3 ms·
> Imagine if they had done this a few years ago, and the micro-B connector was mandated. We would never have gotten usb-C. But they didn't. These people aren't
by Jensson 5y ago
> Imagine if they had done this a few years ago, and the micro-B connector was mandated. We would never have gotten usb-C.
But they didn't. These people aren't that dumb, they told companies to settle on a standard, and now that we have a good standard that basically everyone follows they want to make a law to ensure everybody follows it. Bringing up a scenario where they did the right thing and argue "just imagine if they didn't do the right thing here, that would be a problem!" isn't a strong argument.
- cortesoft 5y agoIt is the standard now, but should it be the standard forever? What happens when we want better features as new tech is invented?
- chii 5y ago> What happens when we want better features as new tech is invented? The new tech would prove itself, somehow, and then the standard changed over after there's evidence that the new tech improves more than the cost of the change!
- cortesoft 5y agoHow would a new tech prove itself if manufacturers aren’t allowed to use it in their product? If customers aren’t allowed to try something new, they are never going to be able to determine if customers prefer it. The only way to ‘prove’ that a tech is better than another is by letting the market decide.
- samus 5y agoDropping a Memorandum of Understanding is almost for free. Putting a law out of commission (pun not intended) is a completely different story!
- taxyz23 5y agoIf basically everyone follows, then why require it and shut off or slow down future innovation? Regulations like this are nearly always obsolete by the time they are implemented.
- Jensson 5y ago> If basically everyone follows, then why require it and shut off or slow down future innovation? Regulations like this are nearly always obsolete by the time they are implemented. Apple doesn't follow it. Also the reason companies settled was that EU threated them with regulations, if they didn't follow through when some companies (Apple) misbehaves it would mean that such threats would lose teeth and wont solve future problems. So if anything the problem here isn't EU, the reason that law is coming is Apple. Best possible scenario is that companies dynamically create new standards and fall inline, but Apple refuses to play along so regulations are necessary.
- kergonath 5y ago> Apple doesn't follow it. They did follow it. The initial agreement was about chargers, not cables, and you can charge any iPhone off any usb charger. Now, we can discuss the spirit versus the letter, but they signed the agreement and followed it.