples of it working we hear "you could do this without x". yes, in theory you could have a mysql database and a company registered in deleware, and stripe processing payments, and also companies in other countries to handle international payments, and blah blah..... Or just use GoFundMe? I agree that none of this would have happened without the crypto bit, but only for the reason that its a rushed and poorly thought out idea that crypto nerds are latching onto as proof that crypto finally has a high profile use beyond speculation. In reality this solves effectively nothing that centralized systems don't while adding the risk of there being no legal recourse if the team decides not to do what the DAO says.
- ohgodplsno 5y ago> the greatest historical tool for human governance: the U.S. Constitution. shitcoiners are evolving, they now have a sense of humour too
- anonporridge 5y agoInsanely heretical idea. Win the bid, then publicly burn this copy of the Constitution, as an act of sacrifice to imbue it's original rarity into a digital representation (some kind of NFT) that an unbounded number of people can own shares of, thereby transmitting the memetic essence of the object into the hyperverse to be preserved and treasured for trillions of years, long after all physical copies have disintegrated away. Despite being seen as an unconscionable and horrific act of destruction by the citizens of meatspace, it could in reality end up being the most powerful act of preservation we could ever do.
- 2bitencryption 5y agoI think this is what kids these days would call "cursed"
- anonporridge 5y agoblursed
- ericjang 5y agoInteresting idea. But doesn't this rely on public acceptance of the "imbuing of the original object's essence into NFT?" How do you encourage people to associate the act of destruction with an act of value transfer? As a counterexample, an art vandal destroying a piece of art does not inherit the value of the art, even though the vandal and art interact in a culturally significant way such that the art ceases to exist after the interaction.
- anonporridge 5y agoFirst, I think there's a fundamental difference between a vandal destroying something they don't own, and the owner intentionally choosing to destroy it as an act of sacrifice. Having said that, there actually is some power in the self sacrifice of engaging in a destructive act giving a person's message more power and attention (see Unabomber Manifesto as a prime example). Second, at least a subculture of people already do accept destruction of real world things as an act that imbues the a digital entity with the real world scarcity. It's called proof of work, and bitcoin is constantly 'sacrificing' real world energy which imbues the token with value in many people's minds. Enough so make it a trillion dollar asset class.
- rvz 5y agoThey are probably going to win the auction + gas fees included, but they would probably need more money to protect it than just simply 'owning it'. > The eventual home must have the expertise to properly house, store, and maintain the artifact. Additionally, the community has expressed strong preferences for institutions that are free to the public and willing to cover the costs associated with housing the document. The problem with DAOs is 'trust' which they are vulnerable to this trust being abused. Hence, I'm afraid that such 'DAOs' don't have a good history of being trustworthy, especially when there is little to no regulations involved, but we'll see. Maybe to launder the $30M, would be to mint the Constitution as an NFT perhaps?
- V__ 5y ago> Am I receiving ownership of the Constitution in exchange for my donation? > No. You are receiving a governance token, not fractionalized ownership. Governance includes the ability to advise on (for illustrative purposes) where the Constitution should be displayed (...) So some anonymous group is raising money to buy the constitution and in exchange you get voting rights? Which they totally pinky-promise will adhere to. Oh, and it's crypto, so it's a token. This sounds like Victor Lustig selling the eiffel tower but with technology.
- casi18 5y agoNot anonymous, team is very public. because of US law this is the practical way of actually doing it, the alternative seems to be not doing it and thatd be boring. theres been long discussions for days in the discord, if people have suggestions of a better way to do this come join in. people are very open to how else could we do this and how it can be improved and secured. remember this was just a joke in a group chat last week, that speed of development will have issues, but community and reputation matter, and we can lean on that as we solve the legal structure.
- manbart 5y agoOne of the founders is listed as “Jango from the internet”
- shrikant 5y ago...whose Twitter profile indicates that they're a Juicebox dev, i.e. the same service being used to "host" the DAO. I can't put my finger on why exactly, but that seems all manner of shady to me.
- V__ 5y agoThe team may be in the public, but neither on Twitter nor on their website is any imprint or personal information. The proper way to do it, would be to set up a non-profit organization where each funding/paying member gets voting rights (no crypto needed). It's funny as a joke and maybe the intention is good, but in the end this could just as well be a new crypto scam and funding this project is the same as gambling at a casino.
- nonameiguess 5y agoWhy give governance tokens? The second blurb there states they wish to hand it over to some place that can house it open to the public free of charge, but then later state the purpose of giving you a governance token in exchange for contributing to the auction bid pool is you get a say in what will be done with it. It sounds like they've already decided what to do with it. Give it to a public national museum. Reserving the right to take it back and do something else instead doesn't make much sense. I'd rather fund a bid that promises to donate it and relinquish any further rights than get some tradable ownership share I can sell to someone else who decides they want to burn it ten years from now.
- djrogers 5y ago"Will the core team receive any of the raised funds for themselves or get compensated in any way from this? The core team has not received or pre-minted any tokens. Following the purchase of the Constitution, we intend to submit a proposal to be voted on by the community. While this is unusual, we believe that it establishes a precedence of mutual trust between the core team and the backers of the ConstitutionDAO." So anyone who funds this has to trust that a) You are not a dog, b) ConstitutionDAO will use the money to buy the copy of the constitution, c) All extra money will be returned, d) The above mentioned proposal will be in the interests of the community, and e) ConstitutionDOA will abide by the above mentioned vote. Setting all of that aside, what mechanism exists for a "governance token" to actually have any power in this relationship at all?
- meheleventyone 5y agoIt’s a physical thing and a DAO (mostly) isn’t a recognised legal entity so there is always a disconnect here irrespective of the crypto side of things. There’s an awful lot of trust being put into the honesty of the people organising this effort with little ability to hold them to account. Which is par for the course and why rug-pull is a turn of phrase.
- cge 5y agoBeyond this, there doesn't appear to be any explanation of how this works from a legal and tax perspective. There's no mention of a legal entity receiving the funds, but at the same time, they state these are donations, not fractional ownership, so presumably from a legal perspective this is actually just giving the funds to the core team, who appear to be mostly in the US, but not entirely? And, while I had always thought that the point of DAOs was that they were autonomous, this appears to be just giving the core contributors direct control over the money? Surely, for example, the actual bidding is not coded into the contract? So, considering this is now over $25m, wouldn't there be some tax involved if people pay you in this way? Maybe if you argue they are gifts (but are they?), and no individual donation is over $10k, but I suspect many are? And at over $25m, Sotheby's is obviously going to have some ownership identification requirements. So who will actually be the legal owner here, and how will they account for this revenue? Apparently, they're planning on setting up a (for-profit?) LLC? (https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/11/16/constitutiondao-a-20-million-stupid-ethereum-trick/ https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/11/16/constitution...)
- jimkleiber 5y agoI think I'd be a lot more excited about this if they had an innovative governance system underlying the DAO, as a way to talk about the future of governance. Considering the Constitution is a document about governance structure, it surprises and disappoints me that their system of checks and balances seems to be mostly missing, with maybe just a phrase of "pro rata" or whoever has the most tokens gets the most votes. Seems not much different than how most corporation voting works. Just seems like there's an opportunity to more deeply discuss what the future of online and offline governance will be, as geographic governing bodies struggle to deal with digital spaces. But memes seem more cool I guess lol.
- EMM_386 5y ago> We intend to put The Constitution in the hands of The People. Additionally, the community has expressed strong preferences for institutions that are free to the public and willing to cover the costs associated with housing the document. They should lend it to the US Government, it meets all these goals.
- wallacoloo 5y agodoes it? what’s our president’s approval rating again? 41%? American government, while better than what came before it, still isn’t perfect. Crypto and DAOs are experiments in government. The whole point is to (try to) do better than our existing institutions.
- meken 5y agoAs of yesterday, they were only at $5M. To see it jump to $25M today is staggering, and insanely impressive, from a fundraising perspective.
- holonomically 5y agoThat's because the main thought leaders in the crypto community have been pumping marketing material on Twitter, Reddit, and Discord.
- keymone 5y agoonly a tiny fraction of those $ gains can be realized.
- wallacoloo 5y agowhat do you mean? crypto markets are incredibly liquid. $35M eth trade is a drop in the bucket vs the $25B eth that trades daily.
- washedup 5y agoFunds from the winning bid are going directly to charity: https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2021/the-constitution-of-the-united-states-sold-to-benefit-the-dorothy-tapper-goldman-foundation?locale=en https://www.sothebys.com/en/buy/auction/2021/the-constitutio... Very interesting. If Sotheby's accepts the DAO's bid, it will potentially bring much more money to charity than any individual bidder.
- jimkleiber 5y agoI'm confused, if an individual bidder bids more than the DAO, wouldn't that bring more to charity than the DAO? Perhaps the argument is that the DAO is raising hype and therefore raising the price for the winning bid and the hype itself will increase the total going to charity, I just don't see how the DAO would necessarily be giving more to charity than an individual if the individual had a higher bid.
- enragedcacti 5y agoI don't understand. Are you just "John Madden"ing that if the DAO wins the auction then they will be the ones that bid the most?
- washedup 5y agoThe highest bidder wins the auction, according to Sotheby's rules. The DAO has already has more than the estimated bidding range and has a good chance of beating all other bids. We will find out tomorrow.
- m8s 5y agoSo what happens if they lose the auction?
- holonomically 5y agoThe money is returned back to the donors (modulo gas fees which is currently at $100-$200 range [1]). 1: https://crypto.com/defi/dashboard/gas-fees https://crypto.com/defi/dashboard/gas-fees
- miguelmota 5y agoThis is an interesting experiment that I'm excited about. The fact that a financial flash mob is possible is incredible. Anybody from anywhere can participate and have voting power by joining the DAO. Regardless of the outcome, it's good to see the convergence of DAOs into meatspace.
- keymone 5y agoexcept of course there is literally zero voting power from participating in this project because the "power" bit is always assigned by a source of authority and nothing about this project tells you how can this power be realized or enforced.
- jimkleiber 5y agoWell, I think they've been saying that the tokens guarantee voting power to advise the LLC which actually owns the physical document, not to actually own the document, because, as someone else mentioned, that may run afoul of US securities laws. I say all this being excited about iterating on the future of governance, I also worry that such quick financial flash mobs could really screw people really fast.
- snewman 5y agoAs usual, Matt Levine has the best take (https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-11-16/jpmorgan-fights-tesla-over-warrants https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-11-16/jpmorg...): > Ben Thompson points out that this is all pretty approximate; ConstitutionDAO will not give its token holders fractionalized ownership of the Constitution... > Also, not to be like this, but there is an original copy of the Constitution on permanent display at the National Archives; it is already “in the hands of the people,” in the sense that (1) it is owned by the U.S. government and (2) the U.S. government is, when you think about it, sort of a decentralized autonomous organization made up of the citizens of the U.S.? The citizens can kind of tell the government what to do? By voting? When you think about it? I don’t know. I’m sure that in five years ConstitutionDAO token holders will vote to change the Second Amendment to say “putting laser implants in your eyes is now mandatory” and somehow that will have the force of law.
- root_axis 5y agoHmm, "government" as a governance model? This has some serious potential.
- warkdarrior 5y agoThe best government (crypto)money can buy.
- wellthisisgreat 5y agoIsn’t it obvious that this is a memeing initiative that ran wild?
- keymone 5y agothere's this saying, something about fools, money and parting.
- kall 5y agoI have read approximately 100 times that this is a grand, endlessly interesting experiment and whatever happens it will be a new era for crypto. OK, sounds kind of cool but what is the hypothesis, or the interesting thing, or the thing that will change? Only things I can think of are meta-crypto stuff, like that crypto hype can hype better than any other hype, that seems clear since Dogecoin. Or maybe how good/fast communities can coordinate using current web2 tooling, which is neat, sure. The speed and scale do feel interesting, but I don‘t really know why. Anyway seems harmless and very fun for everyone involved.
- root_axis 5y agoThis is a great example of the power of crypto. Millions of dollars raised in record time, meanwhile the marks have been fooled into thinking their tokens are actually meaningful while the masterminds of the scam have legal control of the document in question and are free to completely ignore any of the "voting" that goes on since blockchains do not exist in meatspace and mean literally nothing with respect to legal ownership of the document. This kind of thing simply wouldn't be possible without the web3 revolution, this is really exciting stuff!
- ChrisArchitect 5y ago"from a joke last friday to this" ..... all of this stuff is treated like a game. Everything is not a game. The attitude behind all of these stunts and NFTs and everything is fucking ridiculous and points to so much wrong behind the scenes it's unnerving
- robodobo 5y agowgbtc
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI was initially excited because I think that a DAO for the collaborative generation of, commitment to, and maintenance of constitutions would be a really cool thing. You could cultivate reputation as a mediator, or as the champion of a group with ideological stake in the document, or as an editor. We could explore the space of amendment rules and figure out what practices work and which devolve into flame wars. That's not this. This is dumb.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sergiomattei 5y agoThe level of negativity here to what's clearly harmless fun seriously baffles me. It's a fundraiser to buy the Constitution. It happens to be raising funds through Ethereum. I'm unsure why this happens to make so many on here mad.